21 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tobyhanna

“This is the best Pizza in the Poconos! I rate a 8.5 on the Pepperoni Slice. Though I haven’t did an official review that is the score I would give. The Penne Ala vodka is the most authentic Ala vodka ! The people pissing and moaning either don’t know real Italian food or they just wanna cry! Either way get a tissue and a slice idk.“

“Best food, nicest staff I’ve found in quite some time. It is indeed a pleasure to eat there.“

“awesome experience Leila is the best !!“

“We just brought our family and friends (Group of 17) and they readily accommodated us in their larger group room (Complete with decorative propane fireplace). The kids and adults alike devoured the pizza. Service was great and food came out quickly! So glad we came!“

“Today was the first time I tried a slice of pizza at AJ's Pizza and Parm House. 5/5 Stars. Gotta give them their kudos —- great dough, sauce, cheese and sausage. Perfectly cooked - highly recommended if you were in the Pocono Lake area!“

“love this place!.. excellent pizza, great service!!“

“Whether you are heading to the Crossings in Scotrun, PA, the Mt Airy Casino, Great Wolf Lodge, working near or traveling through, Nick’s is a must stop! A great business model with a true sense of running a successful business while serving awesome sandwiches, soups, breakfast 8 am, using fresh ingredients and a kitchen staff eager to prepare great food. One cheesesteak, sauce on side, on a fresh semolina roll, substantial meat, cheesy with nice flavors. The Italian sub, piled high with select Boars Head meats on same seeded roll was so big, it satisfied my hearty appetite. The chili and crab soup were totally delicious, well seasoned and hearty. At $6.99 for 12 ounces (bowl), they both satisfied us as an appetizer or lunch. The soups change daily! It was a delight talking to the owner who takes much pride in the 7 month old deli. I’m happy they landed in this part of the Poconos for residents and travelers to enjoy! We’ll definitely return to try the pizza and a pork Etta sandwich. Open every day but Sunday.“

“best pizza 🍕 i’ve seen.“

“Third time ordering from them in a matter of 2 months. Very pleased and they listen to exactly how you like your food. My new pizza spot,Amazing!!!!“

“Excellent Italian food. Family friendly.“

“Never a disappointment when it comes to great food. Always a good meal no matter what you order.“

“Everyone is is always very friendly. This is the only place that I dine at.The food is absolutely amazing and delicious 😋. You will never be disappointed with anything that comes from the kitchen. I can't say enough about Kay's. There shouldn't be any question about where to find genuine homemade food. It's a party for your taste bud's 😋. Don't forget to try one of their homemade desserts!!“

“I can only speak on a single slice that was a re-heat and I am due to return and try out some more stuff. I stopped in December of 2021 so as you can see, it's been quite some time since then and I need to get back up there and do a re-visit. The guy behind the counter was pretty much a typical pizza place employee...not what I'd call "friendly", not unfriendly...just adequate. Maybe 6-8 tables inside but mostly geared towards takeout.

So a slice and a soda was over $6, so that was a bit concerning out of the gate, but I don't just based on stuff like that solely. I enjoyed the slice. There was a nice char underneath which I love, good snap to the crust, it was nice and thin, good cheese to sauce ratio. Not much else I can really say about it other than I'm due to head back in. If you're just looking for a slice though, Brother Bruno's - DIdn't Suck!“

“I’m from Florida born and raised, some of you may or may not know what a Publix is, well best chicken buffalo sandwich I’ve ever had has to be a pub sub, until I moved here to Tannersville, PA and tried Mad Dawgs chicken buffalo sandwich and I’ll tell you what, there’s no comparison Mad Dawgs has the best sandwich’s and food in town. So if your coming from out of town and staying in any of the resorts around the area have no doubt to order from here, your taste buds will surely thank you.“

“Great food 😋 and really nice people. Me and my family enjoyed ourselves ❣ 5 🌟“

“it doesn't look like you have anything for people that have a gluten problem.
I hope you can in the future have some things for us.
I wish you the best.
Update.
They now have gluten, free, pizza and pasta. Thank you so much For the new menu items.“

“I called to order a pizza at around 9pm. When I arrived to pick up my order the place was empty. I left with my order and the employee turned off the lights and locked the door. I thought it was nice of him to allow me to order when they obviously weren't busy and my order kept him there. The pizza was very good and I definitely recommend them.“

“Not just a place for Pizza, They have solid breakfast sandwices as well! Our Host Juan is amazing. When my Wife and I go to Mt. Airy we always look for Juan. You can tell he has a sharp mind, great people skills and a quick wit. He has a calm demeanor even when the place gets busy, He could no doubt run this location and many others if he so desired. He has intangible skills you can't teach. He is destined for great things and we will miss his service when he goes. Thank you. Joe Assante“

“Food was very well prepared and our waitress Hellen A. Was very attentive and kind hearted to my family and I, we are very much appreciative and will be recommending her and Sortino’s to many of my friends in the area of the Poconos“

“One of the Best restaurants I’ve been to in over 6 years living here!“

“One of our favorite places to eat. The menu has so many delicious choices from the main dish to the desert. Enough to keep us coming back to try something new. The service is wonderful, with minimal waiting and the service as friendly as can be... My family puts them on the top of the list for places to eat when in the area“