10 Best American Restaurants in Sunbury

Midtown Bistro American • $$
315 Market St, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Stir Fry with Veggies
Quesadilla
Jambalaya

“We have been here several times since they have opened. We were so excited when they first opened. The food was amazing and the staff was so accommodating! However our last 2 visits were extremely disappointing, our waitress was straight up rude so much so that we said we weren’t going back. We gave it another try after that and the food was very off, overdone and one of the dishes didn’t even contain the ingredients stated on the menu. I hope that they can get back to the quality they had when they first started out.“

4.8 Superb47 Reviews
Pop Snyder's Lunch American • $
248 Market St, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Wrap
Eggs Sausage Toast
Fresh Cut Fries
Bacon Cheese
Burger

“My husband and I fell in love with this local spot as soon as we walked in. Small town diners are a favorite of ours and this one had plenty of charm! I wish I could give them 50/5 stars! The staff was immediately warm and friendly. We had burgers for breakfast and couldn't believe how good they were. We came by on several occasions within a couple of weeks and everything we tried was a hit and felt like it was homecooked. There's only 4 booths and a counter so beware you might be waiting for seating on a busy day. But I promise you will not be disappointed by this spot.“

4.8 Superb31 Reviews
Boondocks Wood Fired Grill American •
5066 PA-890, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
BBQ Beacon Burger and Fries
Chicken Bacon Ranch Mac
The Boondocks Burger
Burger of the Week
Southern Burger
Bonfire Burger
Jumbo Hot Wings
Lobster Roll
Orange Crush

“Been there a few times with different groups of people and decided it was time to write. This has been a shockingly pleasant surprise! I avoided this location for years when it was a small, local run down bar. I only recently discovered it was completely renovated into a nice restaurant with an owner who clearly cares about ensuring the place remains high quality. The food has been spectacular. We've tried a variety of dishes, from burgers, pulled pork, a chicken sandwich, a shrimp dish, scallops, fresh cut fries, mac and cheese, and a lobster roll. All of is has been great. No complaints from anyone! What a gem for the Sunbury area! Definitely not typical for this area. The cooking staff still care about their craft. (To the staff - please don't lose your passion!) The atmosphere is down to earth, not pretentious, friendly, and warm. Good mix of classic rock always playing in the background. The servers have always been very kind, patient, and friendly. The drinks... the Peach LIT is absolutely amazing. Not a lot of dessert choices which is just fine given I'm usually quite full by the end. But, I did try the PB chocolate pie... oh so good. HIGHLY recommended!“

4.6 Superb67 Reviews
The Squeeze-In Hot Dogs • $
448 1/2 Market St, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Chili Dog--Hot Sweet or Half Hot & Half Sweet
Hot & Sweet Chili Dog with Onions
Hot Dog Ketchup and Mustard
Cheese Dog with Mustard
Chips-Middleswarth
Chili Cheese Dog
Spicy Chili Dog
Chocolate Milk
Bottled Water
Cheese Curls

“I saw this place a while back and wanted to try it so I went on a rainy Saturday afternoon and it was packed. The inside was full and there was 15 or so waiting outside. I got a couple different kinds of hot dogs and everything was great, my only complaint was that they only had one lady working and she was so slow. It's a very neat place, definitely try it if you're driving by.“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
Sweet Chaos (formerly Hurr’s Dairy) American • $
901 Market St, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Grilled or Crispy Chicken
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Broc Cheese Bites
Garlic Parm Fries
Turkey and Bacon
Pittsburgh Steak
Buffalo Chicken
Boardwalk Fries
Zucchini Sticks
Boneless Wings

“This was our first time ordering. We had wings and cheese fries. It was a busy Saturday night and we got delivery, it took a while but it was well worth the wait. Amazing food.. still hot and the deliver guy was so nice. We have a new spot! I am a wing snob… these were perfect!!!“

4.6 Superb41 Reviews
Penn's Tavern Historical Waterfront Restaurant German • $$
113 River Rd, PA-147, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll with Fries
Cream of Crab Soup
Cuban Sandwiches
Jaeger Schnitzel
Cowboy Steak
Sauerbraten
Spinach Dip
Fish Reuben
Cheesecake
Crab Cakes

“The food was amazing, far exceeding our expectations based on the outside appearance of the building. It's cozy inside and the service was outstanding. I recommend reservations because it's a small restaurant and it's amazing so you take a chance of not being seated for a while if you don't make a reservation. It's definitely worth the trip!“

4.5 Superb77 Reviews
McGuigan's Public House Bar & Grill • $$
266 Market St, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Finger Basket
Wings and Fries
Cheese Steaks
Cent Wings

“Nice little down to earth Restaurant. Meals done in a timely manner. Couldn't be better timing. Worth the drive out.Vegetarian options: I would not recommend this place for vegetarian diners.Parking: Free parking on the side street, room for about for 6. No parking zone in front of building.Wheelchair accessibility: Not wheelchair accessible.“

4.4 Superb34 Reviews
The Diner and Bingo American •
427 Market St, Sunbury

“Love having breakfast there!The Staff is always pleasant.The diner is set in a 50's theme. I wait for Richie, Potsie, or The Fonz to walk in!AaaaaaeeWheelchair accessibility: Speaking from a person who is physically challenged, It's very easy-to-use access through the front door.“

4.1 Good18 Reviews
KND'S PIZZA Pizza • $
262 S 4th St, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Italian Doagie

“Im update my complaint because the owners daughter was so nice. I called them with my complaint she handled it in such a sweet manner. I hate to complain unless I absolutely have to. And she understand completely. So thank you so much. I love ordered from this place tbh.“

4.1 Good29 Reviews
Jay's Tiffany's Northside American • $
910 N 4th St, Sunbury

Customers` Favorites

Cream Chip Beef over Fried Potatoes
Ham and Cheese Omelet
Dutch Country Omelet
Farm Hand Breakfast
Eggs Country Style

“I came here early, place was busy, seated quickly at an available booth. Server was attentive and came over and asked if we wanted coffee, yes. Then a few minutes later asks for our order, we order. Coffee came a bit later. Hot and fresh. No problem. Bit of a wait on the food, with no updates from the server, someone did come by and top off our coffee which was appreciated. Thank you. First time coming here for myself, but my brother lives in the area and frequents this place. Food was okay. Toast was delicious and buttered. Bacon was hot and crispy. Not the undercooked rubbery bacon that sometimes happens at breakfast diners. You get it. The flaked hash potatoes were cold, the eggs were runny, lukewarm, needed a tiny bit more cooking as some of the egg white was clear. some things were hot and piping, but those two things had been cooked too early? I ate the food anyways and I didn't die, and it was a good amount for the price. My brother's food was good too. He got a Belgian waffle plate and scrapple. All in all, it was decent, and would go back. The restaurant's atmosphere was happy and lively, and relaxing. I liked that the bathrooms were clean, well stocked and had hot running water at the sink.Kid-friendliness: Easy simple food, not overcomplicated. Kids menu and cereal. Chocolate milk, water, orange juice.Wheelchair accessibility: One level restaurant- no stairs, handicap park spaces near the entrance. Tables where a chair or two can be removed.“

4.1 Good49 Reviews
Loading...
map Map