5 Best Coffee Shops in New Shoreham

“beautiful fresh food prepared with 💗“

“The breakfast bagel with egg, cheese, spinach, sun dried tomatoes and pesto was amazing 😋“

“We got coffee and it’s wasn’t horrible but it wasn’t fantastic. In fairness they were extremely busy. But the people weren’t chill and it just isn’t a coffee house vibe.
Not bad and no one waited a long time. It was expensive ( which is I suppose in keeping with the island in general)“

“excellent for breakfast and lunch!“

“Great experience here on a busy Saturday in August for lunch. We were able to make an 11:45 reservation and arrived right on time from the New London 10:00 departure ferry. Quick, easy walk. Eating outside at the porch rail overlooking the water was a highlight of our day on BI. We liked it so much we came back for a drink at the end of the day! Their ordering system isn't great - go to the line at the bar to order and they bring your food to your numbered table. Luckily our waiter took my order just as I got in line so I didn't need to do that. Food was “fine”. Nothing outstanding but no complaints. It's the view!! We'd definitely come back. We didn't order it, but the lobster rolls looked huge and yummy.“