9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lake City

“We tried Jim and Sue's for the first time tonight. Everything was absolutely delicious! We loved everything. We will be back!“

“Reeds has been a part of my life since I was a little girl, and it’s still just as special today. Their pizza was always my favorite growing up, and now it’s become a tradition — we order the same thing almost every Friday for karaoke nights at my grandparents’ house. It’s more than just good food; it’s part of our family’s memories. Jay is always kind, the service is fast, and the pizza (and subs) never disappoints. Whether you’re picking up a quick bite or creating traditions like we have, Reeds is that perfect, cozy hometown pizza shop you can count on. Thank you, Reeds, for always being a slice of home! 🍕❤️“

“great service and the food is amazing!!! definitely a must !! best food in town!!“

“I grew up in Fairview. When Sabo's opened...the uniqueness of the crust, sauce, and everything was perfect. Every chance I get to take a day trip up, I do to just relive some of my youth. I drive from Pittsburgh to get a slice of the past. I have never had a bad service from this place. The staff have always been great, and the food has never left me wanting more. I am glad to see they are still up and going. I will be in the area next month and plan again to wet my whistle with Sabos for my trip home.“

“New owner changed stuff. Little things like garlic bread from old owner was down graded to garlic roll on tue antipasto salad. Salad feeds 4 but 1 roll leaves people wanting.
I should have figured new owner who say they won't change things would go and change things. New menus dont read like menu borders. Not impressed.“

“We love the food here. The fresh hot bread is wonderful and portions are large. Highly recommend the food and great service!“

“It's nice to walk in and get my order from the holding 9ven at the side of the customer counter. Hot añd ready. Zesty breàd stick's were awesome.

Vegetarian options: We often get veggie pizza. However there's not a lot of veggies on the pizza, especially for the much higher cost.“

“I bought 8 pizzas on the app and they were all burned. I complained but was told it was the ovens fault. I asked them to remake them and they refused. I had to take them because I had prepaid on the app. The next day, the owner tried to saynit never happened.“

“We are from Harborcreek and we came camping at Camp Sherwin and we were looking for some place close to get some food. We were kinda late settling up our camper so we didn't have time to cook. I had Spaghetti and my wife had a sub. I got a large portion of Spaghetti witch was excellent. The sub was large and filled and tasty. Wil be back again. Highly recommend.“