22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Williamsport

“Absolutely excellent. I was traveling and asked the hotel to recommend a place for pizza. This came up as my top option. Located in a strip mall, from outside it looks kinda small - but the inside is very deep and had a ton of room and tables. Outside seating too. Staff was incredibly friendly, and as I waited they greeted obvious regulars by name. I had fall-off-the-bone wings that were too die for, and a margarita pizza that was just excellent. I took them both back to the hotel and ate in the lobby and had people come up and ask where I got them. 5 star, will definitely return when I come back this way. If you're local and haven't gone, you're missing out!“

“It's hard to find decent pizza in this area but Joe's does a great job of making a tasty thin crust that doesn't flop. The buffalo chicken with shredded chicken is the best buff chick pizza I've had since living in NJ. The service is perfect. No frills, straight to the point with quality food. I also saw the owners hired a local photographer to take some photos for social media which I highly respect in this era of business owners posting nothing but crappy AI flyers and weird chaptGPT uncanny valley food pics. I love seeing real photos (even if they are just shitty cell phone pics) and the fact they utilized another local business to have them done is super cool of them when so many places are taking the cheap/lazy way out. For that (and the food actually being great), they will have my loyalty as long as I live here.“

“Was in the area and decided to try . I absolutely loved the pizza it was so fresh and good , sauce perfect. I even mostly ate the crust it was so soft. I hardly ever eat pizza crust. Nice place and atmosphere and customer service. KAREN approved ✨😀“

“My mother and me tired them for the first time today (7/18/25) and we were pleased with the food. Definitely will be going back.“

“the food is great , prices are great and place very clean and very friendly and the Employees are sweet and kind.“

“Stopped on our way back home to NY from Virginia. WOW, we're we surprised!!! Delicious pie with a delicate thin crust cooked perfectly. Multiple different slices available when we were there. Good prices for great pizza. FYI, the white pizza is red sauce, cheese and loaded with sweet white onion. Wasn't expecting that, but it was delicious.“

“excellent food and great service. A nice place to take the family“

“Great staff and communication! Pizza is absolutely delicious and hot! 10/10 will order again! The party pizza is the best decision I’ve made! 🔥❤️🤤“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The owner hooked me up with a free pizza after commenting on a Facebook post they had regarding a giveaway. I had never tried Pudgie’s before but after tasting this delicious pizza, my husband and I both agreed it was one of the best pies we’ve ever had. Sweet yet savory sauce, super cheesy, and great dough. Even my picky toddler loved it. Thanks for making a pregnant momma happy! We will definitely be returning customers.“

“Delicious pizza and wings. Friendly waitresses.“

“this has been my favorite pizza since I was a kid“

“Great Food and Bread Sticks are out of the world, definitely going back soon“

“Legit Cheesesteaks for all those missing your roots back in Philadelphia, get one of them jawns!“

“Best subs, rolls make a sub and they have good ones! Hard to find a good roll like when I grew up and these come the closest. Very filling to. Our favorite sub shop“

“Best pizza!! From Buffalo NY and I’m telling you this is the best pizza! I love it. Thin crust best flavor this reminds me of Joes Pizza in NYC taste just like it. If you’re in the Williamsport area I’m telling you get this pizza. 10 out of 10!!!!!❤️❤️❤️“

“Store was clean. Fast friendly service. I ordered online but called in to tell them light sauce on 3 pies but when I picked them up they all had heavy sauce. There wasn't any problem with getting the pizzas remade. In about 20 mins I hot pizzas with light sauce. No hassle. Great job Little Caesars. ??“

“Great family establishment!“

“Home relaxing after a very busy afternoon & evening at work. I will say working for Wegmans is the best decision I made. My managers are awesome & I'm treated with respect & very well. I'm very pleased working there & moving forward. I'm looking into growing into different positions as times comes. I work helping hands & help on the maintenance team as well. I want thank all my managers & teams for making me.feel very welcomed & appreciated.“

“For got my fries, my sister didn't get her fries on her salad. No refill on my drink, BUT The Waitress did a Amazing job keeping cool and tried making everything right. My food was good and the Waitress did great! Staffing was terrible. 1 new cook and not having enough staff.“

“There was one guy working??? What's up papa John's!! You can't get more people to work? Is there a worker shortage? I don't think so, maybe it's the pay or management?? I don't know, but you ceos need to look into it !! C'mon someone has to need work!?“

“staff was attentive and very friendly and food was delicious as well as affordable! great little find!“