7 Best American Restaurants near Milroy

Ye Olde Hotel American •
236 N Main St, Milroy
4.9 Superb7 Reviews
New Lancaster Valley Wilderness Lodge American • $
20 Jack Pine Cir, Milroy

Customers` Favorites

Wings and Fries
Thunder Fries
Turkey Club
Hamburger

“Basic bar with a woodsman theme, but the food was fantastic and I was able to have a fancy cocktail (James and the Giant Peach). The wait and bar staff were shorthanded but made sure we were well taken care of. Highly recommend their Mac and cheese, boneless chicken, and ribs.“

4.2 Good28 Reviews
Revival Kitchen American • $$$
64 S Main St, Reedsville - 3.51 miles

“The overall experience was enjoyable, but may not be for everyone. Plan on a couple hours at least. Food was very well done. Meal is served as multiple courses brought out over time. For each course you pick one of 2-3 pre prepped options. Atmosphere was quiet and reserved, decor was mild- food is the main attraction. Staff was polite. Cost was high but fair given the experience and quality. I would highly recommend for foodies & discourage someone looking for a quick, economic meal.“

4.8 Superb13 Reviews
The Sticky Bun Cafe Cafe • $
310 S Main St G, Yeagertown - 5.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Choice of Bacon or Sausage
2 Eggs Toast Home Fries
Patty Melt and Fries
Loaded Omelette
Corn Beef Hash
2 Eggs & Toast
Cinnamon Roll
One Pancake
Sticky Bun
Mess Wrap

“This was a great stop during a long road trip with 2 little kids. Service was lovely, and food was great. We stopped for lunch, and burgers, blt, soups, and patty melts were delicious and a bang for the buck. Will remember to stop again when nearby!Kid-friendliness: Nice kids menu, spacious and clean bathrooms.“

4.8 Superb17 Reviews
Big Daddy's Grill-N-Chill American • $
1014 W 4th St, Lewistown - 8.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mac Attack Burger w Fries
Crab Cake Dinner
Chicken Wings
Buffalo Wings

“Good food for a reasonable price. Great atmosphere and great service.Parking: Plenty of parking on side and rearKid-friendliness: Kids welco.e with a pretty good kids menuWheelchair accessibility: No wheelchair obstacles in or out of the bldg“

4.6 Superb49 Reviews
Seven Mountains Wine Cellars and Stonefly Cafe Wine Bar • $$
6 N Main St, Reedsville - 3.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger
Catch of the Day
Creme Brulee
Just Peachy
Fish Taco

“First time visitor, I ordered the Pittsburgher with pasta salad. The sandwich was stacked 1/2 a foot tall! The "side" of pasta salad, could have very-well been a main dish! Our server was very attentive and explained menu questions we had. The atmosphere was ambient with an industrial theme along with some trophy mounts of local trout on the walls. I forgot to mention a cute little vase of fresh flowers on each table, rounded out the entire experience.“

4.6 Superb34 Reviews
Homan's General Store-Potters American • $
125 Old Fort Rd, Spring Mills - 5.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sandwich

“Homan's General store and gas station is a small business operated by friendly staff and the most friendly owner. Brenda, Is the most wonderful person who is always working her butt off and eager to hear what's going on in your life and talk to you. I have come to appreciate this so much over the last year as I have been having trouble in my life and I don't believe she understands how much of an impact she made on my life. This is a gas station I will go out of my way to go to just to support the business. The service is what you would expect from a small business with only a few workers at a time. So sometimes there is a slight delay in counter convenience but trust me it is so worth the wait. The food is fantastic and they always have such unique options. As for the ambiance of the store when I step into there I feel like I am walking into my mom's house. I feel safe, and at home. I mean who wouldn't enjoy feeling like that. With all this being said I admire and appreciate this place because it is exactly what the workers and owner here deserve. Thank you Brenda for all of the hard work you put in and all of the support and talks you have given me over the last months. It has been very appreciative. I want to state I am from Spring Mills, PA my address is not accurate on the yelp page so please do not assume this is a fake post. I know Brenda personally. Well at least through her business.“

4.5 Superb25 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More In Milroy

map Map