13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newville

“We just stopped on May 24 2025 to grab a bite..we had gotten two subs. the bread was fresh as well as all the fixins..We are not from this area...the next time we come thru..this is definitely a stop.. Thank you...“

“we where there on Saturday night and we had a problem with my sandwich thank God I seened it and the staff maid it right we really loved the food very friendly staff the owner is awesome he took the time for a child. awesome place. 5 stars“

“We just stopped on May 24 2025 to grab a bite..we had gotten two subs. the bread was fresh as well as all the fixins..We are not from this area...the next time we come thru..this is definitely a stop.. Thank you...“

“Great place for some good pie.
Very nice staff and can remember your order after 2 times being there (I was impressed). Depending on time a year parking can be a challenge but don't let that stop you. My opinion best pizza in the burg.“

“I’m from out of town and was staying in Shippensburg and was looking for some pizza for dinner. I found reviews and decided to try Pizza Man. I placed my order online, very simple process and you can customize everything. I didn’t do delivery, I did carry out, as it was 3 mins from my hotel. I ordered the Sicilian pizza with everything no olives and bacon cheese fries with ranch. The pizza was amazing and the size was great for the price. The Sicilian pizza is huge. From the dough to the toppings everything was fresh and the tomato sauce wasn’t overpowering either. The bacon cheese fries were hot, fresh, and cheesy with a homemade ranch to dip them in. My family and I all agreed this was the best pizza we’d ever ate and wished that our pizza down home tasted like this. If you’re looking for a great pizza place, then choose Pizza Man, you won’t regret it!“

“food is good, but had cheesesteak sub yesterday, and wasn't crazy about that. roll wasn't good. then I find out they're using pizza dough for their "homemade " rolls now“

“I went to shippensburg domino's on Tuesday 12/30 around 3pm there was only 1 poor girl making pizzas and answering phones and cahing out orders! That poor girl! Later a delivery girl came and helped. These girls DESERVE A RAISE! she kept her cool and was very polite...I'm in the food industry and I would have been losing it! How dare you don't give them enough help! Im sure the managers that get paid more were at home! GET JOB GIRLS!!!“

“I only order from this papa John’s location.
The workers are very good very polite

They fix any problems.

I recommend anybody else to also order from this location

Very trustworthy“

“Alfredo's, in my opinion, has the best pizza in Shippensburg. Having been a customer for more than a few years now, they are a part of my routine and are an appreciated member of the community. Everyone has their favorite, and that's fine, but Sal and his team are my first pick. Small business is the best business to support.“

“Stopped here before our boys football game and the food and service is AMAZING. Highly recommend.“

“If you're looking for place where you can be yourself and get something to eat for good prices and the surrounding of what I would say a friendly welcoming atmosphere well at least welcoming to those who are around the area. Don't take that as a bad thing it's the comfort of home the feeling of familiarity. But if you're not from the area there's enough space and kind people to welcome you either way.“

“Love the pepperoni tavern pizza“

“Stopped by on our trip down. Amazing service and super quick. The food was delicious and amazing presentation. We had the Philly wonton, chop chop chicken salad and the the garlic bread burger. All three were absolutely perfect. The chicken and burger were cooked perfectly. The servers were very attentive and made sure we had a great time while we were there“