31 Best American Restaurants near Sugar Grove

“Great little restaurant! Daily specials. Friendly staff. Regular local customers. According to radio ads "Their winter menu is now in place!"Wheelchair accessibility: The front entrance has easy wheelchair access at ground level.“

“We went there for a family reunion and had good food all around, with good service and at a price that can’t be beat. Sugar Grove isn’t on the Interstate, so you’ll have to make an effort to get here, but it’s worth it. The ambiance is nothing distinctive or exceptional, but it’s a friendly place with many locals attending.“

“Owner's were excellent walked around talked to the table. Food was very good and they were constantly filling your coffee, checking in on you. Great experience ended up going to Allen Street because Lisciandro's was closed and I can honestly say it was a very good experience and I would recommend it to you.“

“This place is truly a down home kind of joint. It reminds me of the old school restaurants. The employees are so UNBELIEVABLY nice! The food is fantastic! My wife was able to get her tuna melt cooked to order, which you just don't really find anymore. They even added mustard to it. My reuben was delicious. They keep your coffee topped off. Stop in if you're around. You won't regret it!“

“CASH ONLY! Delicious!Great BBQ (summer) and breakfast (September-close) food truck located on Fairmount by KFC and the new ccb. Super friendly owner and staff, especially this morning.Lots of outdoor seating, a sink, food and drinks.They offer breakfast sandwiches, wraps, coffee, smoothies, oj, and hash browns. Combos available:)Monday-Friday 6:30am- 11am with walk up ordering or fast curb side service with a smile.“

“Nice place. First time for us. Food was very good, very nice ambiance. Service was great! Would have liked to have seen a little wider choice of menu items. (Reason for the 4 star rating.) Was hoping to see chili or meatloaf, but what I had and what my wife had were both very good meals.“

“It's been a few years since I've eaten at Ribs. I can honestly say I missed the vibe. I came back from Maine this week to be with fam for the eclipse. I was pleasantly surprised to see lobster rolls on the menu! Honestly, they are some of the best I've had outside of the local places up there. In fact they even beat some of those places imo (I'm looking at you Red's....)“

“Super-friendly and cool staff, amazing food, cocktails and small but intetesting wine list.Food is imaginative, high quality and beautifully made...a real jewel of a restaurant!Vegetarian options: Eggplant curry and the whole roasted fish with grilled citrus--super yum!“

“I have dined at Stella's 3 times and every time the food has been beyond my expectations. Definitely try the she crab soup! Both flavor and presentation of meals have been wonderful. Service was good. Stella's is definitely the best in Chautauqua County!“

“The food was outstanding. It's rare to see such a traditional Irish menu, and this place does it so well! I'm not typically a fan of Reuben's, but this place has the best I've ever had and would definitely get again! The interior is small but great atmosphere with Irish music and darts. Beautiful bar with a huge selection. The bartender was so attentive and friendly. 10/10 recommend!“

“OK... this nice family owned place is not fancy ... but clean and friendly. It is obvious they work hard to keep the prices low and still provide fresh and tasty food. Do not be put off by the strip mall location. They will give you a great breakfast ... period. The pancakes are delicious ?! A local gem. Thanks for a great experience.“

“Great food and waitress!! We were honored to come across a very sweet gentleman that paid the bill for my family. It was certainly not expected but such a kind gesture!! Next time we are passing through Jamestown we will be sure to stop back in.“

“Good old fashioned lunch counter diner where the grills and fryers are right in front of you. Food quality was very good. Over easy eggs cooked perfectly, sausage not over done and above average home fries. Companion loved the French toast. Prices are great. Paid about $ 22 for two breakfasts. Often pay $30 elsewhere. Good coffee and generous refills. Service was very good. Neither one of us had been here in many years and wanted to check it out. It was worth the trip.“

“This was my first visit to Lori's and it was an excellent experience! The food came out for our group at the same time, and was hot, fresh, and delicious. The waitress was excellent. From what I hear, the locals tend to keep this restaurant quite busy.“

“Reviewing after just one visit. However, the fish in chips was best I've had in quite a while. Wings are clutch. Wife said the Buff was also awesome. Great spot. We'll be sure to stop back next time we're in town! Nice work Steener and team!“

“This was all of our first time at The Landmark Restaurant, I could not have had a Better experience! Missy was our server and she was Very attentive and responsive to our requests. The food was Amazing!! We all had several different choices for steak, seafood to bowls, they all were Ahhmaazzing! We will be back for sure!! This was a Birthday dinner for 2 family members, we All truly hope to make it a Yearly event! Thank you Landmark for such wonderful service and Food!! We could not have asked for more!“

“It was our first time here, and definitely glad we stopped in on our way through after truck shopping.Jesse was our server and he is such a delightful guy to talk to, as well as professional and totally knowledgeable on the menu.We had the prime rib and Pork Osso Bucco. Both were delicious and the bread with 3 types of butter was amazing, especially the garlic and chive butter!It was our first visit but will definitely be back and with friends next time.“

“First time eating here. It was packed so I felt bad filling up another table. It was great though, and I'm glad that people flock here. I was missing out! There are so many menu items it was hard to choose. But we all were very impressed with our dinners. 2 of us got burgers and they were absolutely phenomenal. I got the black and blue chicken sandwich and it exceeded my expectations. Now I'm going to come back whenever I can! Service was great! There's so many menu options I don't know if I want to switch it up or get the same great meal I got before. The Cherry Lounge knows what they're doing. Come here and you won't regret it.“

“We wanted to try a new place. Prices weren't too bad, waitress was good. The good did take a bit to receive, but maybe we were all just really hungry. I ordered the grilled chicken sandwich and had them put wing sauce on the chicken. I asked tj÷m to shake the chicken in it, but they just put in on the side. It was still good.“

“When we got there it was packed. We were told there would be a 15 minute wait but it was only about 10. The service was amazing. My son got the pizza rolls and one was a bit overdone - our waitress got him another one out right away. The food was amazing - one of the best fish fries in town. Loved it!“

“We were in town for a hockey tournament and this was across the street from the rink. They had karaoke one night and a band the second. The space is large and suitable for what it is. There was some dancing etc. The main bar was busy both nights (upper), so we found it to be quicker at the lower bar (to get service).At night they do keep it dark. It is more of a club than a restaurant. We did get some late night food. The pizza is small and seem to be on a garlic crust. The wings (Cajun) were above average.Given the other options in the area (Especially late night), this was a solid choice.“

“Met some friends here for lunch, the dining room is on the smaller side, but there were plenty of tables and booths available. It has a bar when you walk in to the left so the party is in front! We really enjoyed the food, there was alot of conversation about the seafood salad not being available for the few people that were there so it must be a hit! The waitress was friendly & attentive and the place looked clean. I would certainly return and eat here again. I bet it is packed for Bills games judging by the Bills related items on the walls.“

“Gluten and soy-free diner here. First, my wife and I need to thank the reservations staff who answered the phone late yesterday afternoon and were able to squeeze us in for dinner. We were not disappointed! Their space is bright, and it overlooks Chautauqua Lake. Our server, Gabby, helped me navigate their menu, and she let me know that I could order gluten-free pasta with my crab, scallops, and shrimp scampi. It was topped with Parmigiano cheese and tomatoes, and it was delicious! My wife's Filet Mignon was cooked to her liking (medium rare), so we were two for two. For dessert, Gabby mentioned that they had one gluten-free offering. But she did not know if it was soy-free. Thankfully, she checked because the ingredient list, which she brought to our table, because their gluten-free dessert did contain soy lecithin. Thank you once again, Gabby, for looking out for me, and we will be back sooner rather than later.Dietary restrictions: Gluten and soy-free selections.“

“Atmosphere was great. Beautiful view of the water. Staff are super friendly and polite. Food was “Meh” I was actually a little disappointed. I expected better but at the same time I ate everything on my plate. I’m sure they would have made things right but I’m not one to complain unless it’s really bad. Overall I would probably give them another try.“

“I’ve never had a bad meal or service here. Their Philly Cheesesteak Pasta and Buffalo Chicken Macaroni & Cheese are our favorites. Forgot to snap a picture of dessert - the Skillet Chocolate Chip Cookie is the BEST if you have room for it after your meal.“

“Had a delightful dinner last night. Menu all encompassing, my taco salad was huge, fish chips yummy. Angela Manger was wonderful .Very attentive professional and so personable with us Rody Seniors!!Thank you so much Angela you made our evening❤️???“

“I usually order the bourbon chicken to be delivered I have to say so much kudos to this place. I am allergic to shrimp so I asked them if they could accommodate by giving me extra potatoes and they do. After I place my order through Uber Eats, I automatically call them to let them know please not put the shrimp on it and they know who I am at this point and automatically say to me we know extra potatoes and they are so kind on the phone. everything taste delicious I can’t say enough, many many kudos“

“Annemarie was our waitress.She was wonderful. Personable. Had refills of diet coke before I even asked.Was accommodating to my pregnant partner.Very cirteous. Quick and knowledgeable with food.I'm usually a little harder on chains but this red lobster crushed it compared to the one in erie. Seemed more like a local resturaunt than a chain.Parking: To the west side of the building.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs. Wide entry away.“

“We live in the area and have never been here to eat before. It was awesome! They were busy, but the hostess and waitress were so amazing, patient and nice. We are adding this place to our roster of dinner locations. I got wings and they were so good. My fiancee got a sub and she loved it. My dad got an Italian wrap. Everything came out exactly to order. I really have to give props to our waitress. She went above and beyond.“

“Depending on what you order the food is wonderful. Sometimes the ham is a bit dry or the chicken in your salad can be less than appetizing. I prefer grilled chicken but anytime I've ordered it on my salad it's been awful. I'm not sure if they put the less preferred so now I just order the fried chicken to make sure it's fresh.“

“Visited 1/31/24. This is by far one of the best buffetts I have ever been to and I've been in a lot, through various states. It was very clean, ambient and delicious. I would most definitely recommend you check it out, you won't be disappointed. I dont think I've ever had such fresh food at a buffett! Even the mac and cheese. Normally buffett mac and cheese is gross, i had 2 helpings. We also went mid week and mid day , which usually proves to be a bad time to visit a buffett, but we were not let down. I've found myself promoting this place to quite a few people lol I can't wait to be in the area again, I'll definitely be stopping by!“