17 Best Pizza Restaurants near Selinsgrove

“Pizza is melt-in-your mouth delicious! And those ice cream flavors are fantastic!“

“When I came in to pick up an order that was placed online, I was expecting the price to be about $20 as we bought 2 pizzas and wings as a part of their $6.99 special, when the worker read me the price of $28 I asked if that was right, and said that’s not what the price said online. She printed the receipt and showed me. But when I went to pay she wouldn’t let me and insisted that I don’t worry about the price due to the discrepancy. I was very grateful. Later that night, I found I was incorrect about the price, so I had gotten my pizza for free because Papa John’s Selinsgrove has OUTSTANDING customer service!“

“Don’t give one star order cold sub and two slices got my sub was warm lettuce was brown and wilted pizza totally cold would NOT recommend“

“Always an excellent restaurant for good homemade Italian food. Friendly staff and business owners always support the community whether you are local or pasting thru stop in you won’t be disappointed“

“Delicious Hoagie Pizza!!!“

“Visited yesterday with my family after church, I must say I have been here many times but the atmosphere was awesome. Ty the new store manager was awesome!! friendly and extremely nice. had an awesome time!! thanks for your patience with my card issue and being so kind“

“Delicious pizza! Supreme, meat lovers and chicken bacon ranch are 3 of our favorites! With their garlic butter sauce/seasoning they use, even the crust is good! Do yourself a favor and try some pizza the next time you don't feel like cooking.“

“Best hoagies I know of, anywhere. Unbeatable bread. Best alfredo sauce you'll come across. Chicken alfredo pizza is fantastic, or fettucine alfredo (with shrimp, chicken, broccoli mix and match). Very very nice people, always great service if eating in and a nice dining experience. The owner / head chef is always working hard but makes time to say hello to pretty much everyone he has an opportunity to engage with. Noticeably friendly guy. Great place all around, seriously awesome food at Amatos Norry.“

“This was a nice surprise for us. I didn’t know this place existed. Found it on an advertisement for a local Airbnb. The pizza taste great.
There is no seating. When you enter you can’t go to the counter because the door way is blocked by a table. Probably could make that look better.
Didn’t affect the taste of the pizza though. Good pizza and fairly priced.“

“so we ordered from villa teresa ll and it’s honestly one of the best “mom and pop” pizza places I’ve been to the only one that even comes close I got in Brooklyn. They are big slices cooked well. The sauce was robust. And it did not fall apart, easy to fold. And wallet friendly that’s just a welcome bonus.

Wish I had a picture but we devoured it.“

“Their pizza is amazing, and I love how they give back to the local community! I would highly recommend!“

“It was 20 minutes til close on a Wednesday night and my boss and I were heading back to trevorton from harrisburg after a long day at work. We walked in and they were about shut down for the night, but we were starving after a long days work. Rosario (the manager) was so gracious and kind to us, saw the starvation and exhaustion in our faces, and offered us the rest of the slice pie and a stuffed foccacia for no charge. Needless to say, we were overcome woth gratitude and gave them whatever cash we had in our pockets. I had worked for the same family of owners, in elysburg, for a few years about 15 years ago at a time in my life when nobody should have given me a job. Anyways, it warmed my heart to see that spirit of kindness handed down to the next generation. Thank you to the Gallina family for the blessing tonight, and for the opportunity to better myself so long ago. Salute!“

“I put in an order in for delivery at about 4:15 this afternoon at arrived at 5:01 very hot and extremely good I love their wings and a lot of other things on their menu and the delivery person was very courteous thank you KND,s“

“My husband and I stopped in for our 16th anniversary tonight. This staff if absolutely amazing and made us feel extremely special. Our waitress, Alyccia, let the rest of the staff know that it was our anniversary. They all pitched in to give us a brownie. ❤️ These sweet people made our night!“

“For years going to Hershey always see this and wanna stop since I heard a couple years ago it was the next big thing. In our area we got a blaze pizza and heard they were competing in the marketplace.

Mod was good id say a solid 3.5 out of 5. Surprised at lack of ingredient options and onion choices. I think I personally prefer blaze.“

“Stopped here with my family while on a trip, and the food was so great! I recommend the lasagna, but also all the freshly made bread that comes with it. 😍“

“Went above and beyond for my recent delivery. Grandsons surprise 5th Birthday party. Wish it would allow me to post a picture so you can all see. It allowed me to post the picture. Isn't that sweet“