28 Best American Restaurants near Sugar Grove

“I see on pictures that you carry chipped dried beef on toast, but I can't find it on your menu. Do you carry it ?“

“My son and I stopped last Friday night and it was super packed. We managed to get the last table available at the moment and our waitress was so nice! She was very personable and engaged with my son awesomely. I wish I got her name! She may have introduced herself but that's on me for not remembering it. Food was very good too!“

“Typical food in the area, honestly I find areas with more restaurants and more variety tend to have better food because the restaurants have to have a reason for the customers to come in. Areas, like this where you have pasta, chicken, beef, and usually some fish at least on Fridays, or pizza shops, tend to have food that is only desired when being lazy.“

“We got there at about 7:45 thinking they closed at 9. They actually were closing at 8pm for after labor day hours. I didn't want to be inconvenient and would have left, but the Jeremy and his crew were really polite and kind and said it was no big deal. Everything was made quick, was reasonably priced, and delicious as always. Thanks again for another great meal!“

“The meals were great, service was friendly, and the atmosphere was inviting. Looking forward to coming back here, especially when the weather is nicer and the outdoor seating is more welcoming. 😁“

“Amazing food and amazing service. The waitress was very nice and welcoming, great food at a great price.“

“Just took out the meatloaf dinner, Excellent, really enjoyed the meal!“

“First time there last week. Loved looking out at the lake and socializing. Great bartender and server. Food was delicious! Will definitely call that our place when we visit Jamestown area again. Have already recommended to friends.“

“We were up at Lake Chautauqua from Pittsburgh, had breakfast at this diner. What a hidden gem. Food was delicious and owner Mark who is also the cook is salt of the earth type person. Must eat there!!!!!“

“never been disappointed eating here! everytime is amazing!“

“Just had one of the best meals of the summer at Stella’s last night! 10/10/25. I ordered their special of stuffed haddock and was not disappointed. Thank you to your entire staff for another outstanding dining experience! Great date night thanks to ALL of you!!“

“One of my favorite breakfast places on the lake. I got the Eggs Benedict and a pancake and was stuffed for the rest of the day. As a side note you can swap out the potatoes for hashbrowns (which I will do next time). Coffee is delicious as well.“

“better than a 3.9 that's for sure great chef! i ordered wings grilled only the owner came out and said he would do it. he nailed it. best wings any restaurant ever sold me hands down. It was a pain in the neck i know but very willing to accommodate and they were amazing! any wings ever i would give a 5.0 out of 5.0. very professional.“

“Best Breakfast place around!“

“Went tonight for veterans day meal ,i really appreciated it they have been doing this for 17yrs,and also really impressed by the GREAT parents and two kids who handed out a carnation's to every vet in their (on their own dime and time ?)things like that don't happen much anymore they are doing a really great job of raising those kids better than 90% of high schools and colleges anymore. Lets hope they raise more kids just like that.

Good job applebees and the family with carnation's give yourself a pat on back“

“What a great place! We were up for a Visit Oct 1,2025. Outside was clean and cute as any Irish Pub in Ireland, inside was too! Great atmosphere, Irish music playing. Food was amazing! Shepherds pie and Upside down Guinness Pie. Outstanding ! Will definitely be back! Our Bartender/waiter was the best,very welcoming and fun!“

“We had a fabulous anniversary dinner here! The food was amazing, the atmosphere perfect, and the service was top notch! We’ll definitely be back!“

“So I wasn't crazy about the fish and chips. The fish was nicely cooked but the fries were cold and soggy. It was carry out..I waited to pick it up. But everyone gets another chance. Hadn't eaten a meal in a couple days (family emergency) so I saw the special on FB and decided 3pm was a good lunch/ dinner meal. A phone call confirmed that I didn't need to wait until a proper dinner time. Now the prime rib dinner was amazing. Great salad with the suggested homemade ranch. The 16 oz prime rib dinner came with a yummy salt coated baked potato. I had to get a doggie bag. Oh, and the generous pour of a nice cab topped it off. Thanks to Annie who ran that bar like the pro she is.The prime rib cooked perfectly at medium rare plus. Au jus was just right. Thank you! The snow shovel at the door scared this now..Florida girl. It is October!“

“We ate there tonight. The restaurant is absolutely beautiful! The atmosphere, food and staff are nothing short of excellent! Highly recommend!“

“they have some of the best burgers I've ever had and by far one of my newer favorites to go to for pick up ... always friendly atmosphere and the food has always been A+ in my book“

“The restaurant celebrated recently their 30th Anniversary. Waitress was super experienced having been a long time employee. Remembered whose order was whose when food was delivered. Food was tasty and all 7 in our group thought the breakfast was good and prices were normal. Coffee was good and the waitress returned with refills often. Toast was warm but not hot enough to melt the butter spread on top.“

“Great food and good prices will definitely be back“

“Had a great experience at Shawbucks in Jamestown! The atmosphere was relaxed and welcoming, and the food was delicious at very reasonable prices.

A big shoutout to Natalia—she was an outstanding server! Friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was just right throughout the meal.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, Shawbucks is a great spot to grab a bite and enjoy good service.“

“Forgot her name but my drink was the first cocktail she ever made and it was amazing Think it was tiffany“

“We ordered food to go, it was chicken Alfredo. The chicken was raw and tough, the Alfredo itself tasted like a frozen meal, just wasn’t appetizing at all.“

“The food was pretty good, with interesting choices. Only 2 or 3 choices for vegetarian. The hummus was ok for the US, with warm mini naans . The quinoa was also nice.
The service was kinda amateur, with steak knife coming much later and also the waitress made no connection between the ask not to have black pepper seasoning and the fact that the entire dish was simmered in hot sauce...
The atmosphere outside is great but the mosquitoes definitely ruined it for me“

“Was a great experience, from the food, to the servers and hostess, 11/10 would definitely go back🤩🙌🏾🔥😮‍💨😋🤤“

“the food is good.. and we took daughter some home. went up to get a to go plate. kid was to busy on his phone to get one .Just pointed at them.. like he could not be bothered 😕“