11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Punxsutawney

Sarah L Defelice Pizza House Pizza • $
611 Myrtle Avenue, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Pizza

“If I was a cat...... this would be my catnip. EXCELLENT Pizza“

4.9 Superb73 Reviews
Punxsy Pizza Pizza • $
115 North Findley Street, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Thursday Medium Pepperoni Pizza Special
Punxsy Burger Pizza
Pizza Steak Taco
Chicken Rancher
Cheese Pizza
Sausage Sub
Bruschetta
Taco Salad

“Currently Dining In, The best Italian Wedge 😋 in town ! Love when I get a chance to eat here! Thank you guys so much!“

4.6 Superb193 Reviews
The Hock's Nest Pizza • $
703 Mill Road, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with One Topping
Pepperoni Pizza

“Best burgers and subs great pizza. Service with a smile.“

4.7 Superb69 Reviews
Wing Street Pizza • $$
21866 US-119, Punxsutawney

“Waitress was really nice n friendly.“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Luigi's Pizza • $
535 East Mahoning Street, Punxsutawney

“If you're in Punxsy and looking for a quick lunch Jen has awesome pizza by the slice on specials every day. Its great pizza and she's pleasant to deal with.

*She offers way more than pizza too, I'll occasionally grab her chicken salads or a sandwich and have always been pleased.“

4.4 Superb36 Reviews
Leila Jo's Cafe & Bakery Bakery • $
246 West Mahoning Street, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch
Sticky Bun
Doughnut
Cupcake
Salads

“The hubby and were over for lunch and I had Charlie's pizza it was delicious and the hubby had the French dip and wedding soup everything was delicious. We will be back.😊“

4.8 Superb91 Reviews
Laska's Pizza Pizza • $
405 South Main Street, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Meditteranean Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“The pizza here is always great, despite their default pizza being 9 dollars I can't say it's less than 10 dollars a person because most will struggle to eat just one! Don't get me wrong, I absolutely could eat only one of their pizzas and be filled just fine, but I always want to eat until I'm stuffed here.

The sauce is uniquely sweet and the cheese has a different flavor from most other pizza places. And while we all have had cold pizza, this is a place where if you said you thought their cold pizza was better I wouldn't blame you! It's great hot and fresh, warm, room temp, fridge cold, reheated.

I know if I ever move far enough away I'll have to beg the owner to let me know the secrets of their pizza before I leave, or I'll have to find a way get it shipped internationally!“

4.1 Good172 Reviews
Pizza Town Pizzeria Trattoria Pizza • $
565 West Mahoning Street, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Steak and Cheese Pizza
Italian Wedding Soup
Cheese Steak Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Italian Sub
Special Sub

“Great customer service! Our large order wasn’t correct and they IMMEDIATELY rectified the issue and added on a bonus item. They were sincere and professional. And the food 🤤 perfection. 💯“

4 Good179 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
21866 US-119, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Oven-Baked Cheesy Alfredo Pasta
Chicken Bacon Parmesan Melt
Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Mild Traditional Wings
Hawaiian Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Lovers Pizza
Medium Bone in Wings
Cinnabon Mini Rolls
Cheese Sticks

“I was just there, Punxsutawney Pa. Pizza Hut is awesome.. 6/23/2020.. food and service was great.“

3.9 Good153 Reviews
The New Anchor Inn Italian • $
466 Harmony Road, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Creme Pie
Fresh Baked Bread
Chicken Tenders
Anchor in Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Wings
Garlic Toast
Fettuccine
Meat Sauce
Lasagna

“Awesome pizza and service!“

3.9 Good140 Reviews
Gimmicks Restaurant Family • $
208 Ridge Avenue, Punxsutawney

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Eggs Bacon or Sausage
Stuffed French Toast
Western Omelette
Pizza Thebomb
Hash Browns
Home Fries

“The food we had was so delicious! first time there for me. I recommend this place highly!“

3.8 Good243 Reviews

You May Also Like