7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carnegie

Presutti's Pizza • $
415 Noblestown Rd, Carnegie

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Hot Pepper Pizza
Fresh Cut Curly Fries
Small Pepperoni Pizza
Italian Hoagie Dip
9 Italian Stallion
Chicken Wings
Fried

“We decided to stop in this past Saturday on February 3rd, around 7:00. There was one patron at the bar. We had a group of three and sat at a table. The guy working was fun and personable. He let us know all about the food and helped us in making a decision. We had the dry rub Cajun wings, steak salad and pizza. Everything came out quick was totally amazing! They had a decent beer selection. I will definitely be referring people to try this place out as it was some of the best food we've had at a bar restaurant in a long time! The place is super clean also as well as the bathrooms. They did a lot of renovations in here compared to the many short-lived bars that were in this location previously.“

4.3 Superb87 Reviews
Rennerdale Corner Store Pizza • $
148 Noblestown Rd, Carnegie

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Onion Rings

“Been going here for years as a Rennerdale resident and the Corner Store is a neighborhood institution.The pizza is fantastic, especially the buffalo chicken ranch (BCR). I can actually remember when it was under previous ownership when I was a little kid and people a joked about the corner store pizza but ever since maybe 10-15 years ago it has been excellent. The owner is really nice and seeing her friendly face helps to keep Rennerdale’s Mayberry feel. We’re very proud to have the Corner Store as our local spot.Their hoagies are also great! Haven’t tried every item but if you’re around, definitely order a BCR - and get a large size; you’ll want a few slices.“

4.5 Superb21 Reviews
Slice on Broadway Pizza • $
108 E Main St, Carnegie

Customers` Favorites

New York Style Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Cheese Steak Pizza
Garlic Knots
Athena Pizza
White Pizza
Steak Hoagie

“Big disappointment! Have always gotten good pizza here, this time was different. Ordered pick up online, arrived 10 minutes before time given for order to be ready. Pizza was ice cold and hard, Hoagie was no better, cold, hard and toppings wilted. Obviously had been sitting for a while, very disappointing!“

4.2 Good41 Reviews
Sunset Pizza & Grille Pizza • $
38 E Main St, Carnegie

Customers` Favorites

French Bread Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Hoagie
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Peperoni
Seafood Pizza
Plain Pizza
Tiramisu
Hummus
Wings
Gyro

“I absolutely love ordering from here! The food is delicious and the delivery driver is great! He is so friendly and will go out of his way to make you feel like you are apart of the sunset pizza family! Thank you for the consistency with delivery. If you haven’t tried this place yet, you are absolutely missing out!“

4 Good51 Reviews
Raya's Pizzeria Pizza • $
401 E Main St, Carnegie

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Salad
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Mediterranean Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Breaded Cauliflower
Large Deluxe Pizza
Vegetarian Calzone
Breaded Mushrooms
Provolone Sticks

“Rayas pizza offers great food at reasonable prices. Food comes out fast and I've never been disappointed by an order from this restaurant. Staff is friendly and the menu has many options.Only downfall is the small parking lot. There are only about 4-5 spots off the main road, but I usually don't have a problem finding a spot.“

4 Good33 Reviews
Pizza Americana Pizza • $
1917 E Railroad St, Heidelberg

Customers` Favorites

Spinach Tomato Feta Pizza
Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
Italian Calzone
Breadsticks
Wings

“I LOVE PIZZA AMERICANA! Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life! They also have other great stuff besides pizza. Their wings are phenomenal too and easily the best wings I’ve ever had as well and thats saying something. I don’t drive and it’s kind of a distance for me but anytime I am out that way I always make it a point to stop and get food. Never had a bad meal or experience. The service is always wonderful with the employees always being super nice and fun to talk to.“

4 Good31 Reviews
Tomatoes II Pizzeria Pizza • $
1069 Washington Ave, Carnegie

Customers` Favorites

Hot Pepper Cheese Balls
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Philly Steak Hoagie
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Chicken Wings
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Breadsticks

“I stopped by with some friends and tried this little place at lunch since it was close to us. We are all glad we did! Where to start?The pizza...we ordered a large with pepperoni. Very solid pizza. The pepperoni was the nice cup variety and had a little char on the edges. Boy it was good. We almost ordered a second one but we knew we had more food coming. The cheese was fresh and had a great pull. The flavor was balanced and darn near perfect!The wings...these are the wing ding variety and are breaded. Did I say they are huge? Cooked perfectly and the 2 flavors we got, BBQ and Garlic Parm were perfect. Btw the ranch dressing was outstanding!The cheesy bread sticks...when I say cheesy I mean cheesy! The cheese stretches as long as your arms. Btw, it's the same with the pizza when we ate it. The dipping sauce was a perfect compliment and did not disappoint.The employees were extremely friendly and I can't recommend this place any more highly. All in all it was a very pleasant experience. I love finding these hidden gems and am glad we stopped.“

3.8 Good37 Reviews
Loading...
map Map