50 Best Italian Restaurants near Old Forge

“Outstanding dinners for our party of 6. Service was excellent and atmosphere phenomenal. 5🌟 Restaurant“

“first time here tonight based on my dates recommendation..very happy with our dinners and the service..I got the gnocchi with meat sauce and she got a chicken caesar salad I believe..both large portions . Will definitely be back“

“Fantastic place! Super nice server, plus the owner stopped by to go over some choices. We ordered toasted ravioli, rosemary chicken, veal and peppers(all excellent) and the home run of the evening, manicotti made with a crepe. Pricing was moderate/low, for the quality.

Parking: Parking in rear.“

“Great food ! Love the antipasto , ravioli , gnocchi , calamari & pizza“

“I got 2 trays of red pizza with anchovies & the pizza was Absolutely Scrumptious. Pizza was phenomenal. Loved it! Everything was perfect even though I ordered out. Order was ready when I got there & just the smell, I couldn't wait to get home to have a piece. Sheer Perfection.“

“First solid food my kid ever had was white pizza from here when I was working in the area and her mom brought her by to see me. Afterwards, we always made it a stop when we were in the area. 40 years later I stopped by on Easter after a funeral in Rochester. Mike was gracious enough to heat us up a half tray of double crust white to go. Still amazing Pizza! Like no other. You gotta stop here.“

“Ordered from las vegas. Everything was perfectly packaged and fresh. Great customer service. Quality was as we remembered it. It was great to have a taste of home. Will definitely order again“

“Extraordinary is an understatement. This establishment is phenomenal in every aspect, from its atmosphere to the family ownership, cuisine, and pricing. I highly recommend Anthony's with absolute certainty, and I appreciate supporting small, family-owned businesses.  #LoveMyFamilia“

“The food is super delicious and the service is excellent.“

“We ate there for the first time , the atmosphere and staff where great.Quick service food was great will be back again soon.“

“This place is phenomenal!! The food is incredible, the service is top-notch, and the atmosphere is elegant yet comfortable. It has quickly become my favorite restaurant in the area. Would recommend x a million! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Blessed & grateful to celebrate my son’s birthday dinner at Grico's! The Chef Bill crab cake and the Ribeye were outstanding! Such a welcoming team there too!“

“Wonderful service and making our meal special“

“The food is excellent! I've been going there since I was a kid with my dad, which is a long time! I'm a fan of their Texas Weiners. If you haven't tried one, you're missing out!

Parking: They have two parking lots.“

“My husband and I decided to try this place for the first time and we were amazed! We started with potato pancakes, calamari, and the mozzarella en Carozza and it was like it was touched by the hand of God it was so delicious! Then I had the pretzel chicken with the mashed potatoes and the green beans! I've been looking for pretzel chicken done this way all over the valley and this is the only place that does it the way I like it with the mustard sauce. My dinner also came with a soup and I chose the Italian wedding and it tasted better than mine! My husband had the Joseph's double stuffed crust pizza with pepperoni added on top and we've had other double stuffed crust white pizzas before and this one is at the top of the list! We're definitely coming back and we will be bringing friends and family! Thank you so much for the amazing experience and our waitress was absolutely fantastic and extremely attentive!“

“Just love the place.Food is excellent“

“Fantastic place. Been ordering from Saccos since they opened. Just ordered the October special, cheese steak pizza, delicious. Also the October special od butternut nut squash is delicious. Thank you for a wonderful menu.“

“we had Chicago style pizza. was excellent!! Highly recomend!!!“

“Tried this eatery last night on my friend Carolyns recommendation who is a frequent diner. Could not have had a better experience! highly recommend as we will be back sooner than later! Yum!“

“This pizza is great!!! GO ORDER SOME LOL its seriously that good �“

“Illiano's is by far the best restaurant in the valley. There's something for everyone on the menu. Order the sicilian marinara pizza...thick crust, fresh tomatoes, garlic and plenty of cheese. If you're not happy, it's on you. It's definitely not the food“

“The service was excellent—our waitress Danny was friendly and attentivel. The burrata was hands down the best we’ve had—creamy, fresh, and crunchy pistachios on top. We also tried the chicken parmesan and the pork chop. The pork chop had a nice crunch on the outside, though we felt it could use a bit more seasoning inside. The Albariño white wine was a perfect pairing, it is not easy to find Spanish wine around.“

“This was the best meal I've had since I've lived in Scranton, I've been here 23 yrs. We got the Delmonico steak the chef did such an amazing job, the service was great, the atmosphere was beautiful so relaxing really enjoyed it ! Definitely going back !!“

“Just dined here tonight for the first time. It was wonderful! Our server, Abigail was professional and friendly. The food was fantastic. The Brooklyn Bomber pizza was terrific and the duck wings couldn’t have been better! I’ll definitely be back & recommend this place to anyone in the area!“

“Always wonderful! Today we had the maple toffee cake with cream cheese icing for dessert. Fabulous!“

“Absolutely wonderful food and service. Angela was super attentive and extremely pleasant. We love everything about this place“

“Abbiocco is one of my favorite spots to eat, it’s a hidden gem in Clark’s Summit! From the homemade salad dressings to the generous sized entrees and don’t get me started on the house made desserts! Everything is always fantastic!“

“Best Pizza and Meat Sauce!! Mike the owner is a true gentlemen owner and the bar tender Donna is wonderful. I can’t wait to come back and try more!!“

“The best around, we have had many dinners and celebrations here from wife’s wedding shower, children’s baptisms and both on/off site catering. Always treated like family when we are there“

“We ordered the Gramma Sicilian tonight.....Excellent!! The crust was perfection! The blend of sauce, cheese and pesto was the best Gramma pizza I've ever had. The gentleman who handled my order was so welcoming and friendly also! Thank you!“

“Best Zuppa Di Clams anywhere! Friendly staff, fair prices and real Italian/Sicilian meals.“

“This is a lovely restaurant for a special occasion or for any excuse to go and have a lovely meal. If you are there in the summer, get the long hots - they are amazing. The staff is always super friendly while still maintaining decorum. We always have a great time here, and the food is wonderful.“

“A nice little place that has been in the downtown for close to 20 years. You enter through the bar that is roomy while also having hightop tables. When entering main dining, the first thing we noticed was the piano player, which is a super-cool touch! He played some fun songs, including some of his own, cracked jokes, and also interacted with the crowd while not being intrusive at all. My wife and I each got a martini (Dirty Gin for her and Honey Nut Cheerio for me) and both were delicious. As an appetizer, we got Eggplant Melanzane, which was light, had great flavor, and a delicious vodka sauce. My better half had a Caesar salad with probably the best Caesar dressing we have ever had. I went with the gorgonzola salad that had a nice, tart raspberry vinaigrette. For our entrees, she had the chicken special, which featured thin chicken breast and portobello mushrooms in a port wine sauce, topped with gorgonzola. It was very earthy and deep, a worthy special. I had the Pollo Sambuca, which is the same thin chicken breast with shrimp and mushrooms in a creamy sambuca sauce. It was very flavorful and slightly sweet. The anise is there, but not distracting. This was a solid meal! Our server, Thellenza, was attentive and informative. She made sure we understood all of the specials and took care of anything we asked. The rest of the staff is also helpful, too, and we were never in need of anything for long at all. The adult beverages that we enjoyed were definitely tasty, we just wish they had more of a wine and beer selection. Food: 9 Service: 10 Atmosphere: 10 Adult Drink Selection: 8 Overall: 9.25“

“Five-Star Experience at LUCCA Restaurant & Catering! We had an absolutely fantastic experience at Lucca’s celebrating Mother’s Day with my mom and I have to give a huge shoutout to Tori Krappa who truly sets this place apart! Torry is so giving & deeply passionate about everything she does, from the food to the people—she takes the time to personally greet tables, and ensures everyone feels like a regular! Everything was delicious, right down to the dessert- the cherry nut cake was outstanding! Highly recommended!“

“My family and I had some friend over Saturday evening and wanted to keep it simple with pizza. Our order was a plain, pepperoni and a grandma. As usual every pie was so fresh and delicious. My favorite will always be the grandma, just the right amount of pesto oil, thin and crispy. While I forget his name, the tall gentleman with glasses, who I assume is the manager, is always so polite and keeps things moving behind the counter. Dino’s will always be a pizza that I enjoy and highly recommend!!!!“

“amazing place to eat, great service and great food. amazing customer service.“

“Last night a waitress here clearly tried to rob us! I paid $45 cash then wanted to put the rest on my card. She came back said the card machine was broken ( no big deal) My dad handed her a $50 bill&she never brought his change back. I asked her for a receipt to show we paid, she gave me a song and a dance about having to go write up another receipt. We had already been there for 2 hours & I had to leave, on my way way home I realized I forgot to leave tip on table so I called to give my cc info to leave the tip. later that evening I got a call back saying I never fully paid the bill. That waitress took his $50 and pocketed it!! When I spoke to her on phone she flat out lied!!, even though I told her (after I paid) that she never gave him the change she even said (oh I owe you whatever the amount was) She said we never gave her the $50!?! my elderly dad clearly pulled it out of his wallet & handed it to her. Thankfully Christine the manager took care of everything for us! Btw it wasn't Wendy she was awesome it was the other lady there on 2/22 evening short dark hair! Needless to say we won't be back! Why would I ask for a receipt or change back if we didn't pay you!?!?!?!?!?!But watch who you hire Sidels... She a bad one!! To try and steal from an elderly man with dementia!?!?! Karma is a b**** girly, I hope your mom is proud of you!! Ty Christine and Wendy for being a great waitress! Food was wonderful! and never had another issue here!“

“I never leave reviews, but I was so impressed by my experience here on Saturday that I just feel like I really have to. My girlfriends and I met here for a girls night over the weekend and every single one of the four of us had nothing but great things to say about the whole evening. The service vibes were IMMACULATE; from the hostess, to the server, to the bartender, everyone added a positive energy to the restaurant. The food and drinks.. MY GAWD. We ordered quite a bit of food for the four of us to share, and there was not one single thing that we didn’t love; seriously, we talked about how good the food was for hours to everyone any anyone who would listen. Its two days later and I’m still talking about it and telling my husband that we need to make a reservation for our next date night. Seriously, one of the best restaurant experiences I have ever had.“

“This is the best tasting pizza you’ll find in and around Scranton and the Mid Valley area HANDS DOWN.

Get a large chicken parm hoagie and thank me later.

If you’re having a party, Calabrias is the best bang for your buck and they don’t even brag about it.

Always on time- I’ve ordered for dozens of parties/ personal and have never waited. I’m sure it happens, but hasn’t to me.“

“Absolutely Fantastic! Angelo was wonderful!“

“Tried Sibio’s for first time today for lunch- definitely worth the drive. Food was very good and prices appropriate. I definitely enjoyed this wonderful Italian restaurant. Decor falls between original 1970s and a little updated - but that was charming and likely kept prices so reasonable. The place was quite busy for an afternoon lunch and service prompt and attentive enough! Highly recommend - we will be back to try more. Everything coming out of the kitchen looked great!“

“The food is always excellent.“

“Please accept me as a friend on Facebook. I want your daily info. I have a new page.“

“Great food, staff, and owners!“

“Super excellent food. The only thing better than the food was the service. Our waitress, Corrine was very accommodating. Even though they did not have a specific cocktail we ordered, she improvised and it was better than we expected. We give 5 stars ! We'd give 10 but the app didn't go that high ! We'll be back !“

“Outstanding Italian Family Service. Great food and prices.“

“Love this place! The owner and the staff are amazing! The Food is always great! My wife and I enjoy everything we have ever had!“

“The chicken Caesar wrap on spinach is always fresh. Garlic parm fries always hit the spot. Friendly staff“

“Stopped twice in a week. First time we tried the vodka sauce square. It was amazing, sauce great crust crispy yet light. Today we tried the trifecta square. Not only was it delightful to look at. It tasted incredible the way the Pesto Marina and vodka sauce came together. The crust was crispy and light again.“

“This is the second time it was dried out. No taste. And the bottled garlic that they are using was so over powering it for Ed it down. And I asked for a little more sauce. When it came. It was all dried. Like it was sitting g under the heat lamp a long time. This is the second time. And it had no taste. Twice . And the prices have gone sky high for. Pasta. 17 for a lousy dish of clams in sauce that had no taste. I’m very sorry we loved co I g here for years. But the food is. O share what it is. Most likely there is no one watching how this is prepared“