Pubs in New Shoreham

“I visited the island for 26 days in August/September. After trying every bar, pub and restaurant on the island, the Old Island Pub is the only one that kept us coming back time and time again. Everything on the menu, yes even the hot dog is expertly prepared. Time and experience has gone into crafting these menu items. The pub fries are a work of art and are a must order. Good food takes time so if you're in a hurry or are Hangry and ready to throw a fit you might want to go elsewhere. Aside from the food, the bartenders and crowd that gather here are genuinely awesome and make the OIP the ideal place to go if you want to get a taste of life on the island. We made friends here that we will certainly be back to see.“

“This is a great place for a local vibe!!! We stayed downstairs to enjoy the atmosphere!!! It was worth it!!! The tacos were absolutely amazing!!! The staff was friendly and helpful without being overbearing!! We are definitely going back on our next visit!!!“

“First time visiting the island and it's October so not a lot is open. Went in with no expectations and was blown away by the pulled pork pizza . Crust was perfect. Not greasy and perfect flavors. Best pizza I have had I. Years. A buddy got a different pizza at the same time and his was soggy and not great so depends on which one you get I guess“