7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lake City

“Another excellent pizza 🍕 made to our specifications (thin crust, light sauce, extra toppings etc) once again. When I didn’t thoroughly read new recipe I was trying for dinner tonight (needed to marinate 12-18 hrs not 2-8🤷🏻‍♀️) I told hubby I’ve been craving a Jim & Sue’s pizza. Actually, I can’t think of a time or an order (wings, salads, pizza balls etc) in the past 🤔 30 + years (since they opened in my Gramma’s old bank 🥺…yep, I’m mature🤭)that it wasn’t good -excellent. 🙌🏼West County is lucky!“

“Reeds has been a part of my life since I was a little girl, and it’s still just as special today. Their pizza was always my favorite growing up, and now it’s become a tradition — we order the same thing almost every Friday for karaoke nights at my grandparents’ house. It’s more than just good food; it’s part of our family’s memories. Jay is always kind, the service is fast, and the pizza (and subs) never disappoints. Whether you’re picking up a quick bite or creating traditions like we have, Reeds is that perfect, cozy hometown pizza shop you can count on. Thank you, Reeds, for always being a slice of home! 🍕❤️“

“Ordered hoagies this visit. Two Philly steak and cheese. My grandson asked them to hold the onions and peppers, and they could not as the mixture is already put together. Holding the peppers and onions kind of defeats the whole idea of a Philly steak, but that's what he wanted. He ended up getting it and enjoying the meal anyway. But what concerned me a bit was the fact that it wasn't made fresh and to order and that they couldn't leave it off. The sandwiches were great, and I would recommend them. The service was quick and friendly.“

“great service and the food is amazing!!! definitely a must !! best food in town!!“

“We had them cater our retirement party at our home last evening. The food was amazing, as always! We ordered, chicken, bbq pork, rigatoni, and meatballs. All of our guests raved about the food! Over the years we have used Teresa’s for all our big events. John does an amazing job, and the quality of the food is top notch! Thank you again!
Dean & Lisa Coburn“

“We love the food here. The fresh hot bread is wonderful and portions are large. Highly recommend the food and great service!“

“It's nice to walk in and get my order from the holding 9ven at the side of the customer counter. Hot añd ready. Zesty breàd stick's were awesome.

Vegetarian options: We often get veggie pizza. However there's not a lot of veggies on the pizza, especially for the much higher cost.“