13 Best Italian Restaurants in Williamsport

“Prior to visiting Franco’s I wouldn’t have considered myself an expert on Italian cuisine. However, upon tasting the (highly recommended by locals) food, I now know what Italian food is supposed to taste like. Perfection across the board…the food, the service, the owners…not fussy, not fancy, just exactly what it should be. The lasagna will heal lifelong soul wounds, the fettuccine Alfredo with a meatball will comfort you beyond expectations, and the meat ravioli will make you realize that a simple dish has surprising nuances of flavor you weren’t expecting. I live an hour and a half from Franco’s. I would make the trip to Williamsport even if this was the only place I would go.“

“Delicious pizza and wings. Friendly waitresses.“

“I eat there regularly with friends. We could go anywhere but come here. Enough choices so it not repeating every meal. They can get busy, you may wait for a bit but oh well who's in a hurry. We came by choice! And enjoy it!“

“Wonderful dinner here for my husband’s birthday. The food and staff are amazing. One of the best meals we have had in a very long time.“

“We have been coming here for 8 years and every single are welcomed as if we’re family. Shown to “our” table. Our family has tried probably every meal on the menu and has never been disappointed. We try to go at least once a month and highly recommend everyone at least give it a try- you cannot go wrong.“

“Great Food and Bread Sticks are out of the world, definitely going back soon“

“A fine Italian family restaurant. Entrees, desserts and service were outstanding. We will be back.“

“We came on Mother’s Day for dinner and were very impressed from the moment we walked in. Their staff was friendly, professional and they all seemed to be enjoying being at work. The food was great, portions fair and service excellent. Our waitress Alyssa was fantastic !“

“Shout out to the crew at Joe's tonight, 06/26/2026 16:20. My family orders pickup like once a week (sometimes 2 😅). I called around 19:50 and placed an order; just a large peperoni and a chicken parm dinner. Started to leave about 15mins later.... forgot I dropped my car off at the garage this afternoon and my partner is at work 🤦‍♀️. I called and admitted my blunder, changed the order to delivery and was even able to use my Joes points card over the phone. Their driver showed up in front of my house like 6 minutes after I hung up with them!!!! (I only live like 2mi away, but damn🤯)

We have been ordering from Joe's on Northway since Two Boys closed 😂😁 and they have gotten us through years of hectic work schedules, soccer practices and 4yrs of my partner attending PCT for his RN.

Their food/service/work ethic are the most consistent and dependable I've experienced in the Williamsport area and beyond.

Thanks to everyone working there for showing up and taking pride in what you do everyday, I see and appreciate you!!

Megan Tice💖“

“Just tried Venice Pizza for the first time. Very tasty thin crust with a crunch! Ordered it with peperoni and mushroom with extra sauce. Came out perfect! Very friendly service as well! Went out of their way to make sure I had plates, plenty of crushed red peppers. Overall a really good experience! Thank you kindly!

**I noticed they had a now hiring sign in the window. I asked and they said they'd love to have an experienced pizza maker to cover shifts. Looks like a very nice comfortable place to work!“

“Great staff and communication! Pizza is absolutely delicious and hot! 10/10 will order again! The party pizza is the best decision I’ve made! 🔥❤️🤤“

“Wonderful dinner here for my husband’s birthday. The food and staff are amazing. One of the best meals we have had in a very long time.“

“Best pizza!! From Buffalo NY and I’m telling you this is the best pizza! I love it. Thin crust best flavor this reminds me of Joes Pizza in NYC taste just like it. If you’re in the Williamsport area I’m telling you get this pizza. 10 out of 10!!!!!❤️❤️❤️“