40 Best Pizza Restaurants in Bethlehem

“We've been meaning to stop here for a while. After finally making it in our only regret is not making it here sooner! The menu here offers both traditional and unique Indian inspired spins on old favorites. Pizza, sandwiches, wraps, fries. We ordered the Halal Tandoor Chicken pizza and it absolutely blew us away. Herbaceous, perfectly topped (not skimpy but not so much it made the pie soggy) and spiced to a level of our choosing! You MUST try the white sauce. We eat a lot of Halal, Middle Eastern and Medditeranian Cuisine. This white sauce was among the best of the best. We ended up leaving with a bottle to keep in our own fridge. The staff were so nice. Making sure to let us know our food was going in the oven, bringing it out to us, checking on us and grabbing us some extra napkins without us even asking. It is clear they want their customers to feel taken care of and they succeeded. Much more than you get from your normal pizza spot. We absolutely can't wait to return and only wish we could get hungrier faster. Thank you so much for a lovely meal!“

“We visited Pat’s on our weekend away to Christmas City. The food was absolutely delicious. Made fresh, great prices and wonderful service. I would highly recommend the flight of pasta. The pizza was delicious too. If we ever make our way back out to Bethlehem, we will be stopping g at this little gem again!“

“nice corner restaurant. tried the Grandma Pizza, excellent. Fresh dough and sauce. also tried the spaghetti with meatsauce, outstanding fresh taste. Highly recommend this place.“

“My wife and I stopped in for lunch today, first time goers, but we will definitely be back. Fast, friendly service! We ordered their plain slices with the garlic Knot crust, and let me tell you I was impressed. The pizza came out so crispy, (I hate when I pick up a slice of pizza and it just flops over lol) but theirs was perfect! We got some desserts to go, and I cannot wait to try my GIANT cannoli, which is for later since I'm too full from the pizza!! Thanks Vincenza's for a great lunch!“

“Delicious food 👍🏽👍🏽and excellent service“

“we moved to the area 5 yrs ago and haven’t found our pizza place yet!! i think we found it!!! pizza was very good. we like a well done pizza and they actually listened!!! alot of
places do not! had a buffalo chicken salad that was also very good. chicken was not rubbery and flavor of buffalo was very good. i found the prices to be very reasonable will def be coming back!!“

“Great food! Friendly and awesome service. Loved it!“

“Best food and the pizza is out of this world“

“The food is Delicious - Best Chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant Parmigiana! So many great choices. Love their sauce. Will be back most definitely!“

“I found Andrew Rogers’ Pizzeria by searching on google “Best Pizza Places in Lehigh Valley” and this place was at the top of the list! I was eager to try it so my family and I immediately went over there to get some pies! Andrew was such a nice/welcoming guy, great conversation, great customer service, and good tasting pizza! I highly recommend supporting small local businesses like Andrew Rogers’ Pizzeria. I will definitely be coming back when I am craving some pizza!😋“

“Just moved into the Bethlehem area and needed a good, safe pizza place. Tonight I found Stefko Pizza. And as I sit here eating a pan pizza and an order of fries I am in bliss. It’s all soooooo good. But perhaps more importantly to me is that I feel like I found a home away from home. I have never been in such a friendly, welcoming, and as I said, safe. Why do I say safe? Because I’m transgender and I never know how I will get treated in public especially someplace I’ve never been to before. Stefko Pizza though? Amazing. Such lovely, lovely people. They couldn’t have been kinder. I left with my heart happy and now my tummy happy. I am so grateful to have found such a wonderful place. ❤️ This is Ray! Highly, HIGHLY recommended 💕“

“Best cheesesteaks in the Valley! Great selection of other favorites. Highly Recommended. ☆☆☆☆“

“Today was my first time ordering from this restaurant and you got yourself a new customer! The pizza was absolutely amazing! I moved here from NY a few years ago and have only found a hand full (3-4) of pizza places here in PA that come close to pizza from NY and this restaurant may be my new favorite place to go. I’ll be back on Saturday for more. #pizzanight thank you for the delicious food 🙂“

“Really Good Pizza, their pin wheels are amazing, had their cheesesteak last night and was delicious. And A+ customer service. Todo Riquisimo.“

“Now coming from NYC we appreciate a nice slice of pizza. You can see I lifted the slice up and all the cheese stayed together with the dough, this my friends is properly cooked and proper ratio between cheese and sauce.

The crust isn’t heavy and after 3 slices I felt good and stuffed, high recommend!!“

“Loved this place so much already can’t wait to be hungry again to go back. We are a family of 4, spent $40 for 2 specialty slice pizzas, 2 drinks, an order of garlic knots and a large cheesesteak hoagie. The cheesesteak was BUSSSSSIN like meat falling out the roll in the best wayyyy. Bread was soft and the steak was tender, absolutely surpassed my expectations. And the staff is incredibly nice! Offering extra napkins or utensils after being sat. 10/10 would come back again.“

“Delicious Food! We will be ordering again soon. Miniccotti was delicious and Hubby ordered shrimp alfredo. Your bread Oh My YUMMM!“

“I love pasta from here especially the penne vodka“

“Went on April 30th. Not sure how long they’d been open but I saw the grand opening sign driving by and placed an order later that night.

They were getting slammed with orders, but the two or three gentlemen in the store were hustling and getting orders out in a semi-timely manner. I expect they were a little under staffed for the amount of orders they were receiving. Customer area could use a handful more chairs.

Regardless, order was hot, fresh, correctly made, and delicious! Will return! Nice job!“

“Anthony makes the best cheesesteaks! The bread is always toasted perfectly and the meat is always fresh! Also had the calzone with pepperoni which was also very good! Would highly recommend visiting Bene Casa’s pizzeria!“

“I go to Lorenzo's every Monday night me and my daughter we order our dinner there for our bingo and then we go other times the food is always good no matter what you get they make it just the way you like it hope you go because you will enjoy it“

“This is our favorite pizza shop. You’ll see us there most Fridays challenging the claw machine while we wait for our delicious pizza. We’re huge fans of the white pizza light on the garlic - comes out of the brick oven just right! Delightful family-run place!“

“always has the best pizza by far but holy gluten free option! I was pleasantly surprised when a friend and I tried a loaded gluten free pie....one of the best pizzas I've ever had! dj always on fire too!!“

“Stopped into Mario's after attending the Celtic Classic event nearby. Even though the restaurant was closing within the hour, we were warmly greeted and promptly seated. Our order, half pepperoni, half Hawaiian (no ham) pie was taken at the counter, and brought to our table when ready. We were invited to grab our beverages from the cooler while we waited.

The pizza was delicious! The ingredient portions were generous and the dough and sauce were perfect. Next time I'm in Lehigh valley I'll definitely try to visit again. Thanks!“

“The best love it here the best“

“I ordered the heart pizza special with garlic parm and hot n honey wings and WOW! Food was amazingly delicious. It was my first time ordering from here and my family and I will be back again. Customer service was wonderful and the women working at the counter were very kind. We will be back again! Thank you for making our Valentine’s Day wonderful! ❤️“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Amazing Experience at Villa Fresh Italian!

I recently visited Villa Fresh Italian and was absolutely delighted with my experience. A fantastic place to eat some good pizza

I was especially impressed by Melany, who was incredibly attentive to my food preferences. Her humble and sweet demeanor made me feel right at home. Sophi also captured my attention with her exceptional service. Her kindness and attentiveness truly stood out and made my dining experience memorable.

I highly recommend Villa Fresh Italian to anyone looking for a fantastic slice of pizza paired with top-notch service.

Thank you, Melany and Sophi, for making my visit so special! I will definitely be returning.“

“Gluten Free pizza is out of this world!!!! The absolute best GF pizza I’ve ever had. I have been gluten free for years and continuously search for a GF pizza that doesn’t taste like cardboard. Well, I certainly found it here! Their GF pizza is light, fluffy, and toppings were the perfect amount. My Fiancée had regular pie of Buffalo Chicken Pizza and he too said it was the best pizza he has ever had! We will be back again! Thank you for the great food, service and atmosphere, we thoroughly enjoyed our dinner.“

“I recently visited my daughter at Lehigh and we stopped into Anna's for dinner. It was our first time dining there and it certainly won't be our last! 😋🍝. The meatballs and breadsticks are amazing, the heaping plate of linguini in clam sauce was delicious and my daughter practically licked the plate of stuffed shells with alfredo. I got the tiramisu to go and it was honestly the best I've ever had! Anna not only cared about the quality of her food and service, but she also cared about my daughter who needed a fair share of hugs after finishing midterms. Being so far away from home, Anna offered hugs to my daughter when I can't be there myself. We adore adore Anna! My daughter has already stopped by to say hi and get another hug. Thanks for a delicious dinner and a lifelong friendship Anna. I'll be back to see you soon. 🍝🇮🇹🍕💖“

“Normally I would rate this five because I love their Chicago style deep dish pizza but this time when I picked it up the pepperoni was all dried out and burned around the side. I'm going to have to pick them all off and throw them away. Most of the time when I order from this location the pizzas are perfect“

“We found this restaurant online and we were coming to Bethlehem from Wayne, NJ. We made a reservation for 4 on Sunday at 3pm and arrived on time! We were met by our server Maddy and seated at a large table. The food and service were outstanding. We come from an area filled with Italian restaurants and we were so pleased that we wouldn't hesitate at all to drive back just to eat there again! The portions were large, came out exactly as we ordered them. The prices were excellent also. If you want a great Italian dinner or pizza, I highly recommend this place!“

“I’m a lover of food. The vodka sauce is the best in the valley hands down!!!!“

“The Grandma Pie is MY FAVORITE IN THE VALLEY!!!“

“They hooked me up with a super sexy pizza. What more can I say? ��“

“My husband was acting strange again then he left me so I decided to leave then I found lucky online I explain everything to him and he help me bring back my husband with his powers just within 12 hours and my husband was back apologizing to me and the kids connect with lucky if you have any problem via his Facebook page ?? Dr Zato temple“

“Our group has been gathering at Nick's for decades and they never disappoint. Great tasting food and wonderful staff.“

“I've been going to Pizza Como &50 Yard Line since 1984. It's grown a lot in size and customers because they offer good food, great service and an inviting atmosphere. They offer dine-in, delivery, and pick-up services. The ingredients are always fresh and the food good. I'd definitely recommend this place. It's easily in my families top 3 places in the Lehigh Valley for good pizza. The only drawback is that the business is located on a wedge between Stefko Blvd and Easton Ave leaving their parking lot with no room to expand so parking can be difficult during peak hours.
PS I once left my wallet in the bar and I realized it 5 minutes later. When I pulled back in to the parking lot, there was the young bar manager standing outside looking in cars trying to find me to return my wallet. He refused to take any money for it. Great, honest, caring staff.
-Steve Martini“

“2/26/2025. We ordered two pizzas to be delivered. One was plain cheese….second one was a meatball pepperoni combo. Our order arrived very quickly. Pizzas were hot and ready to eat. We loved the quality ingredients. The crust and sauce set the stage for a very tasty bite. Crust was baked perfectly. It had great texture, flavor and the right chew factor. The delivery person was wonderful too. Bellas has been and will continue to be our go to for incredible pizza.“

“Best pizza and food in town.“

“Great food, very inexpensive. Just know that the restaurant is located inside the casino and anyone under the age of 21 requires an escort that will stand outside the restaurant waiting. There are also no bathrooms. This is not a restaurant flaw, just want to make patrons aware because I was surprised since they even have a children's' menu. Try the Nutella cake! It was amazing!“