New American Restaurants in Gettysburg, PA

“Gettysburg was our last stop on our 2 week summer road trip. We’ve eaten at restaurants with 5 star reviews on our trip but honestly the food we ordered and took back to our room from here was some of the best. The burger was thick and cooked perfectly! Fish tacos great flavor and my son loved his wings. Wait staff was very helpful and packed my to-go great with all the fixings.“

“My wife and I went on our first date since we started our relationship 6 years ago my sister recommended this place and when we got there we were welcomed politely the waiter was amazing and friendly the two burgers of the day is what my wife and I received. We got a amaretto sour and honestly this is one of the best overall experiences I have ever had the food the people everything was amazing and this really did make my day so thank you very much for the hospitality and amazing burgers“

“A great little place to get out of the heat and have a great bite to eat. It’s so hot out today and the cold Club Sandwich was perfect! Sierra our server was prompt and kept checking back on the 3 of us, our granddaughter said her sandwich was delicious and my husband had the cheesesteak and pasta salad. The restaurant is really clean and sporty with baseball memories. Absolutely recommend it!“

“This was my second time dining there and food is fresh and tastes excellent“

“We were visiting Gettysburg and decided to check out Mason Dixon for brunch on Sunday. Our crew had the most amazing breakfast. We had beignets and then eggs Benedict with pulled pork. It was nothing short of fantastic!! Emily was a fantastic waitress and took amazing care of us. Meeting with the owner was an extra touch with great customer service. He was taking time to greet almost every group that came in to eat. Highly recommend coming to enjoy all that they have to offer with great food, drinks and beautiful atmosphere. We will be back again for sure.“

“Finally tried today and just wow! Best lasagna I have had since moving to PA 5 years ago from NJ. Staff is very friendly. Will definitely be going back!“

“In from out of state and just happened upon this fine little “dive bar”. The bartender was amazing, the food was ridiculously fantastic! If we’re ever back on this area, we will surely stop back!“

“Wonderful staff and owner. And how could you not like the name of the restaurant!“

“My bartender was Bailee she was very friendly and courteous. She kept my drinks flowing and continued to check in with me.“

“Service was a little slow, but it was a Saturday. Food was good, and staff was very friendly.“

“I have gone to Hoof, Fin & Fowl twice now in 2 months and both meals have been perfect! Portions, taste, plating, selections they are on point. I have had the crab stuffed jumbo shrimp and Marry Me Chicken, as well as the crab dip appetizer. I highly recommend them!“