12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Maryville

“Justin Wright accommodated 30 former Maryville College basketball players and families on January 25th, 2025. Couldn't have been more pleased with the hospitality and service. Thanks Blue Tick!“

“loved Mr. Gatti's since my kids were little. They are grown now but still love coming here.“

“The large pan, supreme is flipping amazing. It’s become a Friday night tradition. Dine in!“

“Marcos is the best! We love eating there, and our experience is always amazing. Lindsey is extremely kind and always makes us feel like we are welcome and treats us like we are family. Highly recommend choosing these guys when you are in the mood for some great pizza!“

“I haven't ordered from Smokeys in a while and have only ordered wings in the past. Decided to give the pizza a try with some fried mushrooms and it was great! Try the cheeseburger pizza if you want something unique. Workers were nice and prices are fair. Smokeys will be my regular stop for a great pizza in the future. Will have to try the other varieties to see if they are as awesome as the cheeseburger pizza“

“We haven't been to Jaboni's Pizzeria since they opened, but tonight we wanted something different than our usual dining before catching a movie at the mall. The service was fast, food was delicious, and drinks were strong. Our server Nate was fantastic. Very friendly, patient, and had us to our movie right on time. We will definitely be back. The Maui Wowie pizza was savory, sweet, and different. I don't like a lot of pizza, but I will definitely be back for that one and the truffle fries. Thank you Nate for a great night with fast, friendly service. I highly recommend Jaboni's Pizzeria! Ask for Nate!“

“Karaoke on Thursday’s and drunk chicks? That’s what I am always down for.“

“The food was very good. The chicken parm was excellent. Also had the prosciutto and peach pizza which was also very good. Our server Skylen was one of the best we've had at a restaurant in a long time. She genuinely cares about the guests and the restaurant. Only downside is its quite loud due to the cement floors and walls. We definitely would return though.“

“First time having Papa John's in years. But I was presently surprise by everything. The store was clean and they had a lot of people working. Workers were friendly and busy working. The food was good, a lot of butter on the garlic bread but still good. And the jalapeño was not as good as it once was many years ago.
Who I assume to be the manager was very nice, offered us plates and extra sauce, seeing that we were talking about going somewhere to eat outside. I will be back when I get a craving again.“

“Everything they have is GREAT but my favorite is the garden salad with adding feta cheese. I love Italian dressing and my husband likes either Italian or Ranch dressing with his. Highly HIGHLY recommend.“

“the best service and employees“

“The guys and gals here are awesome! I had been working all night and called @ 11:50pm to see if I could order a couple pizza's. They not only fixed my order they thanked me for my patience. Now that might not be that big of a deal to most but to me it says what kind of wonderful people they are. The food is fantastic as well, highly recommend 😊“