23 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mayfield

“Super friendly staff, never disappointed in the ice cream or toppings. Addicted to the hot fudge sundaes.“

“I always take my grandchildren there fast kind delicious I tried banana cream pie soo good I love there flavors fantastic my grandkids like there swirls“

“Very friendly staff, and as usual, EXCELLENT milkshakes!!“

“The strawberry shortcake Ice Cream is amazing!“

“The girls here go above and beyond for there customers!! My Husband and I are regulars here so they allow us to call ahead so our order is ready when we arrive... very good customer service and always with a smile“

“Delicious custard cream. Best atmosphere, always clean. owner & staff is very friendly. Great prices.“

“My new ice cream shop for sure. Third time the charm for catching it open and we'll worth the wait....
My favorite ice cream of all time for over 45 years is mint chocolate chip ..I will judge an entire dairy based on one little taste of my favorite ...as you can see from the size of the scoop , I had many many little tastes and enjoyed every single one of them....smooth, creamy perfectly minty with just the right amount of chocolate! As you can also see, Shasta , my service wahwah enjoyed the heck out of her complimentary pupcup with two teeny weeny milk bone sprinkles!
Such a lovely chill spot and the color changing spoon amused me.
Shasta tested Shasta approved!
Thanks Scoops on Spruce....until we meet again!“

“I had an ice cream, it was very good. There was only one person helping customers, it took a bit long to get service. Nice tables in front, the best part; a working sink to clean your shelf. Plenty of parking space nice people around.

Parking: Big Parking space

Kid-friendliness: Tables and a small playground for kids.“

“We had the best time here! Extremely affordable. The girls were quick to get our ice cream. The line moved very quickly. Mini golf is a must! I feel like it’s a hidden gem. We were the only ones on the course and we had the best time! For $22 my husband and I had the best little date night.“

“Saturday night 8 pm. 5 to 10 minute wait to order. To be expected and desired. Good ice cream is an indication of a line to order. Lot’s of choices and the prices are reasonable. Nice staff working the windows. Great experience and will go back!“

“Ok been here three times and my boyfriend brought it home once for us. It has been his only and favorite ice cream spot for five years and now of course mine as well.I am......a malt snob....I love malt...I will choose a malt above all almost every time. Trip one ..a snoopie malt. .mmm yum yum.Trip two..... I laid off the malt because I had to try my favorite flavor mint chip in shake form.... Oh my scoop...yum....Trip three ....burgundy cherry malt... Thought I bit a cherry. Turned out to be a chunk of butterfat. Now that's fresh!Be still my burgundy heart...Then he brought me home my requested two scoops. One scoop of cheesecake and one scoop of coffee.Let's just say I can't wait to have it in malt form...Thank you Mannings for making my knees permanently weak. Yum.“

“Just moved to Olyphant... First visit ever yesterday. Outstanding sundae and my wife loved her root beer float! Price was great as well. We will definitely be back!“

“Love love love! Excellent service - amazing cakes - dairy free options & don’t forget ice cream for your dogs!!“

“I love Rita's. The servings are good and the prices reasonable. However, this location has limited parking. Difficult to get in and out. They don't secure their umbrellas well. A stiff wind pulled one out of a table and hit my fiance. Not their fault, but maybe it could have been prevented. Regardless, I would definitely return and recommend it.“

“Wow! I’ve been here a few times before and it’s never been anything special but I’ve recently been back during the weekend and have been absolutely blown away by kashala (sorry if I misspelled it)! Amazing customer service, so fast and such a kind soul absolutely will be a regular just for the service“

“Discovered this place last year. Graham Slam is the absolute best flavor! Staff is awesome!“

“Best frozen yogurt I ever had!“

“Used to love Padulas however this year something is off. They had amazing ice cream, Perry's, for all these years now this year it's definitely a different brand, probably Hersheys which is a little bland in my opinion. It is not their fault that I don't prefer Hersheys. Unless I am confused it's ok in a pinch. The sprinkles also seem to be not the best brand either. I asked for layered and extra extra extra, they don't do this quite as well as every other place. Maybe it's a good thing considering.“

“We count down the days for when you guys open for ice cream season!!! The ice cream is amazing and the staff is friendly and helpful. thank you for everything“

“The ice is so refreshing and the custard is amazing so much better then ice cream.“

“As a previous employee, the owner is very friendly and accommodating. Working the whole experience was very cool, my only concern is the sweetness of the cookies because with all of the sugar in each cookie (especially the big ones) it can pose as very unhealthy to your health. It is better to eat these in moderation instead of making it an everyday thing. Also, these cookies get costly quick if you order a lot. Other than that, it was a pleasure working with the staff that was there, and grateful for the opportunity I had working there.“

“amazing food with great pricing! I had the ravioli and eggplant rollatini and it was delicious! The owner cooked and said his family was from Brooklyn. You can tell! it's one of the best Italian food options in NEPA and beyond! can't wait to try more dishes.“