44 Best Pizza Restaurants in Erie

“I absolutely LOVED my burger!“

“Got a whole custom topping pizza, a slice of the Reuben pizza, and 2 slices of the lucky charms cheesecake for only 32 bucks! The guys are sooo sweet and provided above and beyond customer service!! Definitely gonna be a regular spot to go to now 🩵“

“All of the food I have tried is amazing ? ?pie is always on point and love trying all the flavors!“

“good pizza. great owner. More than once my order has been wrong or late. showed up for my order pick up 5 minutes after time to be done. They forgot a pizza. had to wait for pizza. I'd have liked option to just cancel and get home instead of waiting. I'll still go back. Got home and the pizza I was given is crazy spicy hot like they put the hot honey sauce or something on it.“

“Literally been eating Patti's since I was 2!!! Everytime I come home, 1st thing I do is Order!!! Still as Great as it was when I was a baby!!! So Happy U remain a Staple of Erie!!!!!“

“This place has the best gluten-free pizza with a vegan cheese available All you have to do is specify that your gluten-free and they'll use a separate pan so good amazing people and amazing pizza“

“Wow !! Everything I have ordered has been delivered and amazing !! Highly recommend“

“I work in the activities department for Soldiers' and Sailors' Home and this evening we were very pleased with our outing at Maria's Pizza. Not only did their diverse menu hit the spot for many picky eaters, but it also provided a great family atmosphere. The staff was very kind and courteous, respectful of our Veterans and they served us with perfect time, especially since our crowd is typically not known to be very patient and/or have short attention spans. The pricing was well within budget, giving our residents the ability to splurge and go wild on a smorgasbord of deliciousness. Thank you so much for the amazing experience! This is not the last time we see Maria's!“

“Ippa's is our FAVE Pizza, with the hand-stretched mozzarella, the delicious char-crust, the sauces, toppings. We ordered the Rita with cupped char pepperoni and the Chicken Bacon Ranch.Pizzas. Never a disappointment, always ultra-delicious and consistent. Great, friendly service. We love the charred crust, too. The BEST!“

“Awesome food and awesome service!“

“have always loved this place and will still recommend it. the dough is amazing. and the best thing on the menu is the Hawaiian pizza (did you know they put bacon on it BACON) today I was not impressed. got the Italian combo calzone. the lady accidentally put it in as a Italian combo sub. I waited twice the time for it...will not be getting it again. I thought it would be ham salami and pepperoni, with sauce and cheese. no just ham salami and cheese.amd then the meats where hug pieces making it hards to eat. a little disappointed that I waited twice the time for them to fix it but then I got charged 4 dollars difference. looking at the menu there's only a 2.50 difference. will still recommend but will only get what I know now.“

“My order on Doordash was perfect!!

I got the Cubano sandwich inspired pizza and a pepperoni for a back up.
With arrived at a good time and was fresh from the oven. The flavor was so good and the Cubano was a hit!

Even my 2 toddlers ate their pizza instead of playing with it.

Love this place and plan on ordering again and trying more menu items.“

“Food is amazing and staff is great. Love the new location wine and spirits.“

“We have been going here for at least 25 years if not more. Best wings in Erie!!! Never disappoints ❤️“

“it is the best Pizza anywhere. 🍕 And it is reasonably priced.“

“great pizza and sub sandwich“

“Went out to eat here recently. I lived around the corner for a couple of years and never stopped in. Honestly, nothing really drew me in, and now I’m disappointed in myself for not trying it sooner.

The food was delicious! We ordered the pizza logs, cheese bread, a pizza, and a Stromboli. Yes, we were extremely hungry, but everything was fresh, flavorful, and definitely worth it.

Our waitress, Rebecca, was very kind, friendly, and prompt with service. The only minor thing I noticed was that she didn’t check back for drink refills, and our glasses stayed empty for a while. That said, it wasn’t enough to affect the tip we left because she was otherwise great.

Overall, it was a very good experience. The pizza was excellent, the food came out quickly, and the atmosphere was enjoyable. I would definitely recommend giving this place a try. I’ll certainly be back.“

“Lakeshore Teresa's Deli is the spot. Great food and even better people! Highly Recommend.“

“We walked over to Connies for food and ice cream last night with our 2 kids for the first time after moving to the neighborhood last fall. The girls working were great! We loved the pizza and ice cream special! Pizza empanadas were also awesome!“

“friendly staff and great food. reasonable prices as well. Would recommend the burger and quesadilla's. we traveled from Michigan and went to MA and ME trying to find good food and this ended up being our favorite.“

“You want great pizza , Stevos has no question. Deep dish is to die for. Just make sure I get back up there again. Everyone In Butler County who stops there by UPMC Park will have best eating pizza experience you will ever have. Here that Guy .“

“Friday Jun 19, 2026…service very good. Our party of 9 had various meals and 7 good food, 1 ok and mine Chicken fingers with curly fries, sadly WAY over cooked near burnt. My meal very disappointing.“

“Absolutely FANTASTIC!!!!
Clean, fresh, with a fabulous aroma in the air as soon as you walk in the door. Greeted by happy employee 's ready to help. Great team work, they have a system in place and the lines move flawlessly. So excited to have found a fresh pizza spot closer to home.
Delicious crusts, tons of selections to choose from, endless possibilities. Wonderful experience cant wait to come again for another combination.“

“I get my deli every 2 weeks,I always get the sand.pepp,hard salami,some prov,cheese,yellow american,some mozz,occasionally some roast beast,call it in on Saturday b4 10 am,save 1.00 per lb per item,meat is cut nice and thin,cheese as well,best place to get your deli on,I've used garys so many many times,I don't have to leave a name,dude knows who placed it ,names on the bag,didn't give him my name,m paying close to 5 a lb when the Walmart is charging 8-9 per lb,um yeah no brainer,plus when I pick up my order,there is always something tasty too take home,12 in sub rolls,6 in a bag,really fresh,7 bucks dang“

“I had a great time grabbing a quick dinner here recently. The pizza had a really nice crust that wasn't too thick or too thin, and the toppings tasted super fresh. The service was friendly and efficient, so I didn't have to wait long at all. It's definitely a solid choice if you're looking for a tasty meal without any fuss.“

“First time here as we were in Erie for the Curtze food show. Food was fantastic as well as the service. I will definitely return when we get back up that way“

“Great local bar woth great people and great music!“

“Great spot for delicious affordable food. Thanks guys!“

“Went there 5 minutes before they closed and they still happily let us order a couple of pizzas! Nice conversation and the most delicious pizza including the crust! Love the wood fired smell, cooked to perfection! Thank you for spectacular food and service!“

“Highly recommend!!! It was clean and the staff were friendly, always checking up on the party throwers to make sure the kids were comfortable and entertained. Was amazed at the ability for kids to play games by swiping your wrist bands instead of inserting coins. Very affordable…“

“Mama Mia's is our favorite Pizza. It has a chewy crust and delicious sauce. Friendly service and reasonably priced too!“

“Went to Mc’s for the first time a few weeks ago , now it’s become my favorite sidebar . The bartenders are friendly and the drinks are good .The food is delicious ! The iron wings are the best I’ve had in years . I will definitely be ordering food from there again.“

“Always love dominos for their specials and affordability and timeliness. They bust their butt in there. They had orders coming in left and right and the phone was ringing. Nice guy said a few calls offs. With that said, why is there NO TIP JAR!??? I asked the staff and they said they’re not allowed to have it out. that’s outrageous. And they’re probably paying ppl minimum wage. Why not? If they’re busting their butt and provide quality service they deserve a tip just as much as anyone else“

“First time trying Marco's and ZERO disappointment. To start, the staff was awesome, friendly and made me feel like I was an every day customer. The store was clean and tidy. Even the walk was cleared off of snow, and we had a lot of snow!! The pizza itself was delicious, both of them. We had a white pizza and a cheese and pep with old school pepperoni. YUM all the way!! Will be back. The only down side was I didn't get any photos of the pizzas...they didn't last long enough!“

“Ordered for the first time tonight. Reasonable prices. Delivery was quick and the driver was friendly. Loved the pizza. Generous amount of toppings and plenty of sauce so it wasn't dry like many other shops, also loved the cheese! We will definitely order again.“

“I dropped in for an early dinner and sat at the bar. First, I love a bar with hooks for your purse and a foot rest so your legs don’t go numb. Second, service is fantastic. All the White Buffalo staff take care of you. If they notice your drink is low, they ask if you want another. They check if your order is correct and if you need anything else. All the staff care, not just an assigned server. Few places run this way. I got a salad with hot wing sauced chicken and steamed vegetables – brilliant idea. You don’t need dressing, because the sauce is the dressing. I loved that you have an option of grilled or fried chicken. The kitchen staff has chicken down – moist, not over cooked. Also, I was pleasantly surprised that the salad greens were mixed greens – not plain iceburg. It was wing night, so many around me were eating wings – they serve the biggest wings I have seen. The White Buffalo has many wing flavors and from what I saw, cook to order. Sitting at the bar, I could also see they offer lots of liquor options. I enjoy trying new brands and flavors, this bar does not disappoint. They also have some fun top shelf sippers. Looking forward to returning and trying some new treats.“

“I’ve never met better people than you guys! You guys are working Christmas Eve and while some may be bitter - you both are the exact opposite and are what Christmas is all about! Thank you Amanda and Robert for amazing customer service. I wish you nothing but the best.“

“Awesome food and awesome service!“

“My daughter is an employee at Wegman’s. What a wonderful company to work for. They were so caring during the loss of my daughter’s grandmother. We are so appreciative. Everything about this company is fantastic, from the food to the staff. Thank you.“

“After reading some of the reviews my husband and I were kind of reluctant to go there for dinner but we had 2 hungry little ones with us so we figured we would try it out. From the minute we walked and told us in to the minute we left, everything was amazing! Our server greeted us instantly and told us to sit wherever we wanted. We gave her our order, which was a lot, and she didn't even write it down and got everything right.. The food was so good, everything was cooked perfectly.. It looked like the server was the only person working but she was still very attentive to not only my family, also the other custIomers and families. I believe her name was Charise. That's what it said on our bill. Regardless, that woman deserves recognition for all the hard work I witnessed her doing.“

“Papa Johns on East 38th Street delivers a consistently good experience for take-out and delivery, making it a reliable choice when craving pizza. The menu offers a wide selection, from classic favorites to specialty pies, along with wings, sides, and desserts that round out a meal nicely. Orders are usually prepared quickly, and the staff is friendly and efficient at handling both in-person and phone requests. The pizzas arrive hot, with fresh ingredients and the signature garlic sauce that sets Papa Johns apart. While it’s part of a national chain, this location maintains a welcoming feel and provides dependable quality, making it a solid option for a casual meal at home or an easy pick-up“

“Yummy Hawaiian pizza style I’ll buy more soon“

“Though we probably didn’t visit at the best time of day or year, we had a really good experience at Sullivan’s. As a Philly native, their cheesesteak was surprisingly good. The bartender was very friendly and gave good bar suggestions for other places in Erie. The atmosphere wasn’t great though, I think the AC was busted so it was super hot, and the helipad across the street is very loud. Still a really cool divey Irish pub with great food.“

“I thought Uptown Browns was an excellent place to go and have a drink. The bartenders there are excellent and sweethearts I I I had a great girl was serving us and she was absolutely wonderful. I would recommend this place to anybody that's cool with a local flavor and down to hang out with just anybody because we all get along better when we all do it together!“