15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Worthington

“Finally got the chance to try this place today! It did not disappoint. Do yourself a favor and get there 😊❤️“

“I've been going there for almost 20 years. Their grilled chicken salad and spicy Italian is great. The burgers taste legendary. The pizza is excellent! I recommend getting the pizza done "Caleb's Way."“

“Went today for our first time and both got the breaded fish dinner and it was delicious! Very friendly staff. Looking forward to our next visit. 🙂“

“Owners and staff very friendly and food was awesome“

“I haven't had pizza from here in years. I must say, it is still the best pizza around.“

“This is my family's all time favorite pizza place. Always has our pick up on time. Their gluten free crust is great and we have never had an issue with contamination. Lots of cheese on the pizza and the toppings are great. Customizations are reasonably priced and the crust is just right. Definitely try the garlic Parmesan chicken wings if you get a chance.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust is available. They should be able to tell you what toppings are gf as well.“

“I was very impressed with the customer service. I called Saturday evening with a specific pizza order that another pizza place continues to mess up no matter how many times I clarify. The worker that took my order asked me to repeat it to make sure he had it correctly and even read it back to me. When we got our pizza it was made perfectly. So many others look over the fine details and Vocellis took care of us!“

“Great customer service! Fast on a Friday night for a party of 5! Very clean. Young gal was excellent with our group! ❤️ highly recommend.“

“Nice 👍🏻 good good dvhfxffhfddfgfdsdg“

“Thank-you Brian , I can tell when someone cares about what they're sending out. Was losing faith in foxes. Not anymore !!!“

“This location is dedicated to providing exceptional customer service and premium quality products! We had a mistake with our order one time but this location was passionate about fixing the mistake to offer us better quality products and service. Give this location a chance and they’ll certainly impress you with their aspirations to make their customers happy with a full belly, too! Thanks for the great service and dinner! It’s always a good day when I don’t have to cook and we have caring people to do it for us!“

“The woman in the kitchen kept yelling about how overwhelmed she was, that they were apparently down workers and too busy. She was yelling at the other workers left and right. It took an hour to get our pizza, which was under cooked. My wings were crispy but the garlic butter they swam in was flavorless, no garlic flavor only butter. The pizza was supposed to be thin crust, but it was so very thick around the outside. I asked for ranch several times and didn't get it. I understand they were busy, but the service and food were both not good.“

“I would definitely recommend the pizza here. We were in the area for an away high school game, but would definitely be regulars if we lived closer. The Sicilian and regular pizza are both very good!“

“The manager, Paige was super nice. She also served our table as there was an evening callout. She was very attentive and polite. I will visit this location again because of the service that she gave. Great worker and the pizza, breadsticks and melt were awesome! Straight out of the oven, so give it a minute to cool off. Reading some of the negative reviews, I had the complete opposite impression. It was clean and quiet. A nice private date night. Great workers help so much!“

“We order frequently from here on the app and use the $5.99 coupon - at the end of my order I know that some items have an “up charge,” but plain boneless wings are now $7.99? So I’m not sure why they’re on the coupon anymore. But we always have great service and the staff here is always really nice! Great turn around.“