50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tatamy

“Stopped at Leo’s for the first time tonight.. ordered 2 pizzas & garlic knots.. everything was delicious! The crust was perfect. Sausage & peppers added great flavor to an already delicious pizza!! Can’t wait to go back. My kids said it’s their new favorite pizza place. Clean & decorated nicely!“

“Spice Crust Pizzeria is the best! Their pizza is always fresh, cheesy, and full of flavor. I look forward to it every two weeks — it’s my little slice of happiness!
Nothing beats Spice Crust . Don't forget to try their noodle burger . Best thing ever !! 😋“

“Finally got to try Moonlight Pizza today. We got a large pie and a birch beer. Birch Beer was really good but the pizza was incredible! It was worth the wait! The workers were really sweet as well! It was hot and fresh and ready when it was supposed to be! Can’t wait to go back again!!“

“Wow... What can I say about this place. I'll start with the service, which was exceptional. We had all of our needs catered to. We got great advice on menu items, and we well looked after. Next, I can talk about the restaurant itself, which was clean, sleek, and looked to be recently updated. No complaints on that end. Last, but by no means the least, the food. THE. FOOOOD! It was so yummy and delicious, yummilicious. The portion size was very generous, the food was piping hot and freshly made. The 2nd best part is the price. We are a ton of food, and the bill came out to less than 30 bucks. Yes 30 bucks, in 2025. Finally, as we were leaving, they have us free delicious cannolis, on the house. I'm about an hour away from this place, but if it was any closer I would be a regular.
The 4.9 rating (as of Oct 2025) is somehow not high enough. If you're on the fence about this place, go and find out for yourself! We don't have enough resturants of such great quality around anymore.

TLDR: the hype is real, go go go!“

“Best Sicilian pizza!!“

“nice corner restaurant. tried the Grandma Pizza, excellent. Fresh dough and sauce. also tried the spaghetti with meatsauce, outstanding fresh taste. Highly recommend this place.“

“My wife and I stopped in for lunch today, first time goers, but we will definitely be back. Fast, friendly service! We ordered their plain slices with the garlic Knot crust, and let me tell you I was impressed. The pizza came out so crispy, (I hate when I pick up a slice of pizza and it just flops over lol) but theirs was perfect! We got some desserts to go, and I cannot wait to try my GIANT cannoli, which is for later since I'm too full from the pizza!! Thanks Vincenza's for a great lunch!“

“I tried ordering twice from Francos earlier in the beginning of the summer. On both occasions, the order was canceled after an hour, one order from 3pm and another around 7pm. When I came across them advertising in a local group, I brought up my issue and was told by an employee that I must have had a different place. I provided screenshots of my canceled orders and was informed that the restaurant didn't even open fully at that point, so people were allowed to put in orders for a restaurant weeks before they actually opened. When I explained how easy it was to toggle on and off on GrubHub as someone with years of restaurant experience, another employee called me a jerk. After all this, I finally get to see pictures of the pizza, and it looks....well, you look at what they're advertising. Good luck.“

“it is mind blowing how delicious this dough is., veggies pan fried ALL fresh ingredients! 10 out of 10!“

“The best gluten free pizza I've ever had!! 👍🍕❤ Omg! SO SO good!!“

“Great food! Friendly and awesome service. Loved it!“

“Todo estaba delicioso muchas gracias everything was delicious thank you very much“

“We keep going to Familia Pizza because we like the friendly service and thin crust pizza. Super delicious. Beautiful restaurant.“

“This was my first time here, and wow the pizza was amazing! You know the saying, “New York has the best pizza”? Well, I think it might be true. Lol The slices were a great size.

The customer service was excellent, and they made my order right away. I waited maybe five minutes for my two slices, so I was in and out in no time. I’ll definitely be coming back!“

“I just picked up a plain pie and knots from Villa about an hour ago for lunch with my family. My first time ever trying them and they were friendly, polite, and the food is great!“

“Just wanted to say thanks for always being consistent with my orders. It is always the way I order it, delivered on time and always bangin'!“

“Best food around pizzas. Excellent salads are amazing. Highly recommend.“

“I was born and raised in Easton and frequented Colonial Pizza many times in my youth with my family. I moved from Easton in the early 1980’s and have not been to Colonial Pizza since. Yesterday, we brought our 2 grandsons to Crayon and went to Colonial Pizza for dinner before returning to Central NJ. When I saw the sign outside the building, memories of great times from my childhood began. Going up the steps to the dining room added to my memories. We sat down and ordered the Colonial Pizza pie and the kids had pasta. On my first bite of pizza, it again brought me back to my childhood as the look, taste, smell and texture of the pizza was just as I remembered. It was absolutely delicious. The kids also enjoyed their pasta. Our waitress, Allie, was THE BEST, took care of all our requests and her smile lit up the room. The manager, Mellisa, came by to say hello and made sure everything was to our satisfaction. Everything was fantastic and I am so glad we decided to eat at Colonial Pizza and after way too many years of not being there, we will definitely be returning soon and make this a must stop when we have reason to be anywhere close to Easton. Thanks to Allie, Mellisa and all at Colonial Pizza for a wonderful time and meal!!“

“Been coming here since they opened about 16 years ago. Every dish has been yummy and plentiful. When you leave Johnnies, you will be full. The prices are very reasonable for the quality and for the proportions you receive. The pizza is the best! The just right crispy crust with homemade tomato sauce and the cheese isn't greasy. Just right! Every time. I travel quite a distance just to eat there and it's worth the 45 minute drive. Sure I can go to other places, but the food, the portions, the atmosphere, the friendly staff, easy parking, the cleanliness, and the way they make me feel like I'm part of their family, makes it hard to go anywhere else. I also like that I can bring my own bottle of wine or any other adult beverage I may want to enjoy with my food. And Johnnie-the man himself- he is the Champion when it comes to making you the best food you will find in the area hands down. Once you try them, you'll understand my review. Thank you Johnnie for every meal and every pizza pie I've had from you. Nothing but the best!“

“I was in the area for the day and stopped here to grab a bite with the family before heading back to Pittsburgh. I am so glad I did. Everything was amazing!!!! The service was top notch, I got a buffalo calzone that was out of this world, my wife got a bruschetta pizza that was awesome and the steak sub my son got was also great.

Very friendly staff, a clean place and very family orientated. Price was about what you expect at a pizza place but the food quality was above a lot of places I have been to. Strongly recommend and will make the 5 hour trip again so when I do I'll stop by for that calzone again“

“10/4/24 ordered pizza to go burned again. Cheap cheese because greasy. We use to get from here every week for years now it's either burned or greasy so we stopped. So thin no wonder it's burned. Terrible. Shame.“

“Let me just say 😮 we have ordered here twice now and the food is off the charts Amazing. Dinners to pizza hands down fresh Ingredients and by all means leveled up from other local establishments. Your tastebuds will thank you. Friendly and the owners very nice 😊. Weather your a foodie or not you don’t want to miss out on this place!“

“5 Star rating all around. The best.“

“The brick oven pizza was fantastic. Zero flop (I don't care about lot about flop, but it's a thing. 😆), the pizza had great texture, dough had great flavor, pepperoni pizza was not greasy. Pizza could have used more sauce, but that's a personal preference. Garlic knots and pepperoni knots were on the small side, but very tasty. Good marinara. Small place, not a ton of room for dine-in, but adequate. Typical pizza shop atmosphere. Thin Sicilian looked amazing, will try that next time, and they have a full selection of entrees, dinners, sandwiches, appetizers, etc. Great place!“

“es un restaurante familiar muy buen personal que les abre sus puertas con mucho amor“

“We just celebrated a 96th birthday last night at Pizza Village. We could not have asked for better service! The entire staff was so welcoming to all our guests, drinks (including from the bar) were brought out on a timely basis. Each guest (16 total) ordered from the menu. Our food was brought out all together, no one had to wait, and everyone’s order was correct and delicious! The wait staff kindly cut & served the cake. It was an absolutely enjoyable experience!!!“

“The pizza was absolutely delicious. The waitress said she doesn’t know if anything was changed with it, but there was a different than what it used to taste like now on the downfall. There is no more soft ice cream, which is so disappointing. It was a double bonus going there I wish you could just get it fixed. Get a GoFundMe page. Ask your customers to donate but you have the best soft ice cream in the Lehigh Valley.“

“First time at La Bella.
I stopped there on a whim to get a few slices and ended up ordering a calzone. The choice was mini, small and large, I went with the small and it was huge, but so was the taste. I am from Jersey and I know good pizza and calzones. Hands-down, this was one of the best calzones I’ve ever had an it was picture perfect! I will definitely be revisiting and looking forward to another delicious menu choice.
Staff is friendly, price was more than reasonable.“

“Lord, have mercy, we think ya'll have the BEST sausage and green pepper pizza 🍕“

“I found Andrew Rogers’ Pizzeria by searching on google “Best Pizza Places in Lehigh Valley” and this place was at the top of the list! I was eager to try it so my family and I immediately went over there to get some pies! Andrew was such a nice/welcoming guy, great conversation, great customer service, and good tasting pizza! I highly recommend supporting small local businesses like Andrew Rogers’ Pizzeria. I will definitely be coming back when I am craving some pizza!😋“

“The food is Delicious - Best Chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant Parmigiana! So many great choices. Love their sauce. Will be back most definitely!“

“Just moved into the Bethlehem area and needed a good, safe pizza place. Tonight I found Stefko Pizza. And as I sit here eating a pan pizza and an order of fries I am in bliss. It’s all soooooo good. But perhaps more importantly to me is that I feel like I found a home away from home. I have never been in such a friendly, welcoming, and as I said, safe. Why do I say safe? Because I’m transgender and I never know how I will get treated in public especially someplace I’ve never been to before. Stefko Pizza though? Amazing. Such lovely, lovely people. They couldn’t have been kinder. I left with my heart happy and now my tummy happy. I am so grateful to have found such a wonderful place. ❤️ This is Ray! Highly, HIGHLY recommended 💕“

“I love this place, this pizzeria has treated me amazingly as a customer and the employees are great. Will always recommend!“

“Great spot for delicious sandwiches and dinners! Keep up the great work.“

“I recently had Sicily’s cater a family get together for my mom’s 70th birthday. We were impressed with the way the trays were packaged and how everything was so organized when conveniently delivered! The penne Vodka was the favorite! The chicken francaise was out of this world and a huge hit. We also had the sausage and peppers, meatballs, garlic knots and it was just wonderful. I Would definitely recommend having Sicilys cater your next event. And I would absolutely use them again in the future. Thanks to the owner who took the time to deliver everything and was so pleasant to do business with. Great local business to support!“

“Definitely will be returning in the future! They had a special for a Buffalo chicken Mac and cheese pizza with garlic knot crust and were only offering slices. Well they were amazing enough to let us order an entire pie for (my always starving) family and they killed it! One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time and the entire family (kids thought it was “Bussin”) loved it! They had great service and the atmosphere was extremely friendly. 10/10 recommend!“

“Oldest in Lehigh valley they never say this don’t know why. First pizza shop in Lehigh valley grandson running the place now. Everyone they leave is satisfied don’t know what else to tell you“

“My friends and I had a great time at Francesco restaurant. The food was amazing and the service was excellent. Definitely coming back.“

“Family, kids and adults, all love Forks pizza! Cheesesteaks are the best!! Kids love the chicken tenders. Apps are always great even when delivered! So nice to support a family owned local biz like this one! Owners are friendly and delivery drivers are great too :)“

“Today was my first time ordering from this restaurant and you got yourself a new customer! The pizza was absolutely amazing! I moved here from NY a few years ago and have only found a hand full (3-4) of pizza places here in PA that come close to pizza from NY and this restaurant may be my new favorite place to go. I’ll be back on Saturday for more. #pizzanight thank you for the delicious food 🙂“

“I was talking to a friend of mine that must eat gluten free foods. She recommended this restaurant to me because I have another friend who can only eat gluten free. Yesterday we went to try it out! Fantastic!. My friend could not believe that wide variety of foods available. She even bought extra to take home. It was nice to see her so happy. I had "normal" Veal Parm sandwich and sweet potato fries. Excellent! It has now become our favorite!“

“Our second time at My New Place Pizzeria in Easton and once again everything is fantastic . Yeah we carbed up today but being sick for almost a month we said screw it. Cheesesteak was not dry at all. Mine was made with peppers, onions, mushrooms, cheese and sauce. It was delicious. Delivery was quick and food was hot. Truly is going to be our new go to place🩵“

“Great pizza friendly staff. It doesn’t matter what you order there, it’s good! We order multiple times a week. You can eat in it’s a nice atmosphere!“

“The mozzarella cheese fries are amazing!“

“Now coming from NYC we appreciate a nice slice of pizza. You can see I lifted the slice up and all the cheese stayed together with the dough, this my friends is properly cooked and proper ratio between cheese and sauce.

The crust isn’t heavy and after 3 slices I felt good and stuffed, high recommend!!“

“hey! i was the kid that said i was going to give this pace a 5 star review! also, the food is SOOOO good!! This was like, the best pizza i have ever tasted arguably! the servers and employees were very kind, the halloween decorations look awesome, from the table i was seated at, there was a very pretty view! i recommend people to come here!“

“The Greek salad is LITERALLY heaven on earth! I 100% recommend! The drive up window is a bonus for picking up said Greek salad on the way home from work!“

“The grilled shrimp salad with the house balsamic is amazing!! Always a great meal.“

“Emilianos is known for having some of the best Sicilian pizza around—it's always been a favorite of ours. But last night’s experience was a surprise, and not in a good way. We ordered their Sicilian, expecting the usual crispy crust, rich sauce, and generous toppings split between sausage and pepperoni on one side, and peppers and onions on the other. However, what we received was far from normal—barely any toppings at all, just a faint sprinkling of sausage and pepperoni, and almost no veggies. The cheese and sauce were so sparse that the pizza felt empty and lacked the flavor we’ve come to love. We also tried their chicken parmesan sandwich, but that was a huge disappointment. I specifically asked for my chicken to be served whole, not chopped up—a common but misguided interpretation around here of how chicken parmesan should be served. What I got was a dry, rubbery, and incredibly tough piece of chicken—so tough, in fact, it was like chewing on cartilage. It was a nightmare to bite through. The sauce was barely present, and the cheese was minimal, making it far from the creamy, tender chicken parmesan I expected. Instead, it resembled a chopped-up mess rather than the classic dish—a complete misrepresentation. While Emilianos usually hits the mark, last night’s meal was a letdown. Hopefully, it was just an off night.“

“Went on April 30th. Not sure how long they’d been open but I saw the grand opening sign driving by and placed an order later that night.

They were getting slammed with orders, but the two or three gentlemen in the store were hustling and getting orders out in a semi-timely manner. I expect they were a little under staffed for the amount of orders they were receiving. Customer area could use a handful more chairs.

Regardless, order was hot, fresh, correctly made, and delicious! Will return! Nice job!“