38 Best American Restaurants near New Wilmington

“A couple of nights ago I was at the restaurant with two other people. Wonderful ambience , exceptional service. I am only giving this one negative comment so that someone would be aware that the kitchen staff needs to be educated to make the dishes match what the menu states. We had an appetizer and each of us ordered a different meal. The others meals were excellent and perfectly done. I ordered the stuffed sweet potato with a special topping and crispy shallots. The skin on the bottom of the baked sweet potato was burned. No big deal I could scrape the potato away from that. The shallots, however, were not even close to crispy. They were soggy, limp and bitter. I was disappointed but did not want to make a fuss In front of my friends. We had tasty cocktails and I repeat excellent service. I will be back and will recommend the Tavern to friends.“

“We enjoy visiting locally owned restaurants and diners. Ryders sets the gold standard for hospitality, food and comfort. If you are looking for a slice of what America should be stop and visit.“

“Thank you for the delicious chicken dinner you prepared for all the employees of the Last Minit Mart. It is greatly appreciated and enjoyed by all of us.“

“A charming delightful diner. The menu is awesome, a wide variety of choices. I got an omelette. Best one I've had in a long time. Excellent value. Delicious food. Great service too ! Wish I found this place sooner. I'll definitely be back.“

“Venessa makes the kitchen a professional personable experience . Second time in and still trying to things out but first time through was excellent and it is a pleasure to see good work ethic.“

“We haven’t been to Rachael’s in awhile Amy was such a great Waitress (32years). We went for my wife’s Birthday. We both got the 8oz. Sirloin Steak with 6 beautiful Shrimp! Wow! The Chef prepared everything to perfection! We brought half of it home and had it with our eggs for breakfast. We highly recommend Rachael’s. I was shocked to find out that John McKinley passed away last August. I did flooring for Marett’s for 32 years and worked in all of his restaurants and his home he was always kind to us and we became friends. What an excellent group of Restaurants. Thank you all.“

“2 nights before Christmas, we got right in and served quickly. The atmosphere here is awesome if you like rustic cabin/ski resort feels. Make no mistake though, its a top notch restaurant. Lexi was our waitress and she was so polite, gracious and quick. They have an asset in her attention to detail, recommendations and just overall making us feel welcome. The menu is not huge but there's something for everyone. We had the full rack of ribs with asparagus, a grilled chicken salad, two red wines and a seasonal Cinnamon Whisky Sour. Everything was delicious, cooked well, and that whisky sour was wow-memorable. We usually go to Rachel's down the road (owned by the same company) but will definitely start going here more often! Thanks for a great night out!“

“We love the upside down cones... You have to get it upside down in a cup because even the small is HUGE! There is no way you can eat it on the cone without it melting all over everything... ❤❤❤❤ We actually started getting our dinner there as well... Awesome burgers and dog... that's all we have try but the list of yummy things go on and on..“

“Food was very good and service was excellent.“

“Had a large group in the back room tonight. Our server, Amanda was fantastic! Our drinks were always full, food came out fast and delicious. She offered suggestions, answered questions and even got in with us on teasing my husband. We had an amazing experience and will be back soon“

“we had dinner here this afternoon. We had the steak and a baked potato. Our waiter was Nickolas. He was very attentive. Our steaks were cooked exactly the way we ordered them. Loved the bread and garlic butter.“

“I am a hot dog connoisseur. These Chili dogs are A+ Just the right about of kick to the Chili! 5 stars!! I’ll be back!!“

“We went there for the first time and it was excellent. We had fried cod, very healthy portion of fish, real fries! Service was excellent. It's all farm to table, food is really fresh, salad was great. Thursday is Walleye night! We will definitely go back. Prices were reasonable for the portion you receive.“

“1st visit here. Nice little sub shop.

I had the fish with mushrooms (which I shared with my chauffeur for the day). Tom had a 3 meat sub and was very happy with it.

You need to try them out. But make it early they close at 2pm.“

“Just came from another fabulous dinner. Never had a bad meal and quite frankly, Talbots is ruining other restaurants for me. Soooooooo good!“

“There’s really nothing negative to say about this place. They’re fast at getting the food out to you once you place the order. The food is fantastic! Some of my favorites consists of the chicken nugget snack, which they have some of the best nuggets. The pizza egg rolls once in a while, are good! The subs are great! They are always filled with fresh bread, meats, condiments, etc. The price is also worth what you pay for! Not too expensive for what you’re buying! Definitely worth it.“

“I would like to compliment Timary...a wonderful team member and her super attitude and service every time I go thru the pickup window at Eat 'n Park..........She is an outstanding member of your team and I value her service...always has a pleasant smile and is so friendly...my order is always perfect. SHE'S THE BEST!!!!!“

“Highly recommend them for their wings! We visit often to also play darts and hang out. Highly recommend the Jai Alai if you’ve not ever been, you won’t be disappointed!“

“first time at the restaurant excellent service awesome atmosphere top three chicken parm dinner I've ever had“

“Great food and friendly staff. Our family go to for hot dogs and sandwiches.“

“We love this place and it never disappoints.....the Florentine Pizza is absolutely amazing! The staff is very friendly and Stacie is an awesome waitress!“

“Waitresses are always on top of everything, and the food is great! They have reasonable prices, and one of the few places that have really good coffee in town! It is all around a great restaurant for breakfast and lunch!“

“Not a huge menu, but the food was good. Steak was slightly smaller than expected but good (menu doesn't list a weight), and the burgundy steak sandwich was also very good (the au jus was thicker, but worked well). Bonus was the live jazz quartet!“

“After being asked if I needed a nipple for my drink, i finished it and subsequently had to wait 4.5 seconds for my icy cold beverage to be refilled! If there was a negative score I give it. As it is I can say 0 out of 10, would not recommend!“

“This was our first time visiting and we will definitely be back! Valerie was so friendly and helpful! The food was delicious! We had the lamb dinner, lasagna roll-ups, and filet tip sandwich - made with locally-sourced meats and vegetables! 10/10 recommend!“

“VERY CLEAN ! AFFORDABLE VERY! MEALS JUST LIKE HOME COOKED , VERY GOOD MENU ! DAILY SPECIALS ! FAMILY SETTING, PEOPLE ARE VERY NICE! WOULD RECOMMEND FIVE STARS!!!“

“Stopped in today, with my family. I was using a knee scooter, from a recent surgery. They only had two young ladies working. I must say Haven was amazing. She seated us immediately in a great spot seeing my scooter. She was running food, seating customers, taking care of the delivery pick ups and manning the bar. She did all this while being pleasant with a smile on her face. This girl deserves 👏. My appetizer was great but the main course not so much. I'm not sure if the kitchen was short staffed. I didn't say anything because of how crazy it was. That is the only reason I didn't give 5 stars today.“

“We come here every year when we are Christmas shopping and also my birthday( it’s a family tradition for the past 10 years ) . Every time we come this place is amazing. The food and the service. However today was the cherry. Our server was phenomenal and our food was the best. We just wanted to say thank you. It’s hard to find service like we had and food that is made that well. Our server was Kelly R. She is amazing! My husbands filet was cooked to a perfect rare , my fish and chips was excellent. My 10 year old tried clam chowder today for the first time and each bite he made a “mmmmm” sound. He loved it. Thanks to all involved in an excellent experience“

“nice place awsome staff will return again“

“Very good brews. The steak was perfect. Service was top notch and knowledgeable. Patronage were very friendly. A+“

“Ate here last night, had chicken tenders on special 85 cents each and the $1 homemade chips!! Deliscious!! Sauces for tenders were awesome, and chips were thick and crispy. Can’t beat it, stop by, friendly people and under new management!! You won’t be disappointed.“

“Very good experience“

“Food was excellent with ribs always fall off the bone good. Server was very attentive checking often to be sure everything was good. You must try the chocolate chip dessert made with premium ice cream on a warm cookie and drizzled with chocolate syrup.“

“No, I would not recommend. I waited before writing this review hoping that I would get a call back from the manager. I left 2 requests for him to call me and haven't heard anything back. My husband and I were there on a Saturday for lunch. Our food was ok and service was fine. I ordered takeover for my mom, a hamburger with nothing but raw onion on it. We finished our lunch and waited a long time for the takeout. My mom called the next day to thank me. She said they remembered the raw onion, unfortunately there was no hamburger, just the bun and raw onion. We love to support local businesses, however we will not be going back to The Crane Room. I didn't expect a free meal or even credit. However an apology would have gone a long way.“

“I will honestly be the first to tell ya, this restaurant is fine, just how I feel ,not just this location but every one I have been too. I just wanted to say my husband and I came to this restaurant for a few beers and some apps!! I will tell you, this is the best service we had at this particular location, our waitress was so great!! I just got out the receipt our waitress was Jessica R!!! I called in and gave a great review and we do not know her so it’s not bias, but I think people mostly call in to complain, so hopefully the manager reaches out to give you the credit for what you deserve … working hard does pay off!!“

“We recently had breakfast at the New Castle site. Even though the waitress was the only server there she was pleasant and friendly. Thank you Denise for making our experience a good one. You deserve a raise.“

“My dad n I went on thanksgiving. The food was not n fresh n tasty. The resteraunt was extremely busy, but nothing was ever empty. The service was spot on, kept tables clean and drinks filled. Every worker n patron had smiles on their faces.“

“Excellent service. Good very good“