21 Best American Restaurants near Grove City

“Came in thirty min to close. Chicken sandwich was tasty, baked potato seemed microwaved, but still good. Server/bartender could’ve came around a turn or two instead of us having to go to bar to ask for something. She liked her tenders too. Nice they didn’t make us feel rushed. Laid back atmosphere. Comfortable low lighting and comfortable booths. Pickle spears were tasty too! Huge and hot. $35 for two of us. No beers.“

“We did lunch here, three generations. An author, an artist and a soccer player enjoyed a friendly server and great food. Big burgers and loved the smashed potato.“

“Great food. Salad bar was fun (Canadian here: I don't think I've seen a salad bar in 25 years... it was fun making my own). Salad bar had lots of topping options. Buffalo Chicken Wrap was excellent.

Vegetarian options: Salad bar is nice option, either as a meal or add-on for your meal (instead of side)“

“We chose to eat here for lunch for my husband’s birthday at 11:30 on a Sunday, with a party of 11. We knew this was a large ask! The hostesses were wonderful and quickly got us a table all together even though we said separate tables close to each other would be fine! The food came out in a timely manner and was all delicious. Even my picky eater nearly cleared her plate! Everyone was incredibly kind and patient. They were also very helpful with my nephew’s dairy allergy. We live near Pittsburgh and would (and will) happily take the hour drive to enjoy this place again!“

“Jean's Super Subs is Grove City's premier sub shop. They have been in business for over 50 years... and for good reason. The food is good, fresh, and reasonably priced. The staff is friendly but fast. They hand slice each meat per order, add fresh baked bread, veggies and sauces. They also offer meatballs and hot dogs, and cold salads like macaroni salad.

The inside has not changed over the years so be prepared to step back in time a bit. There are several stand alone tables and chairs inside. This consistency in both food, staff and decor brings back cherished memories of their long standing customers. There's a reason we all keep coming back.“

“Amazing food & great service.“

“Had a great steak at the restaurant and just based on the steak, it would receive 5 stars. The steak was tender and cooked perfectly to order. The potato was good as well. The reason for the 4 stars is the soup and salad bar, which offers lower end fare from the food supplier. I worked for a food supplier and can always tell when restaurants choose to serve the lower priced options. I understand the reasons for cost cutting, but it definitely brings the dining experience down a notch.
That being said, it was still a very enjoyable dinner, and the steak made up for any shortcomings of the salad bar. Would recommend this place to anyone wanting a good steak at a fair price.“

“This is a great off the road stop. Got the prime rib it was a bit fatty, but wow was it good. Cooked perfectly. Potatoes were very good. Will definitely be back. Service was outstanding. Came a little after 4 no wait. Great atmosphere.“

“We haven’t been to Rachael’s in awhile Amy was such a great Waitress (32years). We went for my wife’s Birthday. We both got the 8oz. Sirloin Steak with 6 beautiful Shrimp! Wow! The Chef prepared everything to perfection! We brought half of it home and had it with our eggs for breakfast. We highly recommend Rachael’s. I was shocked to find out that John McKinley passed away last August. I did flooring for Marett’s for 32 years and worked in all of his restaurants and his home he was always kind to us and we became friends. What an excellent group of Restaurants. Thank you all.“

“A cozy atmosphere with an extensive menu. Our meals were hot and delicious with generous portions. Friendly staff. Just minutes from the outlets.“

“If you're looking for a fantastic spot to enjoy delicious homemade food, this place is a gem! Every meal we've had has been nothing short of excellent, leaving us eager for our next visit. And don't forget to save room for their incredible desserts – they're a must-try! The staff here truly shines with their politeness and attentiveness, making your dining experience even more enjoyable.“

“Thank you Donna and great group at Rudy’s for making the Mercer class reunion such a success. Great food, accommodations and service for a large group👌“

“40+ year customer, my grand children grew up on cinnamon rolls. Friendly, delicious, and fast.“

“Our waiter Andy, our food and the dog friendly patio were perfect ☺️!!!! Can't wait to come back!“

“was surprised they were open, sadly most are closed due to covid, we use to there 4 to 5 times a week along the whole east coast, only 1 I seen open in a year !! Thanks for staying open, always love their food !!“

“Great food! Great atmosphere! The sweetest staff! ♥️“

“Very good bar food. Always FANTASTIC service and a great atmosphere. my family and I moved to Slippery Rock one year ago. Ginger Hill is our favorite local restaurant. Awesome beer specials too.

Kid-friendliness: For this being a bar/restaurant I have no hesitation taking my kids here before 9 p.m. Aged 3 and 14.“

“My wife's high school class just had a reunion lunch there earlier today and it was excellent!! The food and the venue (their indoor/outdoor room) were excellent but the service was outstanding - Thank you Tara and Katie for making it so enjoyable!“

“We ate here on a Sunday afternoon and the place was moderately busy. We were seated immediately and served our drinks. I had the stromboli and my spouse ordered the Chicken Marsala. The orders came out quickly and if I was only rating the stromboli, it would be 5 stars. The stromboli was very good with a great balance of fillings and very good marinara on the side.
The Chicken Marsala on the other hand was a big disappointment. It was ordered with asparagus, and the asparagus was terrible. The stalks were whole with the inedible ends of the stalks not removed. The asparagus spears were also super thin, much less than pencil thin. It was also undercooked and had to be returned to the kitchen. I love asparagus, but this serving was not at all appealing.
The chicken was ok, but the sauce contained only a few small pieces of mushroom. The chicken was served over mashed potatoes, which were ok, but again, nothing special.
I paid $29.00 for the Chicken Marsala, and I wouldn't order it again if it was half that price. Very disappointing.
Service was good and it is a nice place, but we left feeling that there are much better options for the money. The stromboli seemed reasonable.“

“Parking: Large free parking lot

Kid-friendliness: Child meals and juice bars available. Corn hole game available for kids

Wheelchair accessibility: Low wide ramp accessible to handicap parking close to building.“

“Very disappointed. I'm there every Saturday with my sister who is challenged & has dementia. Just because I took her to the ladies room before paying the bill . ( all my belongings purse, phone etc left at table) a comment was made about walking out and not paying the bill. I watched a waitress (from the door of the hallway to the bathrooms) walk over to the booth and see my purse & still make a comment. No apologies when I said something. She walked away and nobody else said anything. Very rude of them. Other than that the food & my waitress was great. (God has put it in my heart to forgive. I forgive & may God Bless you all )“