43 Best Pizza Restaurants in Erie

“All of the food I have tried is amazing ? ?pie is always on point and love trying all the flavors!“

“This grocery is like art work....the best grocery store I have ever seen in my life... I need to come visit home more for this store 😊“

“9.20.24 While traveling around the US from our home in CO, we stopped at the Erie store. Wow, it is outstanding. The quality, selection, variety of prepared meals and OMG the bakery. In addition the store design is attractive, staff is friendly and the store and restrooms are spotless. Other stores could learn a thing or two about how a grocery store experience should be. I ask you, have you ever seen parking spaces reserved for expecting moms, or flowered in the man’s bathroom. Golly I love it!!“

“Best pizza on the East side without a doubt. Haven't tried the hoagies yet but that'll be next and I'm sure I won't be disappointed. Keep up the excellent work. Dinner tonight was DELICIOUS!“

“After working a 14-hour day, we picked up Donatos for dinner. Unfortunately, the 3 orders of wings were missing from the order. The manager went out of his way to fix the situation. He had the wings delivered to us- way out of their normal delivery area. The food was great. Customer service was top notch. Kudos to the Harborcreek Donatos!“

“The 5 minute ride with the pizza in the backseat was so hard. We got the peppi squared and the rita. They were both amazing! The crust was probably the best of any pizza we have had in our lives. There is nothing left. We can’t wait to go back!“

“Best burgers in the universe“

“have always loved this place and will still recommend it. the dough is amazing. and the best thing on the menu is the Hawaiian pizza (did you know they put bacon on it BACON) today I was not impressed. got the Italian combo calzone. the lady accidentally put it in as a Italian combo sub. I waited twice the time for it...will not be getting it again. I thought it would be ham salami and pepperoni, with sauce and cheese. no just ham salami and cheese.amd then the meats where hug pieces making it hards to eat. a little disappointed that I waited twice the time for them to fix it but then I got charged 4 dollars difference. looking at the menu there's only a 2.50 difference. will still recommend but will only get what I know now.“

“Literally been eating Patti's since I was 2!!! Everytime I come home, 1st thing I do is Order!!! Still as Great as it was when I was a baby!!! So Happy U remain a Staple of Erie!!!!!“

“I work in the activities department for Soldiers' and Sailors' Home and this evening we were very pleased with our outing at Maria's Pizza. Not only did their diverse menu hit the spot for many picky eaters, but it also provided a great family atmosphere. The staff was very kind and courteous, respectful of our Veterans and they served us with perfect time, especially since our crowd is typically not known to be very patient and/or have short attention spans. The pricing was well within budget, giving our residents the ability to splurge and go wild on a smorgasbord of deliciousness. Thank you so much for the amazing experience! This is not the last time we see Maria's!“

“This place has the best gluten-free pizza with a vegan cheese available All you have to do is specify that your gluten-free and they'll use a separate pan so good amazing people and amazing pizza“

“This is my favorite place to get pizza in Erie. The prices are reasonable and the pizza is cooked to perfection. There was one time we were given a different pizza than we ordered, but it was actually delicious. Hoping they add a cook's choice option. Could be fun!“

“Food is amazing and staff is great. Love the new location wine and spirits.“

“it is the best Pizza anywhere. 🍕 And it is reasonably priced.“

“I used to order every friday when I lived in town. it's been a couple years since I've gone and still hands down the best wings in Erie. man have I missed these wings“

“HARBORCREEK location: What a great way to spent a pizza date night with my kiddos! They wanted to eat in a pizza shop tonight and they even got to play in a pizza shop! Perfect little back room with a pretend pizza shop and the staff was so friendly! ♥️🍕🌟“

“I got a pickup order from here I got the nacho cheese fries and a half sub BLT. The food is amazing even after being in traffic my fries weren't mushy and disgusting. They had very good flavor nacho cheese wasn't spicy like a lot of places the bacon on the sub was soft not super crunchy I will definitely eat here again“

“We love BLAZE! Decided to come after the movies and the ingredients were fresh and my son enjoyed the high rise dough. The team was friendly and made our pies with specificity. But most of all, the rewards are worth it! I got 50% off and a free pizza with my flames🔥 🔥. I just wish there was a second location on the east side of Erie.“

“Amazing Stromboli’s and Pizza!! Highly recommended!!“

“I always feel like Valerio is a pretty fair value for the quality and price point. I feel like you get pretty good portions of pasta. You get bread with it and they always have a really good side salad with plenty of dressing options. The servers have always been polite And overall just enjoyable night out. As a full-blooded Italian, I feel like their sauce and food in general is a little bit bland and could always use more garlic or herbs and spices but of course that’s just me a genuine 100% Italian most people like some of my other family memberswho are not blood probably wouldn’t want it to be too spicy or to have too much seasoning, so I understand why they have to make it that way“

“We walked over to Connies for food and ice cream last night with our 2 kids for the first time after moving to the neighborhood last fall. The girls working were great! We loved the pizza and ice cream special! Pizza empanadas were also awesome!“

“I get my deli every 2 weeks,I always get the sand.pepp,hard salami,some prov,cheese,yellow american,some mozz,occasionally some roast beast,call it in on Saturday b4 10 am,save 1.00 per lb per item,meat is cut nice and thin,cheese as well,best place to get your deli on,I've used garys so many many times,I don't have to leave a name,dude knows who placed it ,names on the bag,didn't give him my name,m paying close to 5 a lb when the Walmart is charging 8-9 per lb,um yeah no brainer,plus when I pick up my order,there is always something tasty too take home,12 in sub rolls,6 in a bag,really fresh,7 bucks dang“

“Wow !! Everything I have ordered has been delivered and amazing !! Highly recommend“

“This place has the best gluten-free pizza with a vegan cheese available All you have to do is specify that your gluten-free and they'll use a separate pan so good amazing people and amazing pizza“

“Perfect in all categories! We tried several different pizzas on the menu and all were perfection! Boneless wings, antipasto, and cookies, all were top notch and delicious!! We placed a large order for a work lunch and all items were fresh, and hot. Our delivery was also at the time requested. 100 STARS!!“

“I absolutely Love Sbarro The workers at this location are Wonderful Thank You 😊🍕🍕❤️“

“Same family as valerios and the interior is almost identical. Small, casual Italian restaurant; no frills and decent pricing. Stuffed rigatoni and chicken Alfredo were good, IMO better than valerios. Seemed more flavorful and they had more homemade options such as Italian wedding soup and lasagna. The food could have been hotter/cooked longer- it actually came out really quick and was Luke warm and quickly cooled to cold. Specifically the red sauce wasn’t as hot as it should’ve been. Pls take your time especially when not busy. But at least they gave a nice portion of sauce. Most never give enough. Secondly, the side salad was very small and on a weird oblong dish with only cheese and tomato. Aside from those two things the service was excellent, with Ms. Heidi being very polite and attentive and also reminding us to BYOB next time! Dishes were about 14 a piece so $30 for two with waters. I’d say it’s fairly priced with portions and a salad or soup and bread. Sauce was sweet which I enjoyed. But as a full blooded Italian it could always use more garlic and Italian seasoning lol that goes for 99% of Italian places though. Thx for the good service. Also please get lemons as she said they didn’t have them- like, ever.“

“so much to do. friendly helpful staff. Pizza was good and my kids had a blast. very reasonably priced.“

“friendly staff and great food. reasonable prices as well. Would recommend the burger and quesadilla's. we traveled from Michigan and went to MA and ME trying to find good food and this ended up being our favorite.“

“Great spot for delicious affordable food. Thanks guys!“

“I have loved the pizza here for all my life. Honestly the best. I just wish you could be open a little later. By the time we go to order dinner you are closed. I am making a mental note to come for lunch sometime instead. Thank you for being awesome.“

“Mama Mia's is our favorite Pizza. It has a chewy crust and delicious sauce. Friendly service and reasonably priced too!“

“They are always nice and patient with me when I stop because I always need to look at the menu.

Vegetarian options: Make your own pizza with no meat.

Dietary restrictions: Making your own pizza means you can have it the way you want.

Parking: There are only a few parking spots due to the delivery drivers, but it's usually a pick up and leave so you can usually find a spot.

Kid-friendliness: Nothing to entertain kids, but it didn't seem that there's adult talk that is non kid friendly.

Wheelchair accessibility: They do have handicapped parking and easy access to the door.“

“I’ve never met better people than you guys! You guys are working Christmas Eve and while some may be bitter - you both are the exact opposite and are what Christmas is all about! Thank you Amanda and Robert for amazing customer service. I wish you nothing but the best.“

“I ordered the Diamond steak 10oz takeout medium-rare and I have to say it is hands-down one of the best in the Erie PA area. It was as tender and flavorful as a filet and would highly recommend. I wished I had another for a reasonable $20 with mashed & a tossed salad.

Parking: Plenty of parking beside and at the rear of their lot.

Kid-friendliness: Very friendly & welcoming staff“

“I signed up on the app and, every year, get a free cookie on my birthday. Plus, you can save up dough points for free pizza!! It smells amazing in there with all their fresh ingredients. Staff are friendly and welcoming. Lots of great deals on the app. They food cooks fast for a delicious meal. I highly recommend you won't be sorry.

Vegetarian options: They have lots of vegetables to choose from for you're pizza. There garlic knots are garlicky deliciousness.

Kid-friendliness: They have cheese pizza, desert, and sides you're little one is sure to love.“

“Great local bar woth great people and great music!“

“Absolutely amazing food and service I will 100% be back one of the best pizzas I have ever had. crispy, fluffy and buttery crust and the sauce is delicious.“

“After reading some of the reviews my husband and I were kind of reluctant to go there for dinner but we had 2 hungry little ones with us so we figured we would try it out. From the minute we walked and told us in to the minute we left, everything was amazing! Our server greeted us instantly and told us to sit wherever we wanted. We gave her our order, which was a lot, and she didn't even write it down and got everything right.. The food was so good, everything was cooked perfectly.. It looked like the server was the only person working but she was still very attentive to not only my family, also the other custIomers and families. I believe her name was Charise. That's what it said on our bill. Regardless, that woman deserves recognition for all the hard work I witnessed her doing.“

“Ordered the meat lovers large pizza for 50% off and I have to honestly say it was one of the best pizza's I have ever had. The best topping was the Italian Sausage which really gave the pizza some extra flavor. The amount of toppings was good and the end of the crust was not too big. Sometimes you buy a pizza and 1/4th of it is raised crust that most people don't eat. Excellent pizza and service. 5 stars.“

“It’s a classic Pizza Hut. The service was amazing each time, I order online. Really nice girl working counter too, makes it worth the visit just for the excellent service provided

Parking: Parking is easy to find, multiple entrances and lot surrounds the perimeter of building

Kid-friendliness: Good lighting and seating. Plenty of seats and divided areas to keep it quieter“

“Went to Mc’s for the first time a few weeks ago , now it’s become my favorite sidebar . The bartenders are friendly and the drinks are good .The food is delicious ! The iron wings are the best I’ve had in years . I will definitely be ordering food from there again.“

“Ordered for the first time tonight. Reasonable prices. Delivery was quick and the driver was friendly. Loved the pizza. Generous amount of toppings and plenty of sauce so it wasn't dry like many other shops, also loved the cheese! We will definitely order again.“