29 Best Italian Restaurants near Stroudsburg

1 Momento Restaurant

4.5 Superb 536 Reviews

1159 North 9th Street, Stroudsburg

• Take-Out

“Grazie Nicola! Another AMAZING dinner. You never disappoint. The food was spectacular! My son chose to eat at Momentos for his 21st birthday. The best birthday dinner, (his words). We have been coming for over 20 years, in the days of the pizzeria. We are so proud of you and your hard work, creativity and devotion to your art. We will see you soon! From Chef Nina.”

2 Stroud Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

4.3 Superb 235 Reviews

745 Main Street Suite 101, Stroudsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“All staff members were very friendly, food was delicious, and I love the Main Street vibe! My son has a gluten allergy - their GF pizza was great!! If we end up in that area again, we will definitely go back!!”

3 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.1 Good 468 Reviews

600 Shoppes At Stroud, Stroudsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Wow, the best olive garden I've bin to thats around ! The staff is very friendly and the service is fast ! I must say this i will be going back and when I do I will ask for Hilda! Sorry if I spelled it wrong but she Made my family experience amazing! She was personable but not annoying and was ontop of everything! Its very hard to find servers out there like her ! Thank you for make our experience an amazing one ! Oh dont get me wrong there are good servers out there ! I talked to Tom the manager and told him about my interaction and experience with Her ! Soo I hope the management and Olive Garden team takes good care of Hilda ! The neverending pasta bowls are back but for long ! So make sure you gooo! You wont regret it! Thanks again!”

4 Benvenuto Pizza & Italian restaurant

4.4 Superb 174 Reviews

424 Main Street, Stroudsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“excellent food and good people!”

5 Tony's Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.9 Good 118 Reviews

290 Frantz Road, Stroudsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“If you’re looking for incredible catering, I can’t recommend Original Tony’s Pizza & Restaurant in Effort, PA enough! They catered and delivered food to our home on the Fourth of July, and the entire experience was outstanding from start to finish. Ordering was easy, the customer service was absolutely top notch, and the delivery was right on time. Every dish arrived fresh, hot, and absolutely delicious. We ordered full trays of penne alla vodka, chicken francese, sausage with peppers and onions, meatballs, roasted vegetables, fresh rolls, and a caprese salad and every single item was a hit! The portions were generous, the quality was exceptional, and the prices simply couldn’t be beat. Our guests kept commenting on how amazing the food was and asking where it came from. It’s not often that every dish at a catered event gets great reviews, but Original Tony’s definitely delivered and was enjoyed by all. Thank you to the entire team for helping make our Fourth of July celebration so easy and memorable. We will absolutely be ordering from you again!”

6 Goombas Pizza

3.9 Good 266 Reviews

720 Main Street, Stroudsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing pizza! best in the area.. Fresh and delicious and very consistent. Never got a bad pie. Always Amazing.”

7 Palumbo’s pizza

3.8 Good 191 Reviews

246 North Courtland Street, East Stroudsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“this family has been feeding me since I was a kid....but it's been said the Gilliland family and the Polumbos go back together since prohibition in NYC to the Poconos”

8 Bono Pizza Stroudsburg

3.5 Good 193 Reviews

1316 North 5th Street, Stroudsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“i’m so obsessed with this spot. bono’s has literally the best pizza in the area and i will not settle for anything less!!! they have such good deals and they are sooo incredibly kind. it’s so rare to find a place that is not only affordable but delicious too. i’m writing this while eating their pizza and it never fails to hit the spot. i love love love you guys! 🥹🫶🏼”

9 Amici Pizza & Pasta Family Restaurant

4.6 Superb 613 Reviews

2838 PA-611 Suite 204, Tannersville · 6.94 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I haven’t been there yet, but after hearing this lovely story of how wonderfully honest and kind the owners are and hearing so many stories of how delicious the food is I will definitely be stopping by!!!”

10 New York Pizza & Family Restaurant

4.7 Superb 621 Reviews

2912 PA-611, Tannersville · 6.63 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Every time we come to the area, we have to stop to enjoy the delicious food. New York Pizza encapsulates the true New York flavor of pizza. Any pie that you order is absolutely delicious. Our family favorite is the cheesesteak pizza and the grandmas pizza is by far the best around. Garlic knots are a must! They are huge and delicious. Friendly service by all and a great atmosphere.”

11 Brothers Pizzeria

4.6 Superb 197 Reviews

2610 Milford Rd, East Stroudsburg · 5.22 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing food! Great service! My whole crew came back 3 days in a row. We made sure we could make it back for lunch!”

12 Bliss Cheesecakes Cafe and Grill

4.7 Superb 222 Reviews

2610 Milford Road, East Stroudsburg · 5.23 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Delicious food made fresh to order!!! I’m so glad I checked this place out and I will definitely be going back every time I pass through the area!”

13 Volare Ristorante

4.2 Good 207 Reviews

2756 PA-611, Tannersville · 7.2 miles

“We went to this this restaurant for the first time last night. The welcome we received when we entered was truly amazing. We were treated so special. The food was absolutely amazing! We definitely will recommend this establishment to our friends. OUTSTANDING IN ALL AREAS!”

14 Primo's Pizza & Pasta

4.2 Good 160 Reviews

156 Eagles Glenn mall Suite 102, East Stroudsburg · 2.45 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“LUV THERE PIZZA ! GREAT PEOPLE! GOOD SERVICE !!”

15 512Restaurant

4.1 Good 172 Reviews

2 East Pennsylvania Avenue, Pen Argyl · 8.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We placed a large catering order. Everything was perfect and delicious!”

16 Johnnie's Restaurant & Pizza

4.5 Superb 242 Reviews

117 Washington Boulevard, Bangor · 9.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First visit. Food is fantastic. Good quality. Great portions. Place is clean and welcoming.. Josie was our waitress, very charming and friendly. Met her grandfather who was behind the counter. He was just as charming and friendly. i will definitely be back with family. Telling my friends that this is the place to go to have a great meal.”

17 Bovino's Pizzeria & Brewery

4.3 Superb 220 Reviews

331 North Courtland Street, East Stroudsburg · 1.57 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I love this place. Been coming here for 9 years already. Their pizza, fries, and wings are so good. Snd so are the fresh salads. My daughter and I particularly love the dried rubbed wings. Highly recommend 🥰 Extra seasoned jerk wings and cajun wings are our go to 💯”

18 Bosco Pizza

4.3 Superb 154 Reviews

107 Buttermilk Falls Road, Shawnee on Delaware · 3.99 miles

• Delivery

“Best chicken parm I’ve ever had, it is literally to die for. Also their bruschetta pizza is out of this world. Friendly family runs the restaurant and I started going with a really good friend of mine a few months back and we can’t get enough. :) If you haven’t been what are you waiting for? Highly highly recommend if you’re looking for authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of the Poconos.”

19 Bistecca By Il Mulino

3.9 Good 684 Reviews

312 Woodland Road, Mount Pocono · 10.94 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“It’s great food, great atmosphere, perfect music and great service. It’s our favorite restaurant.”

20 Pizzaro's

4.2 Good 248 Reviews

6 Fox Run Lane, East Stroudsburg · 8.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Always stop in for lunch on the road from Maine to Maryland. 20+ years. Always something for everyone. Ready & HOT -to go!”

21 PrimoHoagies

4.2 Good 136 Reviews

2836 PA-611, Tannersville · 7.02 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First time visiting this shop! Absolutely delicious, best bread in the area for sure 💜 bada -bing sandwich is sooooo good ! Will be back for sure :)”

22 Frank's Pizza of Bartonsville

4.1 Good 284 Reviews

3578 PA-611 Ste 240, Bartonsville · 4.12 miles

• Take-Out

“By far the best pizza in the area! Always hot and fresh! just wish the other pleasant server was there!”

23 Teresa's Pizza Cucina & Cantina

4.1 Good 195 Reviews

3040 North Delaware Drive, Mount Bethel · 6.91 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Good menu and good service! Anyone would enjoy this place. I go there often. Only complaint, fix the urinal!”

24 Peppe's Bistro

4.1 Good 185 Reviews

208 Skyline Drive, East Stroudsburg · 2.35 miles

• Take-Out

“Cozy little Bistro in E. Stouodsburg....With great food & friendly service....Drove up from the Jersey Shore for a change of scenery & was delighted to find it....No kidding, this is e real unsolicited review.....Pay Izelta & Raoul a visit & tell them Gene & Marisa sent you!....😋”

25 The Roasted Tomato

4.1 Good 147 Reviews

320 Greentree Drive, East Stroudsburg · 1.15 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“one word to describe the food and the staff. AWESOME!!!!!!!!”

26 Little Italy (Belvidere)

3.0 Average 56 Reviews

539 US-46, Belvidere · 12.31 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food is delicious 😋 Best Spaghetti Carbonara I’ve had in a long time!! Thanks again”

27 Pocono Brewery Company

3.9 Good 478 Reviews

2092 PA-611, Swiftwater · 9.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“One of the Best restaurants I’ve been to in over 6 years living here!”

28 Pizza Hut Express

3.0 Average 34 Reviews

Travel Centers Of America, 2 Simpson Road, Columbia · 6.26 miles

• Delivery

29 Tony's Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.6 Good 217 Reviews

57 Crystal Street, East Stroudsburg · 1.04 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Friendly people very cool interior food was outstanding highly recommend this place and the portions are huge we will be back”