21 Best American Restaurants in Hershey

“It’s been a long time since I can give a raving review on a local restaurant. The Mill did not disappoint. It was clean the drinks were strong and the food was delicious. Highly recommend to anybody looking for a great dining experience!“

“Very nice and comfortable place to dine at. Great food and great service.“

“We ate here yesterday and absolutely enjoyed our meal which we will give 6 stars! The bonus star is for our server Dawne W - who is absolutely amazing and a doll to be around. We’ve been to your establishment a total of 3 times and she remembered us & what we normally order too!! We will definitely be back!“

“The hotel manager at Hampton Inn recommended "What IF" for dinner. He was spot on. Excellent service and our table just off the end of the bar provided a quiet place to enjoy an excellent meal.“

“The goat cheese & artichoke poppers were the first truly unique taste I have experienced in years. Our waitress Wendy was very thoughtful and proactive in helping my wife navigate the menu with her food allergies. The burger meat is a combination of brisket, chuck, and sirloin. I am a very picky burger eater and even grow my own grass fed grass finished meat so when I say their burger is amazing, their burger is AMAZING. 11/10, cannot recommend enough. We will be back!!“

“Stopped in because Tröegs was way too crowded. Food was great, beer was even better and I can’t say enough about the service. The bartender was incredibly knowledgeable and super friendly. I have never had better service! Crowd at the bar was great too. Highly recommend!“

“It is always full of happy memories at the Hotel. Our family has enjoyed the hotel since I was a child. The staff is awesome, friendly & happy. Thanks for a great memories in our family. Jeri & Jeffrey“

“I’ve been a HUGE fan of I&E for a while (their soups are INCREDIBLE) but now I have to eat Gluten Free. Today was my first time having their GF Grilled Cheese and it was AMAZING!!! I’m so excited to still be able to eat at my favorite lunch spot!“

“We had their new coconut chicken salad. This was the best coconut chicken I have ever had and trust me I have had alot. There were large portions of chicken on a spring mix with with braised peaches and watermelon. The combination was amazing. My son had the duck wings and he couldn't stop talking about how great they were. This is probably only place around here that has duck wings. Next time you are in the Hershey area make it a point to stop there. You will be glad you did. BTW the drinks are just as amazing.“

“Nice atmosphere . Good food .“

“I love the crab fries they are the best ever if a little spicy for some of the kids. I really wish they would bring back the bacon and blue burger that they used to have because I would get that all the time. I like the fact that there is a refill station nearby so I can have one person get a drink while I'm waiting in line.“

“The food is meh, nothing to write home about. Definitely simple fried foods with a few other options added. They were under construction when we went so I can't say the atmosphere was great or horrible. The service, I had 2 experiences. The first experience was great our server was friendly and came to the table at the most opportune moments so she was never interrupting us or asking how things were when our mouths were full. She did have a few foul balls thrown at her that I saw, one group of people kept adding more tables to theirs so she went from having 4 people at the table (when we walked in) to having 10 people at the table when we left. Then she had another group of 5 that had been set in someone else's section moved into her section. I believe this might have rightfully annoyed another server because I saw the other server give her some attitude. But she handled everything with a smile on her face and complete grace. The second time we went in the server gave off vibes that we were just a bother, she disappeared at the end when we wanted to pay (she disappeared into the kitchen and I know because we were sat right next to the door for the kitchen). They are the second cheapest restaurant at the lodge and I hope when the construction is done they will get things settled and it will be better.“

“The good and the bad- I love the atmosphere. Really cool old brick building hidden off chocolate Ave. decor was nice and booths are comfy! We ate on the indoor/outdoor patio. It was really nice. I ordered the hot honey salmon which was delicious (at $30 I am glad of it). Really nicely plated and delicious! The raspberry lemon dessert was also so yummy! My husband ordered the cheesesteak which unfortunately came out cold. I would say the main negative of our experience was the service — it was such a disappointment. For the cost of a meal my expectations of service were admittedly high, it’s not a diner so things like removing dirty plates, refilling waters, responding to requests in a timely manner, being able to answer menu questions, etc — none of that was part of our experience. It’s a shame because service is an important part of eating out, and I’m not sure the cost here is worth the risk of the poor service.“

“I love fresh warm tasty donuts. I can’t go back to my normal donuts 🍩 anymore.“

“Went on march 1 for my daughter’s birthday. It was our first time there. Got an all chocolate cake. It was absolutely delicious!! All of their cakes and cupcakes in the display were beautifully designed“

“Atmosphere, beers, food, and service are all very good. We had the brisket sandwich and chilli.the sandwich was very dry, but nothing a packet of BBQ sauce couldn't fix. The chilli was surprisingly good and we definitely recommend it. Next time we're ordering two of those.“

“Great place! Love the OG onion rings!“

“Took our kids (15 and 12). Small but welcoming place. Wings were so good, cheesesteak and burgers delicious too! Food came out fast and hot. Our waiter was friendly and attentive. We will definitely come again.“

“Took our kids to the water park, got to stay close to water works, great for kids“

“My daughter is the most picky hot chocolate drinker I've ever met, and she does not like it too chocolaty (go figure) or too hot. I ordered a kid's hot chocolate, with a little less chocolate than normal and it was awarded the title of "best hot chocolate ever," by my 7 year old. I also really liked my caramel apple cider, so I guess we have a new favorite coffee shop now 😆“

“Took our kids to the water park, got to stay close to water works, great for kids“