New American Restaurants near Middletown, PA

“Came in on a random Thursday night, traveling in from out of town. Looking for a spot to get some good Indian food and beer(s). I can say the lamb jalfrezi was on-point. Spicy and flavorful. Slow cooked in the way that’s hard to do from a microwave. Ingredients were clearly fresh. Full bar and decent selection of draft beers and traditional bar food. Seems like a fun neighborhood hangout spot. You’re probably going to need to park on the street or walk. Will return.“

“Went there a week or so ago with family that came in from out of town. We had a person with a gluten allergy, but she found the steak salad on the menu and was very happy with it. All of the food was great. The service was fantastic. And the prices were reasonable (for the world we are in right now). Have gone there a few times over the past few years and really don't ever recall having a bad meal or service. We will definitely be going back and really looking forward to trying the all you can eat crab in the summer... that sounds amazing!“

“Had a delicious meal here last night with my sister and cousin. We all had the grouper sandwich which was very good. The french fries were the best that I have had in a long time! Our server was friendly and very accommodating. Will definitely be back!“

“One of the gems of linglestown! My husband and I love mellow minded. We have come countless times and you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. All of the staff are very kind, helpful, and personable. An extra added bonus is the art features from local artists. 10/10“

“Excellent experience everytime we visit. Make sure to make reservations. Great selection of appetizers, and not just typical appetizers. Specials are delicious as is most items on the menu. Would recommend for an upscale family dinner or even an date night.“

“Denise, thank you for being the absolute best! You served us dinner more nights than not! The food is amazing, but, you are such a special person! We’re leaving the state..it’s not goodbye, it’s see ya later! ❤️❤️ Love, your favorite suckholes!“

“Friendly staff, good food when traveling through the area. We had a couple apps, flight of beer sampler, and multiple meal. All the food was good. Lemon blueberry shanty was terrific. Minimal GF options, but did put my burger on a bed of lettuce. Staff was super friendly and helpful.“

“Nothing bad to say! Food was delicious and server was really nice. Seemed to be a few regulars coming and going and the staff talked with them like friends. That's a good place. I got the baked ziti and it was the best I've had in a long time.“

“Located right by Hersheypark, Tröegs was a perfect way to unwind after a busy day. It's a huge space with indoor and outdoor seating, from bar seating to full service booths. Staff was super attentive and helpful in making recommendations on food and drinks.“

“My husband and I always enjoy breakfast at the Circular. The fresh made omelettes by John are by far the best. The fruit is always so delicious. Even with our food sensitivities we find plenty to enjoy. We also love the time we get with our favorite server Jo. She is a joy!! We even took our teenagers on one of our trips away just so they could meet Jo. They loved her too!! She is the shining gem of The Circular!!!Dietary restrictions: Nut and strawberry allergies, non pork“

“Everything I've tried has been delicious and fresh. The only exception would be the steak. I've tried several dishes with steak (tortellini, tacos) and often the steak is chewy where you have to spit it out because you cant chew it.“

“I find this a comfortable place to dine when I am alone. The food is good and the service staff is very accommodating. The restaurant has been around forever, so it is not really fancy, but they have remodeled lately. Try the chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting...OMG!!!“

“We have been coming here for 27 years. How is this my first review of them! Probably cause I always get so excited We both got house margaritas. Tasty as always. They gave us waters first when we arrived As always I get the carnitas entree with rice & beans. I do love their salsa as it tastes fresh & flavorful. Hubby got the carnita enchiladas with mole. He tried a new food & loved it. Mole is this lip smacking peppers, tomato & onion sauce. Try it- you'll love it. We got the flan which is creamy, silky and delicious!“

“Stopped here for lunch after test driving a car. Wings were great. I just got the Medium Buffalo style and they were crisp and saucy the way I like them. The fries were served in a paper cone fashion and were a bit bland, needed salt in my opinion but wasnt bad at all. My wife and son got burgers. They said they really liked them. The waitress was the bartender and she handled the bar room and the seated customers just fine.“

“The store clerk was very kind ✨I wonder if it's Jimoti's popular restaurant, and it's full by 7pm...What will happen to my last supper in America? Just as I was thinking that, I was guided to the second floor.I wish I had followed my father's advice that ``pasta is recommended''...The pasta was drowning in the thick soup, and the alcohol went on and on as I ate the thick, sticky soup. I ended up drinking a lot of alcohol with the pasta I was given!Mom's main dish is steak salad. picture? Will salad be the main thing? →There was a very large piece of meat sitting on top of the salad.I'm a hamburger!was delicious! But I want to try more things... I can't eat them all...Let me bring you again!“

“Love what the Beerded Goat has done with the space! The energy and vibe of the entire place make you want to return! There was a good variety of beers on tap! We did flights so we could try 8 very different beers! Dinner was great (fish and chips/mahi tacos). The servers were knowledgeable and attentive! Definitely recommend and definitely going back! The couches, games, and jukebox are great touches! It is such a large space but it's warm and inviting!“

“Good morning.We had breakfast this morning at the restaurant located on the first floor of the Hershey Lodge.We previously dined there for dinner the other night and had a positive experience.This morning, we opted for the buffet, which I found to be overpriced for the selection offered. However, since we were staying at the lodge, it was included in our room rate.Our server, Mandy, provided excellent service on both occasions. She was friendly, attentive, and went above and beyond to make our dining experience enjoyable.On our first visit, Mandy inquired if we were celebrating any special occasions. I informed her that it was my birthday and wedding anniversary. At the end of our meal, she surprised me with a complimentary dessert with a candle.I would like to express my appreciation to Mandy for her exceptional service.“

“The food, service and ambiance were fantastic. Never had Primanti Bros but will be back! The portion was great, pastrami was delicious and the server Katie was delightful. We sat on the patio on a beautiful night out. They cleaned tables the moment they got up and it was just a pleasant environment. We tried going to a different location in Camp Hill and left immediately as it was dirty and unorganized. The PB in Hershey is top notch!“

“Very impressed! We generally eat in the circular, Harvest came highly recommended, after eating here I would actually recommend this more than the circular! The atmosphere is like a modern Country Club but still down to earth. Service was impeccable. You must try the crab soup. The filet was so tender I was able to cut it with the side of my Fork. Very extensive bourbon selection, with a solid old-fashioned bartender. We will definitely be back!Parking: Plenty of parking, same elevationWheelchair accessibility: Very easily accessible“

“Great atmosphere, chicken fingers were juicy, crunchy and huge! They have a good menu, something for everyone. Beer is a must try...even if your not really "a beer person" like me. They have some sweeter beers with candy names such as Nerds, sugar plum, gummy...something and more. Our server was phenomenal! Will definitely be back!“

“We. Had reservations but really didn't need them on this visit as it was not too busy. I can tell this place does get busy in the summer so book ahead if that is the season you go. I didn't go with high hopes as this is the restaurant attached to the park but the food was excellent. On the menu they mark items that are made with a candy based item. Hubs got the Reese's chicken sandwich and a Reese's old fashion. Delicious. I had a red stripe Martini and wings. After a long day in the park this was the perfect way to end the night.“

“We. Had reservations but really didn't need them on this visit as it was not too busy. I can tell this place does get busy in the summer so book ahead if that is the season you go. I didn't go with high hopes as this is the restaurant attached to the park but the food was excellent. On the menu they mark items that are made with a candy based item. Hubs got the Reese's chicken sandwich and a Reese's old fashion. Delicious. I had a red stripe Martini and wings. After a long day in the park this was the perfect way to end the night.“