New American Restaurants near Middletown, PA

“The workers were very kind,cordial and congenial and the girl with the braces had such A lovely smile,but the pizza was burned on the bottom and the crust was so hard and thin so my first visit is also my last.Its back to Whopper wednesday for me instead of half price pizza“

“Was in the area for a seminar and decided to stop by for dinner and watch football game. Service was excellent and food was outstanding. The restaurant is a amazing place. Highly recommend it“

“My husband and I dined here last night. it was our first experience at The Mill,and everything was spectacular. I chose the porterhouse bone-in pork chop,while he had the seasonal duck. The food was delicious, as were the drinks. We also really enjoyed the rustic/industrial atmosphere. We will definitely be back!“

“I was just there from Ohio on the way to Wildwood, NJ the smashburgers are great! The waitress was wonderful and pleasant. She was blonde forgot to get her name. Great place yummy!“

“The hotel manager at Hampton Inn recommended "What IF" for dinner. He was spot on. Excellent service and our table just off the end of the bar provided a quiet place to enjoy an excellent meal.“

“Server was crazy friendly and funny. He was also fun to talk to and gave me some great advice for what to get for dinner. Also really enjoyed my cocktails. The pineapple mango rum, and the Black Walnut Old Fashioned we're both delicious. Can't wait to go back!“

“Ate dinner there about a week ago. Food was good but their telephone rang at top volume the entire time we were there making it difficult to talk or enjoy our meal. Complained to waitress who said it had to be that way so they could hear in the back for take out orders. The restaurant was far from busy for in house dining so I guess the owner doesn't care about us; only the take out customers! I have eaten here for years and tried to support them during covid but never again.“

“Excellent service. Our server was Billy. Great food.“

“Stopped in because Tröegs was way too crowded. Food was great, beer was even better and I can’t say enough about the service. The bartender was incredibly knowledgeable and super friendly. I have never had better service! Crowd at the bar was great too. Highly recommend!“

“Very sweet! the sandwich menu is out of this world! My boyfriend tried to say you can get a deli to make a sandwich yes but not like mellow minded does! cant wait to go again!“

“Stunning, the staff was amazing! We loved our stay! 5 star“

“Stopped here for lunch with my husband and our daughters. The place was quaint. We had a friendly waitress and our food arrives quickly. I had the chicken ciabatta sandwich with sweet potato fries, my daughter had the chicken Caesar salad, my other daughter had the LBC burger with fries, and my husband had the Cajun Caesar salmon wrap. Everything tasted good and was reasonably priced.“

“Went there for our son’s engagement party with her family, amazing experience and night. Thank you Nick!“

“Somewhat dissapointed. We had been looking forward to trying the new menu items. We ordered one of the bolis. It came out and was so small, almost like a single serving would be. Taste was ok. I expected much more for the $18 charge. Service was nice but we left hungry.“

“Incredible mariachi band! Amazing talent. Great food and atmosphere! Fried ice cream yum.“

“Atmosphere, beers, food, and service are all very good. We had the brisket sandwich and chilli.the sandwich was very dry, but nothing a packet of BBQ sauce couldn't fix. The chilli was surprisingly good and we definitely recommend it. Next time we're ordering two of those.“

“Came here with a group of at least 25 and staff treated us nicely and with efficiency. They served us relatively quickly and the server was super nice. The food was good, my friends got the steak which was a tad bit overcooked, and the mashed potatoes were inedible, and the broccoli was mushy, other than that, very decent food. We also had people get the Black Peppered Seared Tuna Steak which was decent, and the Philly Cheese Steak Potato which was said to be amazing. I got the Old Bay seasoned traditional wings which were delicious. The fries were also very fresh. They also had some arcade games and slot machines. Overall, decent sports bar👍“

“Unfortunately did not get to try the food, but we ended our night at the Lucky Duck with Jason who was courteous, humorous, and an extreme pleasure to have as our bartender. He made the experience fantastic for a bunch of people from out of town to the point that we want to stop back in to get another round from him soon. Thanks Jason!“

“Took our kids to the water park, got to stay close to water works, great for kids“

“My kids and I stayed Monday-Wednesday. The lodge and water works are gorgeous and clean! Everyone was polite! I got coffee both mornings at the coffee shop! Decently priced and friendly service! The room was a whole different story. We were in the Reese’s tower and everything was outdated, dingy, and dirty. I called 30 min after we got there and they send a young man with a rag and spray bottle. You could not even see in the mirrors, dust was everywhere, crown molding falling apart and pulling off the walls. The tub and sink were chipping and had hair leftover in them. When I walked to the coffee shop you can see the difference when you leave the Reese’s tower and enter kisses tower/hershey tower. I do wish they showed more concern about the condition of the room and update that tower asap. I would never stay in that tower again. It was gross. I do have video and photos.“

“PLAY THE AUDIO FOR THE PIRATES HOME OPENER! Heading to the Hershey Primanti Bros this afternoon around 1:30 PM for the Pittsburgh Pirates Home Opener, featuring ace Paul Skenes against the Mets in what should be an electric nationally televised game. As a proud Pittsburgh fan far from home, I'm strongly encouraging - actually, straight-up urging - the staff to make sure the audio is turned up loud on the Pirates broadcast. Let's hear those calls, the crowd energy, and every Skenes strikeout! Primanti Brothers is more than just a sandwich spot; it's a Pittsburgh institution. This is your chance to prove that the spirit of the 'Burgh travels with you, even in Hershey. We all know that if it were a Phillies game, places like Chickie's & Pete's would have the volume blasting without question. Today's the day to show the same love for the Pirates - turn that audio on, crank it up, and let the black and gold energy fill the place. Can't wait to grab a sandwich, of course, and cheer on Skenes and the Bucs. Let's go Bucs! Show me that true Pittsburgh hospitality and loyalty today.“

“I’ve eaten here a couple of times before, today was my second time and not only was the food good, our waitress, Kasey, was amazing! Super kind and helpful. I’d definitely love to come back here sometime.“

“Megan was very friendly and brought our food to the table with a great sense of humor and excellent service! Our dinner was yummy with a type of chocolate on all the dishes. The ferris wheel of desserts was so delicious! Thank you, Megan!“