17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Hilton Head Island

“Excellent traditional pizza joint played U2 and all !“

“We decided to try the Hilton Head Dough Boys during our vacation and I must say, their wings are SO good! I am very picky with wings and I was not disappointed. The Carolina Gold sauce and the Honey Hot were on point!!! I ordered them well done. We also tried the pizza. It was good, different from what I’m use to as it tasted like they used several different kinds of cheese, but it was not bad (ordered one with extra cheese & pepperoni and one half mushroom, half cheese). I enjoyed the mushroom slices the best and appreciated they they used fresh mushrooms instead of canned. Unfortunately, the crust didn’t really have any flavor. We will definitely order some wings from them each time we visit now!“

“The pizza was fresh, hot, and tasted awesome 👌. We also ordered the Stromboli Cheesecake, these were absolutely delicious!“

“We always love Fat Baby's and look forward to dining every year, but we had the most amazing waitress this year. I hate that we didn't catch her name, but she overheard our kids talking about Labubu dolls and actually gave the one on her own backpack to our daughter. I was blown away by her kindness. And, of course, the food was delicious!“

“Food is FABULOUS !!! And the staff is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!“

“My family has eaten here for years during our many visits to HHI. Always delicious.“

“Always the best pizza around. Our server - Angel - was the best.“

“pie was just right. sauce not sweet and not acidic. pepperoni, meatball and cheese perfect. will come again“

“can’t wait for TJ’s Take & Bake to be back—perfect pizza for busy families.“

“The pizza is phenomenal!!“

“You should honestly just walk over to the Salty Dog Cafe. They serve the absolute same menu, and they accept the discount card from the resort. This is the only place that didn’t. You also have to order food at bar, wait, then take it to the table. You can get a table quicker though. For $90 meal, the discount card makes a big difference.“

“Fun atmosphere. Our food was wonderful, well priced and we had fantastic service!“

“We had a fantastic experience at Frosty Frog. Despite arriving right before closing time, the staff kindly squeezed us in which was already a great sign. The atmosphere is fun and family-friendly, with a laid-back charm that makes you feel welcome.

The food was excellent. Everything we ordered was fresh, flavorful, and came out promptly. The drinks were also fantastic. They were well-mixed and refreshing.

Highly recommend!“

“We were in town for a week and on our last night ordered a pizza to our hotel. Wow! I wish we would have known about it before we had to leave. Whoever makes the crust, keep it up! Amazing pie and fast delivery. We had it for breakfast too! Thanks!“

“We always have a GREAT experience.“

“Scott and his team are awesome! They accommodated a large party for us at the last minute. They also put up with our wild and crazy kids on a Friday night! Great service, great food and a fun atmosphere!“

“We only went for a drink and had to sit at outside bar. In Hilton Head smoking is allowed at outside bars so we didn’t stay there to eat so I know nothing about the food. But my gin and tonic was very good“