50 Best Italian Restaurants near Plains

“Their buffalo chicken wing pizza is to die for! We also love their burgers & salads! Be sure to try the meatball hoagie next time you’re there, you won’t regret it! They are so friendly & the food was ready fast!“

“We ate there for the first time , the atmosphere and staff where great.Quick service food was great will be back again soon.“

“Blessed & grateful to celebrate my son’s birthday dinner at Grico's! The Chef Bill crab cake and the Ribeye were outstanding! Such a welcoming team there too!“

“Saturday 2/8/2025 , wife and i had the pork special , it was outstanding , waitress was outstandind also , i believe it was abby“

“The food is excellent! I've been going there since I was a kid with my dad, which is a long time! I'm a fan of their Texas Weiners. If you haven't tried one, you're missing out!

Parking: They have two parking lots.“

“I just ordered for the first time and I have to say I'm very pleased!!!! Pizza and wings were just the way I liked... The service was awesome and We'll be back for more!!“

“Tried this eatery last night on my friend Carolyns recommendation who is a frequent diner. Could not have had a better experience! highly recommend as we will be back sooner than later! Yum!“

“The Pasta alla Tovalo is an awesome night out. The service is excellent and everything we've ever ordered has been phenomenal. Highly recommend this restaurant.“

“absolutely delicious!! great customer service and great food! We ordered their garlic knot Chicken parm and would highly recommend 🤤“

“My son kept telling me he wanted us to try this restaurant as he lives in the area and he goes there often. It was a hike for us, but we decided to go try it out. There were 6 of us there, and everyone enjoyed their food, but I will speak to what we ordered. My son insisted we try the pizza as an appetizer. I am not really into pizza when I go out to a restaurant, so I was hesitant. When it came out, it was huge. I loved that it was very crisp on the bottom and it was not overloaded with sauce. It didn't have the typical cheese that slides off the pizza when you order it. The owner, Chris, came to check on us to see how we liked it. I thought it was fantastic, but there are a limited number made during the evening so I think you have to get there early. My daughter and I shared the bang bang cauliflower and that was very tasty. There was a lot of it so we ended up taking some of that home. The other appetizer we had were the soul scallops. We all thought this was an amazing appetizer and I loved the combination with the cornbread. We each had a salad before dinner and I personally like the spring mix with tomatoes. It wasn't an overly large salad, but it was a salad was what is was supposed to be: a precursor to dinner. With the portion sizes of the appetizers and the food, we actually ended up taking some of the salad home. My son got the Italian Chicken and Waffles, which was huge. I was give a taste of that and while it was a combination that I did not think would work, it was very good and a creative recipe. My husband had the Surf and Turf Fricassee and he is still talking about that almost a week later. It was a very nice dish and his steak came out the way he asked. He is frequently disappointed when he goes out to eat in other restaurants and is disappointed by how often the steak is overcooked. I had the Alfredo Bay, which again, was a large portion that I ended up taking home and finishing the next day. I was worried that it was going to be a bit too spicy with the Old Bay, but I liked the combination of ingredients so I thought I would give it a try. You can taste the kick, but it wasn't overwhelming thankfully. When talking to the owner, he said that the only dessert they were out of was the Tiramisu (which is one of my favorite desserts). His mom personally makes it so it tends to sell out. Chris.....tell your mother to make more (just kidding). The staff that we interacted with were very personable and friendly. While this was a little over an hour from home, we will definitely be back the next time we are visiting our son!“

“Illiano's is by far the best restaurant in the valley. There's something for everyone on the menu. Order the sicilian marinara pizza...thick crust, fresh tomatoes, garlic and plenty of cheese. If you're not happy, it's on you. It's definitely not the food“

“Had the grandma Pizza for the first time tonight…. Fantastic! Thin and crispy, just the right amount of pesto, and an excellent cheese blend. I will definitely be back!“

“Absolutely wonderful food and service. Angela was super attentive and extremely pleasant. We love everything about this place“

“I had dinner there with friends and everything was super. The food was delicious, and the service was even better. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone who is looking for a great meal and very good waitress and bartender.“

“Outstanding dinners for our party of 6. Service was excellent and atmosphere phenomenal. 5🌟 Restaurant“

“My family and I had some friend over Saturday evening and wanted to keep it simple with pizza. Our order was a plain, pepperoni and a grandma. As usual every pie was so fresh and delicious. My favorite will always be the grandma, just the right amount of pesto oil, thin and crispy. While I forget his name, the tall gentleman with glasses, who I assume is the manager, is always so polite and keeps things moving behind the counter. Dino’s will always be a pizza that I enjoy and highly recommend!!!!“

“first time here tonight based on my dates recommendation..very happy with our dinners and the service..I got the gnocchi with meat sauce and she got a chicken caesar salad I believe..both large portions . Will definitely be back“

“Best Pizza and Meat Sauce!! Mike the owner is a true gentlemen owner and the bar tender Donna is wonderful. I can’t wait to come back and try more!!“

“Had dinner there 9-25-2024 everything was perfect from the waitress to the drinks and the fabulous food. Would definitely recommend eating there. Can’t wait to have my leftovers for lunch.“

“The best around, we have had many dinners and celebrations here from wife’s wedding shower, children’s baptisms and both on/off site catering. Always treated like family when we are there“

“This is a lovely restaurant for a special occasion or for any excuse to go and have a lovely meal. If you are there in the summer, get the long hots - they are amazing. The staff is always super friendly while still maintaining decorum. We always have a great time here, and the food is wonderful.“

“Best Zuppa Di Clams anywhere! Friendly staff, fair prices and real Italian/Sicilian meals.“

“We come here as much as possible. There isn't anything that we have ordered that we didn't love. I love date nights here and the food is out of this world.“

“Great ambience in the downstairs bar. The food (veggie Stromboli) was excellent and the bartenders crafted delicious Christmas cocktails. Will definitely be back to try more on the menu!“

“Perugino’s was terrific. We hadn’t been there in a long time and we will certainly go back. The food was delicious with generous portions. The service and staff was great.“

“Fantastic place! Super nice server, plus the owner stopped by to go over some choices. We ordered toasted ravioli, rosemary chicken, veal and peppers(all excellent) and the home run of the evening, manicotti made with a crepe. Pricing was moderate/low, for the quality.

Parking: Parking in rear.“

“Not impressed! We had a family birthday celebration here for about 25 people. Only 1 server. Waited forever for food & drinks. The server never brought me my meal until last minute(ended up taking home) My niece was served raw chicken. No cranberries for the Cranberry/walnut chicken salad & it didn't smell the best. Fountain soda tasted terrible! No coleslaw offered even though it was part of our meal. No A1 sauce for the steak. Never again!“

“Great food ! Love the antipasto , ravioli , gnocchi , calamari & pizza“

“Please accept me as a friend on Facebook. I want your daily info. I have a new page.“

“I got 2 trays of red pizza with anchovies & the pizza was Absolutely Scrumptious. Pizza was phenomenal. Loved it! Everything was perfect even though I ordered out. Order was ready when I got there & just the smell, I couldn't wait to get home to have a piece. Sheer Perfection.“

“I had my bridal shower at Lucca in July 2024 and it was an absolutely incredible experience. The food was hot and delicious - we did a the brunch buffet with a sandwiches, eggs and the most amazing bananas foster French Toast. The space was clean, modern, and beautifully decorated with some items we brought, but most supplied by their team like linens and centerpieces. The staff was so kind and helpful to all my guests. I truly couldn’t have asked for a better venue for such a special day. Will definitely be keeping them in mind for further events!!“

“Love this place! The owner and the staff are amazing! The Food is always great! My wife and I enjoy everything we have ever had!“

“Great food, staff, and owners!“

“Picked up some slices to go for lunch. The staff was very friendly, the food was good, and was priced right!

The slices were have tossed, plain cheese, pizza. The sauce had a good taste and wasn't too sweet. I added some spices to have some additional flavors, but that is what I specifically like.

As with most places, they have a reward program. I feel as though this is a very fair program (as of 7/2024). I will be making them a part of my "regular places" to eat ?

Thank you to the owners and staff for their hard work, it is appreciated .

Will add photos later.

Parking: Usually more than enough parking for the seating area.“

“it's ok... was way better back in the day but still decent.“

“Good place in town nice people.“

“I took my Love, Maritza here for Valentine's Day. It was very enjoyable except when I ordered the Stuffed Chicken Marsala, it was EXTREMELY salty.( I am an experienced chef and food experimenter. ) so I informed our waitress, who responded quickly and without hesitation offered a fresh plate or change of order.
Shortly after the manager came to the table attempting to change my opinion of how the dish was a Very salty type of preparation.
I again had to stand by my statement about the plating.
Please, Olive Garden, you need a Chef to insure quality going to your customers.
If I was there any other time, I would have just walked out!“

“This is the second time it was dried out. No taste. And the bottled garlic that they are using was so over powering it for Ed it down. And I asked for a little more sauce. When it came. It was all dried. Like it was sitting g under the heat lamp a long time. This is the second time. And it had no taste. Twice . And the prices have gone sky high for. Pasta. 17 for a lousy dish of clams in sauce that had no taste. I’m very sorry we loved co I g here for years. But the food is. O share what it is. Most likely there is no one watching how this is prepared“

“Can't say enough about Pam and her staff. I had an important luncheon that needed to be catered and Pam came in on her day off and prepared a delicious meal for 30 of us. Everyone was courteous, and the food was on time and was prepared to perfection. If your office needs a great meal from a local, non-chain, restaurant look no further than right here.“

“Lemme just tell you, I wanna kiss Giuseppe right now! We ordered subs, wings and pizza and drove it back to Scranton. Everything was fire ?. How have I not eaten here before.? You guys got your s*** together, lemme tell you!! I'll be back, Jack!!“

“Napoli's is great especially when you're on a time crunch! They have several different kinds of slices available and service is fast and friendly. The dining area is super clean, and the pizza is great! Perfect place to pop in on lunch break. They have full pies available too but I love being able to just grab slices!“

“I happened upon Angelo's restaurant by chance and thought it was just a little pizza parlor but instead I found a cute little restaurant a wonderful atmosphere great service and excellent food. I would highly recommend this to everyone whether you're looking to have a quick bite or a leisurely dinner. Angelo's accommodates both. I will definitely be returning.“

“I grew up on Main Street in Old Forge and the Pizza here tastes like it’s from Main Street in Old Forge. Outstanding job!“

“Great service awesome food!definitely will be back !!“

“This restaurant is always busy. Great location. Very nice inside. Small but comfortable bar. I stoped for a small pizza and a draft beer. It was very good. Pricey menu and loyal customers.

Wait staff is excellent and knowledgeable. Dinner special sounded enticing, but I was in a rush.

Looking forward to returning for one of their specials.“

“Getting hoagies from III Guys is CONSISTENTLY hit or miss. Now it's constantly a *miss* so we're done spending money here. I got a turkey hoagie today and there was barely anything on it! 😠 A regular sandwich is thicker! Two slices of turkey, a tiny bit of lettuce, some onions and a couple tomato slices! Oh and it was DRY! We paid for mostly BREAD! Feels awesome to be shafted for what you paid for. I had to put my own Mayo on it, add lettuce and add tomato to fill it! That's NOT the point of take out. Food quality is going DOWN last few years. ((See comments for pics of this sad hoagie)) We're done giving them the benefit of the doubt. The other hoagie we bought was also lacking & dry. Plenty of other good quality restaurants to choose from than wasting money on food that clearly quality isn't a priority. ~Signed Another Unhappy customer“

“I’ve worked in their kitchen, it’s one of the cleanest in the valley. Had their food today it was very good!“

“My family enjoyed everything we ordered (Sicilian & Taco pizza and wings ). Thank you for delivering!“

“I just had the double crust broccoli and a tray of red. Mike and Chris did a great job the pizza was delicious. The staff was also fantastic we will be back.“

“Food was fantastic and cheap! 1 large (2 topping pizza), dozen wings with EXTRA Blue Cheese, and an Italian hoagie for $39. What? In todays day and age? Thats pennies compared to the other guy. The gentleman behind the counter was incredibly polite. Can't wait to be back!“