21 Best Pizza Restaurants near Montoursville

“Shout out to Pudgies Montoursville employees for their excellent customer service. I always get smiles, “thank you” and “ have a good day” when I go in there. It’s the little things like this that make it special. Hard to find that elsewhere, these days. Keep up the great work!“

“The best turkey cosmo I have ever had! If you have not been to Frankie’s, give it a try! The establishment is clean, and the owners and workers are very friendly!“

“Marco’s saved the day for our Warrior Run Soccer Team the other day. There was a failure with another pizza place on delivering the team pizza after a soccer game late at night. There was 5 mins left for the boys to play and I called Marco’s and they fulfilled our order to serve 40 people in 25 mins. They offered us to even come to the restaurant. So the bus loaded up all the kids and went straight to Marco’s. They had a nice dry (because it was raining) place to eat their delicious pizza. They also made the boys cinnamon squares out of kindness. Such a nice bunch of people working there. The boys had a good night and you took the stress right off my shoulders. Thank you so much. We definitely will be ordering here the next time we are in town.“

“Massive selection of flavors. We enjoyed the soft serve but will be back to try other items for sure.“

“Very clean and bright. Staff friendly and accommodating. Food is excellent and portions large. Thin sliced meats on subs and salads tastes excellent. Overall, extremely pleased with this restaurant and will definitely return.“

“I always enjoy our family pizza nights from OIP. Huge fan of their salads & breads, too. I don’t think we’ve ever gotten anything from here that we don’t like!It’s always delivered promptly or ready to go on time. Staff is always friendly. Also a great place for ordering during work - they have a little bit of everything for everyone at the office!“

“Very welcoming as soon as you enter. Pizza by the slice, sandwiches, whole pies, Stromboli, calzone... you name it. Very reasonable prices as well. Staff was very nice. The pizza is very good. My favorite part was the amazing cheese they use. I recommend trying them out.

Update - still amazing as always!“

“My mother and me tired them for the first time today (7/18/25) and we were pleased with the food. Definitely will be going back.“

“Was in the area and decided to try . I absolutely loved the pizza it was so fresh and good , sauce perfect. I even mostly ate the crust it was so soft. I hardly ever eat pizza crust. Nice place and atmosphere and customer service. KAREN approved ✨😀“

“Just tried Venice Pizza for the first time. Very tasty thin crust with a crunch! Ordered it with peperoni and mushroom with extra sauce. Came out perfect! Very friendly service as well! Went out of their way to make sure I had plates, plenty of crushed red peppers. Overall a really good experience! Thank you kindly!

**I noticed they had a now hiring sign in the window. I asked and they said they'd love to have an experienced pizza maker to cover shifts. Looks like a very nice comfortable place to work!“

“excellent food and great service. A nice place to take the family“

“Joe's east end has the best wings. Especially when you get them to go. They are always hot, saucy, and most importantly crispy! I've never had any other experience there, and we go there A Lot. The rest of the food there is delicious as well. And the girl at the counter is always friendly and helpful.“

“the food is great , prices are great and place very clean and very friendly and the Employees are sweet and kind.“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The owner hooked me up with a free pizza after commenting on a Facebook post they had regarding a giveaway. I had never tried Pudgie’s before but after tasting this delicious pizza, my husband and I both agreed it was one of the best pies we’ve ever had. Sweet yet savory sauce, super cheesy, and great dough. Even my picky toddler loved it. Thanks for making a pregnant momma happy! We will definitely be returning customers.“

“1st time here tonight, and I'm in love with the Pizza. Excellent. Customers Service was Awesome also. if I could I'd give Barts 100 🌟“

“Beautiful new banquet room and patio. Nice updates in the dining room, also. Pizza is always a favorite“

“Best Pizza by far in Williamsport. My favorite pizza for over 50 years. Quality of the ingredients and the service is truly unmatched“

“Delicious pizza and wings. Friendly waitresses.“

“2 slices and a soda for $6 what a great lunch!

For me personally the pizza was too tomatoey, but it was still a solid slice.

Service was quick and friendly, can’t as for much more.

Atmosphere was seemingly right out of the early 2000s and gives an incredible nostalgic feeling.

Parking: Plenty of parking in the front and on side of building.“

“Absolutely delicious food!!!!“

“Food and booze always good, clientele, and the staff always seem very respectful, a great place to go…“