30 Best Pizza Restaurants near South Williamsport

“Had ordered from here for the first time this evening. To think how much money I’ve wasted on these local pizza shops in my area just sickens me knowing you guys are just across the river!!! By far the BEST Italian sub I’ve ever eaten!!! Tysm!! Found my new pizza shop!! 10+ ⭐️“

“My mother and me tired them for the first time today (7/18/25) and we were pleased with the food. Definitely will be going back.“

“Shout out to Pudgies Montoursville employees for their excellent customer service. I always get smiles, “thank you” and “ have a good day” when I go in there. It’s the little things like this that make it special. Hard to find that elsewhere, these days. Keep up the great work!“

“Very rarely does a single 5 minute visit to ANY eatery spark me to post about it. This place is clearly an exception. All I ordered was a slice of premade chicken, bacon and ranch pizza. It was hands down one of the best slices of pizza I have ever consumed and by far the best in the Williamsport and surrounding areas.

Service was top shelf. It’s extremely spacious for a pizza shop and I think I even noticed a table outside. If you are a fan of chicken bacon and ranch pizza, this one will satisfy! ??“

“Was in the area and decided to try . I absolutely loved the pizza it was so fresh and good , sauce perfect. I even mostly ate the crust it was so soft. I hardly ever eat pizza crust. Nice place and atmosphere and customer service. KAREN approved ✨😀“

“Everything I have ever had here has been very good. It does seem the meat has changed for the cheesesteaks and was not as flavorful this past order. They are so very busy and work so hard to keep everybody happy. I suggest you call your order in and plenty of time whether it is pick up or take out. They stay true to the times quoted.“

“Brilliant service great ppl and ovcourse the best food what a awsome place“

“Great home-style cooking, service is excellent.“

“1st time here tonight, and I'm in love with the Pizza. Excellent. Customers Service was Awesome also. if I could I'd give Barts 100 🌟“

“Idk what his name was but one of the employees just told me I brightened his day. Let me tell you that brightened my day, and was very unexpected. He was also very polite and even told me not to apologize for not being able to tip more than I had. (I felt $1 on a $54 order was just way too small and hated that I didn't have more cash to tip with.) He told me "Don't ever apologize for what you tip, we are grateful no matter what" You don't see a lot of people like that in the food industry and it was a great experience! Also our food was delicious as always! Thank you!!!“

“Great pizza, great staff, my go to pizza shop!! I’m pretty picky on my pizza but Venice has never failed me NOT ONCE!!! Solid Pizza, comparable to a true New York slice. 10/10 every time. They even know me by name there!! 2 slices Pep and a drink, I could eat it everyday and not get old!! Love Venice pizza“

“2 slices and a soda for $6 what a great lunch!

For me personally the pizza was too tomatoey, but it was still a solid slice.

Service was quick and friendly, can’t as for much more.

Atmosphere was seemingly right out of the early 2000s and gives an incredible nostalgic feeling.

Parking: Plenty of parking in the front and on side of building.“

“Great pizza and wings after a great football game! Thanks!“

“The best turkey cosmo I have ever had! If you have not been to Frankie’s, give it a try! The establishment is clean, and the owners and workers are very friendly!“

“Marco’s saved the day for our Warrior Run Soccer Team the other day. There was a failure with another pizza place on delivering the team pizza after a soccer game late at night. There was 5 mins left for the boys to play and I called Marco’s and they fulfilled our order to serve 40 people in 25 mins. They offered us to even come to the restaurant. So the bus loaded up all the kids and went straight to Marco’s. They had a nice dry (because it was raining) place to eat their delicious pizza. They also made the boys cinnamon squares out of kindness. Such a nice bunch of people working there. The boys had a good night and you took the stress right off my shoulders. Thank you so much. We definitely will be ordering here the next time we are in town.“

“Absolutely a must stop for ice cream. They do serve other foods like pizza and hot dogs, etc. The shop atmosphere sends you back to the 50's! Everything was great, including the friendly service. We'll be frequenting Weaver's on our regular trips between Virginia and western NY.“

“Excellent food !“

“Excellent food, served in a family friendly environment, and budget friendly. Best Cosmos on the planet!“

“Delicious pizza and wings. Friendly waitresses.“

“Massive selection of flavors. We enjoyed the soft serve but will be back to try other items for sure.“

“Very clean and bright. Staff friendly and accommodating. Food is excellent and portions large. Thin sliced meats on subs and salads tastes excellent. Overall, extremely pleased with this restaurant and will definitely return.“

“3rd time in a row over the last year that I got the wrong order or had a sincere issue. Not the correct sandwhich and no marina with my mozz sticks. My mozz sticks were still cold inside, just shy of frozen. Last time I'll give them a chance. Very disappointing.“

“Store was clean. Fast friendly service. I ordered online but called in to tell them light sauce on 3 pies but when I picked them up they all had heavy sauce. There wasn't any problem with getting the pizzas remade. In about 20 mins I hot pizzas with light sauce. No hassle. Great job Little Caesars. ??“

“Great customer service and very friendly delivery staff! I was a total Karen when I called to check on an order, and I realized my out-of-state number hadn't allowed the driver's calls to reach me in the large building I'm in. The manager arranged for a second delivery attempt, and the driver was very pleasant. Found out he had tried for several minutes to find me originally with no luck. ProTip: Put your suite or room number in the Delivery Notes!“

“They were very accommodating and very nice.“

“Legit Cheesesteaks for all those missing your roots back in Philadelphia, get one of them jawns!“

“Huge fan of their cheesesteaks….homemade bread, yummy! The pizza is awesome….always delivered hot, the girls are super nice and polite. Definitely recommend.“

“Great Food and Bread Sticks are out of the world, definitely going back soon“

“Fantastic food! Great Service!“

“Home relaxing after a very busy afternoon & evening at work. I will say working for Wegmans is the best decision I made. My managers are awesome & I'm treated with respect & very well. I'm very pleased working there & moving forward. I'm looking into growing into different positions as times comes. I work helping hands & help on the maintenance team as well. I want thank all my managers & teams for making me.feel very welcomed & appreciated.“