11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Elizabethton

1 Jiggy Ray's Downtown Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 349 Reviews

610 East Elk Avenue, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The pizza was VERY good! Full of flavor and toppings. The wings were good. They will double bake (not fried) the wings on request to get a crispy outside, very good flavor. The service was great. Our waitress was attentive to our needs the whole time we were there. 5 stars for food and service. The reason I gave 2 stars is because the owner was throwing around GDs like they were chicken scratch. Dude, this is the Bible belt., not California. All these churches out here that you talked about aren't empty. Stop cursing our God, repent and give your life to Christ, and I guarantee your business will pick up.”

2 Pizza Inn

4.3 Superb 324 Reviews

West Town Square Shopping, 101 Hudson Drive, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“our first visit was average. our second visit made this a destination we will be returning to regularly. It was our first day out after the snowstorm hit and we decided to get Pizza Inn again even though we weren't thrilled with our first visit. All of the food was delicious, fresh, and the quality was great! Our server Ellen never let our drinks get empty, checked on us often, and brought the special treat dessert pizza my 7 year old had been waiting on directly to us at the table. The manager Carson fixed the machine at the arcade we wanted to play, had complete respect and cooperation from their staff and happily listened and agreed when I raved about our server. We WILL be back, probably several times a month. That is entirely due to our second visit and how well everyone worked together to create a great environment. I have a 7 year old and a 3 month old. This restaurant was clean, attentive, well managed and delicious and I am grateful to have found a local place I can enjoy family dinners out at in my new town. Shout out to Carson and Ellen!”

3 Rico's Pizza & Sub's

4.6 Superb 145 Reviews

2209 TN-91, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Rico’s is always 10/10 no matter what you’re having. Rico is always super nice and his son does a fantastic job as well!”

4 The Black Olive- Elizabethton

4.4 Superb 361 Reviews

173 Hudson Drive, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“stopped by today with my son was feeling socially overwhelmed and then they ask me about seating I said somewhere quiet. they directed me to their beautiful lounge. I wasn't feeling super hungry and got a pizza because figured it would reheat well. it was amazing the crust was light and airy the cheese and sauce were perfect. I would have never thought I would have found the perfect pizza in the area but I swear this is it. I hate it all....”

5 Old Stone Pizza

4.5 Superb 30 Reviews

817 Broad Street, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I wish I had words to describe how "perfect" the pie was I just purchased. Price, Taste, Presentation, PERFECT. These men know what they're doing. Please spend a couple extra dollars and get the best.”

6 Greg's Pizza

3.6 Good 202 Reviews

776 West Elk Avenue, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“*** in Top 10% of Google Eatery reviewers in the US 🙂 as well as over 9 million total content views for all business categories between Google, Yelp, Quora, and ABOV (whiskey reviews) *** We live in Hendersonville NC and stop here every time we're near Johnson City. I lived in NY for 48 years, my wife is Italian from NJ and has 8 uncles and cousins that own pizzeria. Greg's uses Grande mozzarella......'nuf said. I'm sorry, but anyone who leaves less than a 5 is a knucklehead......”

7 Pizza Hut

3.6 Good 59 Reviews

319 Broad Street Ste 301, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Gotta give this one a solid 5 stars. I asked for a little darker than normal on a thin crust (hard to get perfect, but this one absolutely was perfect). Served exactly when promised and with a smile. Visited on 8/18/26 at 12:10 (just so management knows who to thank for bringing me back to the Pizza Hut thin crust excellence that I have loved for over 50 years). It was worth going off my low-carb diet on this meal!”

8 Pizza Hut

3.5 Good 154 Reviews

415 West Elk Avenue, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This pizza hut is awesome to dine in at. It's like the old school pizza hut you may remember in the early and mid 90's the way the dining room is set up with great values on pizza meals for 2 or more people. The service was ? !! The waitstaff is very friendly and goes above and beyond. Definitely my favorite Pizza Hut in Northeast Tennessee here at this West Kingsport on West Stone Drive location by far !! I will always come back here. I hope they stay this way and never change because it was a great experience and value for the money spent ?!!”

9 Little Caesars Pizza

3.4 Good 236 Reviews

1801 US-19E, Elizabethton

• Delivery

“This particular location is always fantastic. Food is prepared the right way, and always hot and the staff is friendly. I eat here often and also door dash the area and unlike some other local restaurants, This staff is always cool. It’s appreciated!”

10 Booty Judy’s Corner Pocket

3.9 Good 32 Reviews

547 East Elk Avenue, Elizabethton

“My brother in law and I had a fun time out tonight playing pool and darts. Very reasonable price to play pool and darts. The ciders we cold and tasty. The staff was attentive and friendly. The pepperoni pizza from Jiggy Rays was a bit greasy for my taste. Overall we will be back....fun times in Elizabethton.”

11 Papa Johns Pizza

3.1 Average 183 Reviews

727 West Elk Avenue Ste B-02B, Elizabethton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We ordered two pizzas on Sunday, Jan. 19th for carry out. It was snowing and roads were getting slick, made it to the entrance of the subdivision only to turn around and come back home. Called the store and asked for delivery and explained out dilemma. The manager made no promises, but said he would give it a try. 20 minutes later Todd pulled up to our house in a 4x4 with hot pizzas. Durning our conversation I found out that Todd was an Army veteran and he has worked with Papa John's for two years making deliveries. He explained that he enjoyed this job because he gets to meet new people every day. Thank you to the store manager and Todd. We will be ordering from Papa John's again, requesting Todd again, snow or shine. ..... oh yeah, the pizzas were great too.”