15 Best American Restaurants in Selinsgrove

“We stopped in early afternoon and had ice cream. Tom checked out the restaurant and we decided to come back for dinner. Was wonderful.“

“there food is amazing my husband and I stop here often on way to and from selinsgrove! we highly recommend there wings they are fantastic and large and worth the price! I choose them many times! my husband loves the cheesesteak and cheesefries which I highly recommend as well! plus don't forget they got funnel cake fries which feeds my love for fair food craving now and again♡ this is a great stop!!!!“

“Great! We had an awesome time“

“was highly disappointed with my recent trip to this place. we got there around 2pm and was not very busy. waited about 30 minutes for our food. we ordered three meals, once steak and shrimp, one bbq chicken and a steak and chicken fingers. brought out our food and it was barely warm. they forgot the chicken fingers and when I asked about them after waiting about 10 minutes for someone to walk by they went back and grabbed them and they had the nerve to say they were sitting back there the whole time they forgot to grab them. that is absolutely poor food management and a huge food violation.“

“Stopped here for dinner with my husband. He had the BBQ chicken and Jalapeño flatbread. I had the Pulled Pub Sandwich. He drank a pink lady IPA and I had the raspberry coconut margarita. There was only one waitress/bartender for the whole restaurant. She managed it well though. The food was okay for the price. Atmosphere was a old pub vibes in a basement. We sat inside but outdoor seating was available.“

“New Years Eve and the restaurant was maxed out. Hostess was ill prepared to handle number of patrons causing long wait times and parties being seated out of order. They ran out of baked potatoes, a staple for a steak house. All a reflection of poor management.“

“Cozy atmosphere. The staff is always friendly. And the breakfast is always delicious 😋“

“Food is always great! The Service is amazing! Great staff! The wings are some of the best around! Definitely Recommend!“

“Don’t give one star order cold sub and two slices got my sub was warm lettuce was brown and wilted pizza totally cold would NOT recommend“

“Love the selinsgrove hotel!! I forgot some of my order and even when they were swamped my additional order was still out in record time!! Their food is always hot and delicious! We order almost every Friday night from them! You won’t be disappointed!! Thank you selinsgrove hotel!! Keep up the amazing work!!“

“Visited yesterday with my family after church, I must say I have been here many times but the atmosphere was awesome. Ty the new store manager was awesome!! friendly and extremely nice. had an awesome time!! thanks for your patience with my card issue and being so kind“

“Applebee’s is a solid choice for casual dining any night of the week, but I find early evenings (5–7 PM) are the best time to go if you want a relaxed vibe with attentive service. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, great for family dinners, date night, or a laid‑back night out with friends.

The menu has plenty of crowd‑pleasers like classic burgers, sizzling fajitas, and grilled chicken dishes, and their boneless wings and loaded fries are always a hit. They also run fun drink specials and seasonal dishes that add variety to the menu. The staff are friendly and quick, which makes dining here easy and enjoyable.“

“Emily you were amazing! I found myself with very high emotions while visiting this location. I recently lost my boyfriend and this was the first dinner there without him. Emily showed me such kindness and went well above and beyond her call of duty. She asked me what she could do, she hugged me and apologized for my loss. Red Robin has a very special young lady working there. Emily I will be back and looking for you. Thank you“

“Everything is just delicious“

“We had a waitress named June. As a party if 20 that is alot. She was PERFECT brought refills out before we were empty. Food was fast and correct. We all loved her and she deserves a raise and employee of the year. She made our experience great even with singing happy birthday to my 15 year old daughter while she was busy. Please ask for her she is the best waitress I ever had. I dont know her personality but she is a very personable and relatable woman.
Thank you June.
Even the hostess where great and friendly.“