45 Best Pizza Restaurants in Erie

“All of the food I have tried is amazing ? ?pie is always on point and love trying all the flavors!“

“The 5 minute ride with the pizza in the backseat was so hard. We got the peppi squared and the rita. They were both amazing! The crust was probably the best of any pizza we have had in our lives. There is nothing left. We can’t wait to go back!“

“9.20.24 While traveling around the US from our home in CO, we stopped at the Erie store. Wow, it is outstanding. The quality, selection, variety of prepared meals and OMG the bakery. In addition the store design is attractive, staff is friendly and the store and restrooms are spotless. Other stores could learn a thing or two about how a grocery store experience should be. I ask you, have you ever seen parking spaces reserved for expecting moms, or flowered in the man’s bathroom. Golly I love it!!“

“We have always had great experiences for over 15 years, until tonight with a newer customer service employees. She needs to be moved if she cant project the companies values for high standards for all people. She claimed to be the expert but 3 other employees couldnt figure out my question. The other 3 employees were very helpful!“

“The Chicken Parmesan pizza was amazing and my family loved it. We also had the cheese and pepperoni pizza it was delicious as well. Homemade crust, tasty sauce, cheesy goodness and I love the pepperoni curls. Maybe consider adding a Chicken, Bacon and Ranch pizza to the menu. High quality pizza at a great price. Support Local“

“Literally been eating Patti's since I was 2!!! Everytime I come home, 1st thing I do is Order!!! Still as Great as it was when I was a baby!!! So Happy U remain a Staple of Erie!!!!!“

“Good food, great customer service, and a friendly and fun crew. Even during a rush my wait has never been long.“

“I used to order every friday when I lived in town. it's been a couple years since I've gone and still hands down the best wings in Erie. man have I missed these wings“

“We are so lucky to have Donatos open a location here in Harborcreek. My husband and I go there often to enjoy a sub, salad or pizza. We have enjoyed every one of them immensely. They have awesome deals too which is always a plus. I have to say the manager (I'm sorry that I don't know his name) is remarkable. We go there for the first class service as much as we go for the great food! Thank you so much!“

“guy who runs it is a baller.“

“This place has the best gluten-free pizza with a vegan cheese available All you have to do is specify that your gluten-free and they'll use a separate pan so good amazing people and amazing pizza“

“First time at Donatos and I LOVED IT!!!
The Calzatos are to die for!
When we came in, the staff was so friendly and helpful!
We got a Pizza, Bread sticks, the Calzatos, and the dessert bread and everything was delicious!
Highly recommend!!“

“Have gotten take out numerous times and usually for pizza and subs. Got 2 grilled chicken salads that were excellent, but the steak and cheese Pittsburgh style was absolutely amazing!! The roll was soft and crisp (have gotten this as well numerous times and very consistent), added tomato and onions on the sub with hot sauce on the side! Just an absolute beast of a sandwich that doesn’t lack on flavor and quality! Also-BEST pizza in the city!!“

“One of our favorite pizza places and not just in Erie! If you want NY pizza-this is your place. We always order a “taste of New York” The crust is fresh, not too thin and not too thick. To switch things up sometimes we get an aloha or quesadilla pizza on the side but our families favorite hands down is the taste of New York. When we travel and try out other pizza places we can’t help but compare it to Pizza Pete’s. Wings and chicken tenders are ok but pizza is what they do best. Plan to allow up to 45 minutes on Friday and Saturday during peak times. Sometimes the phone line is busy during these hours we just wait and call back because it’s worth the wait!“

“This was a real treat to randomly visit. I had a HUGE seafood salad, and it was very tasty with sweet crab meat and shrimp. We also had chicken parm that was perfectly cooked and juicy.

There was only one waitress in the dinning room and you would have thought there was six. She served and bussed so many tables, I was so very impressed! On a $21 bill for 2 people, she earned a $20 tip!“

“Food is amazing and staff is great. Love the new location wine and spirits.“

“We had flights since this was our first time and can honestly say they were all good beers! We also had a calzone, which was very good. You can do a self guided tour to see the facilities a little closer. Patio seating and a gift shop....all the things! Also took 2 growlers home, their pumpkin and grandma's oatmeal cookies.“

“Got takeout and I thought their food was fabulous. Stromboli dough was soft, fresh, and not hard and leathery like a lot of other pizza joints. It was generously stuffed with some good tasting cheese and pepperoni and their sauce was tangy and delicious.“

“We walked over to Connies for food and ice cream last night with our 2 kids for the first time after moving to the neighborhood last fall. The girls working were great! We loved the pizza and ice cream special! Pizza empanadas were also awesome!“

“The Wagner brothers are two of the most affable guys on the planet, and the kids that work there are just like them . . . pleasant, courteous, and fun to be around. We love the food and the atmosphere.“

“Great pizza. But if you tell people their pizza will be done in 20 mins, it shouldn't take 45. If you're busy, don't tell people 20 mins, tell them 45. To make matters worse we got the wrong pizza and didn't realize until we got all the way home.

Update: was 4 Stars. Customer service makes it 5.“

“This place has the best gluten-free pizza with a vegan cheese available All you have to do is specify that your gluten-free and they'll use a separate pan so good amazing people and amazing pizza“

“My driver forgot my soda.. I called him and informed but honestly I didn't think he'd come back...20mins later he showed up with my soda and a carrot cake for my inconvenience, I thought that was so sweet of him. Thank you! Wish I had cash to leave a nice tip.“

“I get my deli every 2 weeks,I always get the sand.pepp,hard salami,some prov,cheese,yellow american,some mozz,occasionally some roast beast,call it in on Saturday b4 10 am,save 1.00 per lb per item,meat is cut nice and thin,cheese as well,best place to get your deli on,I've used garys so many many times,I don't have to leave a name,dude knows who placed it ,names on the bag,didn't give him my name,m paying close to 5 a lb when the Walmart is charging 8-9 per lb,um yeah no brainer,plus when I pick up my order,there is always something tasty too take home,12 in sub rolls,6 in a bag,really fresh,7 bucks dang“

“so much to do. friendly helpful staff. Pizza was good and my kids had a blast. very reasonably priced.“

“They are always nice and patient with me when I stop because I always need to look at the menu.

Vegetarian options: Make your own pizza with no meat.

Dietary restrictions: Making your own pizza means you can have it the way you want.

Parking: There are only a few parking spots due to the delivery drivers, but it's usually a pick up and leave so you can usually find a spot.

Kid-friendliness: Nothing to entertain kids, but it didn't seem that there's adult talk that is non kid friendly.

Wheelchair accessibility: They do have handicapped parking and easy access to the door.“

“Exactly what you would expect. I have been going here once per week for 3 years and have never gotten a bad pizza. We're probably the only ones whom dine in.As for the the other food I can't say.

Kid-friendliness: Been bringing my boy here every week to dine in. Mainly to save clean up at home.The dining room is always empty, so they can act however they please.“

“I signed up on the app and, every year, get a free cookie on my birthday. Plus, you can save up dough points for free pizza!! It smells amazing in there with all their fresh ingredients. Staff are friendly and welcoming. Lots of great deals on the app. They food cooks fast for a delicious meal. I highly recommend you won't be sorry.

Vegetarian options: They have lots of vegetables to choose from for you're pizza. There garlic knots are garlicky deliciousness.

Kid-friendliness: They have cheese pizza, desert, and sides you're little one is sure to love.“

“Delicious jumbo wings and outstanding service from both bartenders. When I’m back in the area again I wouldn’t think twice about stopping in just for the terrific staff!“

“One of the few traditional Italian restaurants and pizza shops that has managed to survive in Erie. Food here is delicious and reasonably priced. I am a huge fan of their wedding soup, meat and cheese ravioli and meatballs dinner and their thin crust pizza. I’m sure that many other things are also good here but I have a hard time deviating from these personal favorites. If dining in, Heidi will take very good care of you…enjoy!“

“I have loved the pizza here for all my life. Honestly the best. I just wish you could be open a little later. By the time we go to order dinner you are closed. I am making a mental note to come for lunch sometime instead. Thank you for being awesome.“

“This was my first time ordering here at Patti’s. I usually order at Marco’s. But I’ll stay here now. The cheese was better. The sauce is better. And it’s a better dough too. Plus it’s a mile down the road from my house and it took 11 minutes to get my pizza. Great job guys keep it up.“

“I ordered the Diamond steak 10oz takeout medium-rare and I have to say it is hands-down one of the best in the Erie PA area. It was as tender and flavorful as a filet and would highly recommend. I wished I had another for a reasonable $20 with mashed & a tossed salad.

Parking: Plenty of parking beside and at the rear of their lot.

Kid-friendliness: Very friendly & welcoming staff“

“Absolutely amazing food and service I will 100% be back one of the best pizzas I have ever had. crispy, fluffy and buttery crust and the sauce is delicious.“

“Great local bar woth great people and great music!“

“Always has amazing food and service!“

“Wow !! Everything I have ordered has been delivered and amazing !! Highly recommend“

“Only leaving the bottom so people can understand the update…. After writing this review I thought to myself why would they do that it was driving me crazy … then I looked at the receipt my wife accidentally hit contactless delivery so this is 100% on us the driver did exactly what he was supposed to do.

As always the food is absolutely amazing… but there delivery service is honestly terrible no sooner did he ring the bell he started heading back to his car leaving my pizza and pizzoli on the cement… if he waited just thirty seconds longer he would have seen two five dollar bills put into his hand. I have never had a pizza place just leave my food except one time when it took me a few min to get to the door and that was on me.“

“Excellent food and a wide array of beers. The view is incredible from all of the decks !“

“After reading some of the reviews my husband and I were kind of reluctant to go there for dinner but we had 2 hungry little ones with us so we figured we would try it out. From the minute we walked and told us in to the minute we left, everything was amazing! Our server greeted us instantly and told us to sit wherever we wanted. We gave her our order, which was a lot, and she didn't even write it down and got everything right.. The food was so good, everything was cooked perfectly.. It looked like the server was the only person working but she was still very attentive to not only my family, also the other custIomers and families. I believe her name was Charise. That's what it said on our bill. Regardless, that woman deserves recognition for all the hard work I witnessed her doing.“

“Went to Mc’s for the first time a few weeks ago , now it’s become my favorite sidebar . The bartenders are friendly and the drinks are good .The food is delicious ! The iron wings are the best I’ve had in years . I will definitely be ordering food from there again.“

“Ordered for the first time tonight. Reasonable prices. Delivery was quick and the driver was friendly. Loved the pizza. Generous amount of toppings and plenty of sauce so it wasn't dry like many other shops, also loved the cheese! We will definitely order again.“

“The pizza is usually pretty amazing. I LOVE the stuffed cheesy bread and the pasta dishes. I also love the points system. It's so easy to stack points to get a free pizza or something else if you choose. It's affordable and yummy. Domino's is definitely my go to!!“

“the food and service is amazing!!!“

“Pizza was excellent and had no issues ordering over the phone as some other reviews mentioned. FYI - If you're a first time customer you have to pay over the phone. They're takeout only.

Will definitely be ordering again.“