42 Best Pizza Restaurants near Midway

“My family placed a large order with Knucklehead's today. The food was delivered within forty-five minutes and was piping hot. Everything was great, but the pepperoni roll, stromboli and fried ravioli were absolutely amazing. As an added bonus, the woman who delivered was incredibly sweet.“

“1st timer. Pizza was delicious! Crust amazing! And the young lady at the counter was so sweet and told us all about the pizza and answered questions. Really seems to enjoy what she does! Refreshing!“

“Best pizza in Moon hands down! I've tried many in the area and this is by far my favorite. Don't let the dated exterior fool you...this place is amazing for traditional pizza!“

“Best pizza I’ve ever had outside of a place on Lake Como in Italy“

“I got a humble pepperoni pizza from here, but it was the best I've had in years. I could tell they really put in attention to detail on this. They even added some cheese onto the pepperonis! It was perfectly baked and crispy. The crust was a bit chewy but not so much to detract from the overall quality. Will definitely be getting pizza from here in the future.“

“Family was in Pittsburgh over the weekend and we had Speedies Pizza. It was very good and the breadsticks were amazing. Highly recommend if you're in the area“

“Angelina's is a reliable quick option for our plant. They always provide prompt hot pizza. My personal favorite make your own is white pizza with feta and gyro meat! Thanks for always coming through for our team here at Niagara.“

“Good pizza and hoagies served up by great people...“

“Always amazing food and great people. Just had the personal deep dish pan and it’s amazing. The salad and Italian hoagies are the best around!!“

“Dean and. I get pizza whenever we are in headed to PPMS! Bob makes THE best white pizza. Bar none. Fiori's on 19 is a close second, but not worth the money, really. I will never get white pizza anywhere else but Don's because I just end up disappointed. Thanks, Bob, for hooking us up and never giving me the "roach ends" .“

“If you’re looking for consistently great pizza, Pizza Bella in Moon Township is our go-to every single time. The pizza is always fresh, cheesy, and cooked just right, and the menu has plenty of solid options beyond pizza too. Orders are ready when they say they will be, the staff is friendly, and the quality never misses. Reliable, delicious, and exactly what you want when the pizza craving hits. Highly recommend Pizza Bella.“

“This is by far my favorite pizza joint! Anytime family or friends come to visit I choose this place to wow them. Today's Pizza was a slice above the rest! It was Sunday March 23rd and we picked up the pizza at about 3:20. The name on the receipt was Brenden. This man is truly a pizza artist!!! We always get the extra large Peppadew pizza and today this pizza really hit the spot. Brendan not only fully covered the pizza, but he kept the peppers whole, which elevated this pizza even more. Great job! This man deserves a raise!!!!“

“Delicious pizza! Ready on time!“

“This is my review from Yelp for the new CASTLE SHANNON LOCATION. The pizza pops! I mean that in a great way and wanted to start the review out by saying so. I was excited when I saw the 'coming soon' sign. I've never had their pizza before but looking at the website, the pictures were enticing. I even called the number for the CS location. I got Greg who was in there doing last minute stuff. He told me when they were opening, he was really nice about it. So let's get to the pizza, shall we? It's square. The crust is light, crispy and flavorful. The sauce is ZEE best (See how I did that there). I love square pizza and I go to other areas to get it because we haven't had good square pizza since Jim's back in the early 90s. Now we have Jimmy Z's and I couldn't be more thrilled. Having grown up in the city, it was a staple and a treat to go to another pizza place. I won't say the name, but it sounds like Leedos. Where they have square pizza and cold cheese on top. I would go there despite the numerous times they were out of pizza (Yep no lie) and the staff just needs to attend "Sunshine is Us' school of customer service. But I put moody teens aside and trudged there. Now, no more. I don't have to. I get better pizza from Jimmy Z's and ... and I get service with a smile. They are so polite and welcoming. I also tried one of their Zoagies. If you get one, get it with everything. They're absolutely ZEElicous. When I find a place I like, I am like an old faithful dog. These people are gonna get tired of me.“

“Down home traditional Mom and Pop Pizza!!!...
This establishment has been there for close to 30 yrs!!!
The white pizza, garlic and tomatoes is so delicious!!! oozing with buttery garlic white sauce on a thin crispy crust where it counts!! Tomatoes sweet and soft melting into cheesy goodness!!
Delicious!!!
Also wanted to try their hot sausage hoagie!!!...
They buy their ingredients local...
right down road, persay....
and that payoff of freshness comes out in this hot sausage flavor with a punch of real authentic spice!!!...love everything about this!!!
Bread was just right!!!...
Sauce was bangin!!
I used to live in this area, came to pay a visit, and I must say...this establishment hasn't parted ways with their original ingredients!!!!...like most eateries do over the years!!!
When I pass thru again, I will definitely stop here!!!!
Thank You!!!!
For staying 'faithful' to your name!!!!

I“

“Delicious food, great prices, and the best people running this place. Highly recommend to all! You will not be disappointed. Thank you!“

“Every time we come here the pizza is great and so is the cheesey breadsticks with red sauce my wife absolutely loves it when we order here to the point where we try once a month to make it tradition to always get pizza from here absolutely love it

Parking: Plenty of parking behind the building“

“I've lived in this area almost 14 years tried my 1st pie here and could not believe I've never tried it.100% my favorite pizza in the area.ty.“

“FANTASTIC! My partner and I hadn't been to this location in years. We couldn't agree on what to have for dinner so we decided to try Milano again. I'm so glad we did.

I got the Ranchero Steak with fries on the side. That's what I always used to order and it was always acceptable. This time, however, it was delicious! Perfectly seasoned with just the right amount of sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. Toasted crispy without being hard (it used to be charred). The food has truly been given an upgrade and is reason enough to return!

That said, the service has improved ten fold. The group of people working on Friday (9/26/25) was kind, inclusive and welcoming. They really cared about the food and the customers!

I'd return again and again. But, probably only on Friday because I want the same amazing group that made the end of my day so delightful!“

“Food is really good lately. We love the Philly Steak Pizza!“

“Arleo's Pizza is AMAZING. Their pizza is to die for!! And I'm a bit of a pizza snob lol. The staff is on-task, on-time, friendly and funny! And the prices are quite reasonable. 10/10 I would reccomend.“

“I have had almost everything on Vocelli Pizza's menu and have never been disappointed.“

“Wow! Loved the authentic food“

“our first experience at the christmas pop up was really fun. The decorations and set up looked amazing and it was a very fun atmosphere. The food was excellent but is definitely a shareable portion! However, the only downfall that we did not understand is that if it does not open until 4pm how were people already being sat in the restaurant at 3:30 since reservations are not allowed during these events? The other is while we waited in the bar building that was drinks only, I ordered 2 cokes for my kids, and had to close out and re purchase the same drinks again when our table was called in the restaurant. Alcohol is understandable, but there should be refills on fountain drinks since its all one place. We are going to come back in the summer when we can enjoy the outside, because it looks really relaxing.“

“Had the custom deluxe when we were staying around the corner at the Super 8, and it was incredible!!! Absolutely would recommend!!!“

“They have the best fish sandwiches and other things they deliver after 4pm and FYI there not closing“

“Good food, reasonable prices, and nice staff. Quick service“

“We visit yesterday with friends. There food was literally delicious and staff was very kind“

“Theresa was amazing. She really seemed to make her team have a good time while working. My pizza took a few extra minutes and she compensated me with a beverage (which was not necessary, as I was not an unhappy customer). She seems to go above and beyond to make sure the customer is happy. The atmosphere is just a standard mall style pizzeria but everything else was fantastic! Definitely fresh ingredients on the pizza in the Caprese salad was a treat.“

“The food is delicious! We've been going for years. Love the staff!“

“Had a Christmas party of 25 there, service and food were excellent!! And we stayed later than we should have but they were so gracious about it! Everyone took home leftovers!!“

“I've been ordering from AJ Bambino for almost 8 yrs now. My family & I are regular customers. Their food is amazing. They are very clean. The Philly steak hoagies & spinach pizza are a plus other than the regular pizza & hoagies that we've gotten. The only bummer is the prices went up but I guess they have to in our economy right now.“

“I love pizza and I travel for work constantly. I have eaten pizza in every major city in the US fancy places mom and pop places whatever. I just ordered pizza here and it's fantastic. 1 topping large pizza 10 bucks and its one of the best if not the best pizza I have ever had. It is hands down the best pizza I have ever had for 10 dollars without a doubt. The crust the pepperoni the cheese it's fresh and delicious and I have nothing but good things to say about it. This is the first time I have left a review about something I have eaten in years if not ever so if that doesn't say something I don't know what does. Excellent stuff highly recommend it!!“

“Excited to have the Pretzel Pizza back - even for a limited time? Always order with the app. Receive confirmation immediately with estimated ready time and a code is sent for the Pizza Portal. Quick and easy - pizza always hot, fresh and a good value. Staff very nice and kept very busy. Great neighborhood business!“

“YOU CANNOT HAVE THE PIZZA WITHOUT THE HUT

HEY FOLKS COME ON IN THIS PLACE SUPER FRIENDLY LOTS OF PARKING

THE PIZZA ABSOLUTELY AMAZING

YOU LOVE EVERYTHING ABOUT COMING TO THIS ESTABLISHMENT

THEY HAVE GREAT SPECIALS

FANTASTIC CUSTOMER SERVICE

IT'S ALWAYS A WIN FOR ME

IF YOU'RE SHORT ON A FEW DOLLARS OR YOU JUST WANT TO GET SOMETHING SMALL FOR LUNCH AND QUICK

GRAB YOUR PERSONAL PAN PIZZA WITH A DRINK SPECIAL

IT'S MY GO TO FOR QUICK LUNCH

IF YOU NEVER SANG BEFORE

YOU'LL BE SINGING AND HUMMING COME DINNER TIME

WITH THEIR GOOD TASTING PIZZA AND ALL THE SPECIALTY ITEMS YOU CAN ORDER AS WELL

SUPER AWESOME

HEY MANAGEMENT I LOVE COMING TO SEE YOU GUYS YOU'RE WONDERFUL“

“Excellent service, friendly staff, great food and the prices are definitely the lowest around town! We ordered the Any Day Deal, the pizza was perfect, the steak hoagie was loaded, the breadsticks had two sides of sauce and we had a 2 Liter of coke for our drink and we added an order of sugar fried dough for our sweet tooth!! 😋😋 The driver was fast and friendly and we couldn’t have asked for a better experience! Thank you Fellini’s for making our night!“

“just a great time during the day“

“Amazing Food, Great customer service. Definitely will eat there again!“

“Great pizza great service thanks Jess and Amanda“

“Good food, large portions, reasonabke prices - but slow service“

“LOVE THIS PLACE! We were visiting for work and decided to eat here. First Lena is an amazing server. Friendly, kept our drinks filled and gave us great advice on the menu. This place serves family size portions. So be ready for left overs or plan to share with someone. Highly recommend the Philly Rolls!!“

“I had an incredible experience at Domino's! The service was top-notch, and the staff was friendly and efficient. Special shoutout to Abhinav, who was really nice and made the most amazing pizzas! Each bite was a perfect blend of flavors and the crust was cooked to perfection. Highly recommend this location for a delightful pizza experience. Can't wait to come back!“