25 Best Italian Restaurants near Hallam

“I’ll admit the food takes a little while to come out but that’s kind of the charm of the place. I love it. In my opinion Touch of Italy is better than Jim and nenas in terms of pizza. Great place to hang out for a while and have some great food.“

“Where do I begin... lord have mercy this place was AMAZING!!!!!! GILLIAN our waitress was AMAZING!!! the food was AMAZING!!!! It was just such an incredible experience. I've been to some "fancy" restaurants and this hidden gem blew our minds. I recommend this restaurant 100000%.“

“Ordered for pickup tonight. First time customer. We moved to Salunga two years ago and usually order from same nearby places. We lately have not been happy with either of those. So found DiMarias is close enough. Soooo glad we did!! We have been missing out!!! After my breaded chicken hoagie tonight and my families meals they enjoyed we are Sold!! My hoagie was on freshly baked bread , thin chicken cutlet, tomato, lettuce( pickles I asked for) salt, pepper , oregano and oil. Everything was fresh and filling !!!! When I called the guy who answered was very nice !!! And my fiancee said he was greeted nicely by owner when he picked up our delivery. So good I'm making a til Tok review video !!!!! Follow Kristy Sue Ortman . :)“

“The portions are extra ordinarily generous! I would say 3 TIMES Greater than anything at APPLEBEE'S. Maddy my server is very kind hearted, beautiful, and even put 3 cherries? on top of my whipped cream tapioca!Shown is half my order I'm taking out.Bill Ross, President & CEO of Safe Instruction, LLC.“

“I’m not from the area and in on my way from the airport. When I received my order, it didn’t contain one of my sandwiches but that was quickly resolved. The cheesesteak was okay, but the baked ziti is fantastic! I’ll stop by the next time I’m in the area for sure.“

“I’m only rating the food because that’s all that matters if you’re eating here. You’ll quickly forget about everything if you order a sub here. The pizza is pretty good. The subs are absolutely wonderful. The bread just makes it. Then could put grass clippings in a sub role with mayonnaise and it would be better than anyone else’s subs I’ve ever had. Chicken cheesesteak sub is my go to meal. I’ve had hundreds and it will continue to be my go to meal. Keep it up, never change.“

“Vegetarian options: They were so kind. Had an issue with the app I ordered on and they were more then helpful explaining things. The food was so fresh everything was amazing!This was our first time but absolutely will be back. Way better than jojos lol“

“Always love this restaurant, excellent homemade, quality food. Great service every time. It's so nice to go to a restaurant that is not a chain and have excellent food consistently. I love that they have freezer food you may purchase for food prep in a pinch .“

“Holy smokes this place is amazing!!! First time here and it didn't disappoint! The staff is super attentive and polite and the home made bread....WOW !!!I ordered the ham boat and fries...the sub was neatly made and full of meat and toasted to perfection.The fries were the best I've ever had at a sub shop.Other places need to take step their game WAY up after eating here. Fabulous.“

“Open spaces. Table seating. Private booths. I was a little shocked by the size of the room tbh.Absolutely authentic cuisine. My order was a to-go burrito w/guac no sour cream. Great hospitality, compassion, leadership-suited deck come meet the aces!I offer up Juarez, MX (founding of the burrito) better have a check-in because this cuisine’s got something that might have a person reconsider their definition of burrito. Go strong! Stay long! I know their bar serves nicely so bring your friends! Muchas gracias! Gratzie!:) Salud.“

“Came here for dinner with my daughter and she made an instant friend with the owners daughter. In addition to that, the food was DELICIOUS! Especially the cheese fries! This is close to my house and we’ve been looking for a good pizza spot that was local. We definitely will be coming back and spreading the word!“

“Good italian restraunt really good food and large variety of good choicesParking: Large open parking lot in front of restrauntKid-friendliness: Staff was truly friendly and made me feel like family goid price of food n very talkative n attentive to customers and food made fresh n truly caring staff of there customers needsWheelchair accessibility: The parking lot is flat n the restraunt has wheel chair accessibility no issue for disabled customers to come out to eat they have plenty of room n can acomidate there needs no problem“

“Service was top notch and even tho they were busy, we were well taken care of! Caesar salad was really good had an interesting take on the dressing. I can’t figure out what made it special but it sure was yummy. Pepperoni/sausage pizza was wood fired and yummy!!!! Ended with a slice of creamy Tiramisu !!! SO GOOD!!!!! Definitely coming back! Worth an 1 1/2 hour drive!“

“Amazing family. They remember faces when you come in often enough. Treats everyone like family. They pour their love into their food which always comes out amazing. Andrew and Anna are the greatest around. Their service is phenomenal and they always rise above my expectation. There's always good vibes when me and my fiancé walk in and we're always happy to see them. we practically consider them as family because they always help us out.“

“Moving to Wrightsville next month. Stopped in, they have PIZZA BY THE SLICE! pizza tasted great, thinner style almost like beach pizza. Nice people, they had just pulled out fresh bread in the racks. This is my new pizza spot!The review below is off base, my slices looked like his and they rocked!“

“Grab takeout from here all the time! Good food that's worth the price!Parking: A small parking lot that fills up quickly, but usually has spots available.Wheelchair accessibility: They have a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking spots.“

“Just moved to the town and I found this little hidden gem they make their own bread which is always a plus and they got good combo specials that they run all day long and you get a free drink with every combo purchased so that’s a win-win and they deliver“

“The staff are very pleasnt every time I go here. I'd have to recommend the wings and cheeseburger sub. The other food does look delicious but I've religously only been here for lunch time. I hear great things about the rest of the menu and most definetly need to try other stuff !!!“

“First time ordering. Ordered the lg thick square pizza, crust light & airy not like regular heavy pizza dough. Sauce not over powering. Lg Special Calzone delish. Everyone enjoyed their dinner & asked for the directions to Vecchia Sicila Pizza Shop! (LOL, no senior discount) #21“

“Returned to our old haunts and ordered. a long time favorite: "ham boats" plus a margarita pizza. Ham boats were delicious... a simple sub sandwich (see my photo) with ham & cheese, and a few "Fixin's, slightly toasted....yum. Pizza was just OK. Crust was crispy but really lacked any distinctive flavor....sauce was same. Toppings were fair. (You can kinda "see" what I mean in my photo). Filling. Next time will probably just stick to the ham boats... Always a winner.“

“My partner got the best Bolognese he says he's ever had, and my Pumpkin fettuccine(sans sage) was extraordinary. Our server recommended a great wine and we finished with panna cotta for dessert. Really a stellar experience and I Highly recommend.“

“I've been coming here for years and the owner and I have been friends since high school! The food, drink menu, and atmosphere are superb! I usually get the Italian Stromboli and my husband loves their cheeseburger sub. I've had lots the other items on the menu and you can't go wrong! Friendly service, clean bathrooms, this is a 5 star experience! Thanks Vinny and the rest of the crew at Golden Crust! You guys rock!❤️“

“I'm extremely lucky to live in the apartment building right beside this place so I've tried a lot of their menu. Great food, always with very friendly service. I tried the cheese supreme on a whim and... Y'know that pizza in A Goofy Movie (or maybe the sequel) that is so ooey-gooey with cheese and just looks so perfect that you know it couldn't possibly exist in real life? That's what their cheese supreme is like. Also try the baklava.“

“Yum! Visiting town for business and had to try this. Very good. Quality of food is excellent! Variety of pizza hot and fresh. They’ll make one if they don’t already have the variety. Bread sticks are delicious, everything was! Customer Service was top notch, all employees friendly and smiling. Troy was very friendly and informative when I checked in for a table. Price was a value. Would visit again when in the area. Give it a try you’ll be glad you did!Kid-friendliness: There were many kids here. Very kid friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: Open spaces between tables.“

“To start, they were very polite on the phone, and made sure to repeat the order back to ensure it was correct.I was greeted with smiles and a very positive attitude as soon as I walked in, which not many places seem to do anymore. Both ladies working there made it an awesome experience.I ordered a large pepperoni, a California cheese steak and a order of fries. Everything was very well made, exactly how I wanted it. The pizza had great flavor and they weren't stingy with the pepperoni. The fries were crispy and plentiful. My sub was above average but not the best I've ever had, the lettuce tasted a little old and it could have used some more meat, but nonetheless it was good.I would recommend Marcello's over any other pizza shop in York.“