38 Best American Restaurants near New Cumberland

“was at nicks tonight. kudos to the cooks. our meals were really good. The only thing that was disappointing was our waitress. she was sitting at the bar with a customer and we were looking for her to serve us some more drinks. service used to be tip top. we will come back for the food, not so much the service.“

“is never or didn't even know it existed went for the first time yesterday Sunday March the 15th 2026 thought it was a really cool place five pool tables foosball jukebox couldn't ask for much more. good beer good food“

“Everything I have ordered has been delicious! Staff are always very friendly!“

“good stuff, highly recommend!“

“Wanted a place to go with friends before a movie at the theater nearby…stumbled onto Fratelli’s…so glad that we did. Food was fresh and delicious. Homemade dough for the pizza and Stromboli. Apps were awesome…we had the pretzels and the cheesesteak egg rolls. My friend had wings and said they were good as well. Everything was reasonably priced and the service was impeccable. Definitely recommend that you check it out. They have Italian entrees and a dining room as well (that I believe is open on the weekends) and I can only imagine that the entrees would be just as good. We are certainly planning on checking out this little diamond in the rough again.“

“We came here for dinner after a tournament my daughter had today. Food was so so good . We had a brisket wood fire pizza , salad and my daughter had a chicken sandwich. We were waited on by Betsy . So nice and super helpful when it came to helping us pick from their menu / beer selection since it was our first time here . Would definitely recommend!“

“Great place.Food was delicious.We were a group of 11.A variety of dishes was ordered.All enjoyed their choises.The red house wine was v.good.I am a NewYorker, this Pennsylvania restaurant beats many so called and well reviewed NYC restaurants. It is a genuinely a solid eating establishment.Service was perfect and elegant. I very much enjoyed the soup; mushrooms bisque.Delicious.We were on the way to Dickinson's graduation for our grandson.Wonderful stop for dinner!!!!! May 16th 2026.Anna(grandma).“

“We were invited to the friends and family breakfast the day before opening. We were all absolutely floored by this place and have already made a new tradition to come every sunday! The wait staff and INCREDIBLE, they are so sweet and so speedy! They were so considerate, turned the fire place off for us, and talked with our kids. The restaurant is clean, calm, almost beachy feeling. The most important...the food was absolutely amazing AND at an incredible price. The portions are large and VERY affordable, while looking and tasting like high end breakfast. This place makes you feel rich, and will thankfully not give your bank account the bill.“

“I tried the chicken and French toast, and it was absolutely delicious. The atmosphere has a timeless charm that makes the experience even better.“

“Ate dinner there about a week ago. Food was good but their telephone rang at top volume the entire time we were there making it difficult to talk or enjoy our meal. Complained to waitress who said it had to be that way so they could hear in the back for take out orders. The restaurant was far from busy for in house dining so I guess the owner doesn't care about us; only the take out customers! I have eaten here for years and tried to support them during covid but never again.“

“Food is great, service great and everyone is so personable! Now becoming our favorite place?“

“Black n Bleu is how a restaurant's supposed to be: staff are friendly, welcoming, and well-trained on the menu and how to sell it; atmosphere is warm, clean, and curated, with surreal pop art and almost all booths; food and drink are inspired, house-made, and cohesive. We had the dry-rubbed short ribs served with an awesome mac & cheese and sugar-snap peas, the steak and calamari salad, a coffee, and a creme brulee. I already know next time I'm in I'll be trying the Creole Grouper pasta. If you're in the area, skip the national slop stops and give this place a try.“

“We go to eat breakfast at Tito’s almost every Saturday morning. The service is good and the food is always hot and delicious. The owner is very cordial and always makes you feel welcome.“

“I’m not sure how we have never heard of CSG. But I’m happy we stumbled upon CSG! For once I’m happy I came to my girls basketball practice! We decided to try this place (thanks coach) this is better than all the places Near me lol I’ll definitely drive the extra 30 minutes for the amazing food, good service, and 27 Pepsi’s! 😂 WE WILL BE BACK! See ya real soon!“

“We always enjoy coming to Summit, especially for breakfast. Good food and great service!“

“If you are looking for fresh made to order delicious food, this is your place. It is not your typical restaurant. You place your order at the counter and pay, then it is delivered to your table.“

“Constantine is a good friend of mine very in fighting place to hang out or have a party!“

“We enjoyed the casual atmosphere yet sophisticated menu and food selections. We tried different items during 3 visits - swordfish, scallops and seafood special. All were delicious! We also had mussels in beer broth and chicken flatbread - both excellent choices for appetizers or light meal. Staff is friendly and professional. Would definitely make it a stop on our next trip to the Harrisburg PA area.“

“Great food, drinks and entertainment.“

“This is a quaint cozy restaurant with homemade from scratch food. Everything we’ve had has been extraordinary! Staff and owners are so nice! Highly recommend!“

“good food, amazing service, thank you for being open on Christmas day ,“

“Went there for our son’s engagement party with her family, amazing experience and night. Thank you Nick!“

“My man and I tried the Valentine's special -- Surf and Turf loaded potato. 10/10!!“

“Finally made it in here and so glad we did!! Don't get my Long Island Ice Tea done correctly but they got it spot on!! The food was absolutely delicious and the service and atmosphere was exceptional!! Check this place out when you can cause you won't be disappointed!!!“

“Don’t leave review very often but they deserve 100 stars! We were traveling and in a hurry. Ordered a to go smash burger and onion rings. Perfect, sweet service and excellent food!! 100% will be back!!“

“Best place ever!! Food was great so was the staff.“

“Fun local restaurant with great food, personable staff, and a beautiful deck for the summer!“

“Fantastic place, great food and service.“

“Juicy medium rare burger was absolutely perfect. Waitress was spot on with my refills as I needed. Her name is Madigan,if you want good service ask for her. Caddyshack is a great restaurant and the food is always delicious. Even if you don't play the course,consider the restaurant for a great lunch or dinner“

“Went today on an impromptu date with hubby. Got there about 5:30. Only a few cars in the parking lot. Walked in and was immediately greeted with a smile and taken to a booth at our request. Can't remember the hostesses name but she had long braids with red I believe, very kind.

Was taken to our booth and after a few months were greeted by our server Isaac. Isaac was very kind and attentive despite being the only server for majority of the restaurant. Was it the fastest dinner we had, no but did he constantly give us an update or check in when passing our table, absolutely. Admittedly my husband and I are very forgiving of servers in general but especially those working hard which Isaac definitely was. We both ordered entrees and did the garden bar add on. The garden bar was fully stocked, clean and everything very fresh. It was so good I didn't touch my dinner and just enjoyed 2 salads and brought my meal home. My husband did the same. My strawberry lemonade was lovely and my husband's blue raspberry sprite was good as well. The drinks being $5 a piece was rude lol but good nonetheless. We forgot to take pictures of our meals but they came out looking good. I got the steak and ribs with mashed potatoes and he got the French onion burger with tots. We did get a picture of dessert which was a brownie sundae. We never order dessert but man are we glad we did. The brownie was warm and rich and went well with the vanilla ice cream. That was $10 but well worth it and plenty for two adults to share. If you're in a rush for a super fast meal this may not have been the place for you. But if you want a clean atmosphere, kind staff and delicious food then I couldn't recommend it more! We will definitely be back and will ask for Isaac for sure!

Update! Had the ribs at home.... FALL OFF THE BONE! (Throws glasses) TENDERNISM!!!🤣“

“Gilligans in Colonial Park has the Best Real crab cakes. I had a Christmas lunch with a friend. I enjoyed my food so much that two days later, I called and ordered a to go crab cake dinner lol. Service and atmosphere also great.“

“We had dinner this evening at the Water Shed Pub. What an enjoyable evening!!!! The appetizer we started with was the karaage chicken. I can’t explain how the flavors come together for this dynamic appetizer but, Wow! It was fantastic!!! Our entrees of the scallop po boy…..( yum!!! )…… and the seafood enchiladas……. ( oh my goodness!!! ). …were delightful!! So, so delicious!!!! Sweet potato pie and pumpkin cheesecake ice cream were an amazing ending to a superb meal!!! We’ll definitely be back soon! There’s lots more on the menu that we can’t wait to try!!!“

“The service you get when visiting this spot. Today a friend and I were treated to fabulous food and service (Durinda). Durinda , like others there, can't seem to do enough to make your dining experience fabulous. I could say the same for other staff who work there as well. Go there and see for yourself!“

“Staff was not great me and my friend went to wash our hands and my friend didn’t even run he just skipped to the bathroom and the staff yelled at us for “running”. But overall the Taphouse burger was REALLY good I recommend you guys try it,food was great and the tables and the place was great ⭐️“

“My first time here was amazing! Service was quick and very friendly! Complimentary monkey bread and first mimosa was a huge plus side. Food is delicious! We will be recommending and coming back!“

“DJ’s Smoke shack prepared the food for my mother-in-law‘s 100th birthday party celebration. There were 51 attending, and everyone raved about the food. The price was half what I was quoted from Dickies’ Barbecue. We were provided a large container to keep all the food hot until we served it. There was plenty of food for everyone and leftovers to split among families. We had barbecued chicken, pulled pork, three sauces, rolls, baked beans, and macaroni and cheese which tasted just like homemade. I will definitely use this business for parties again.“

“We had dinner today and could not me more pleased with our server Ella. She was very personable and professional. Had great confidence for someone the job for only about a month. She took her time with us, responding to our questions and needs. I rerely do this but was so impressed that I found the manager and told her how impressed I was with Ella.“