Old Mill Creamery

Name: Old Mill Creamery
Address: 171 Old Mill Ave #3515, Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, 37863, US
Telephone: (865) 453-4301
Price range: $
Rating: 4.2

$ • Ice Cream, American

Hours:
171 Old Mill Ave #3515, Pigeon Forge
(865) 453-4301

About Old Mill Creamery

Old Mill Creamery is a popular ice cream shop known for its creamy and delicious treats. The oatmeal cream pie and banana pudding ice cream flavors are highly recommended. They offer a variety of ice cream flavors, muffins, and other treats with a large parking lot and outdoor seating area. The staff is friendly and the shop is fully accessible. Visitors can enjoy generous kid-sized cones, which are often quite large. The shop provides samples for those who want to try different flavors before ordering. While there are many flavors, some customers noticed limited options for chocolate ice cream, so chocolate lovers might want to check what’s available. The ice cream is great, and the shop has interesting flavors like whiskey ribbon, which is a favorite among visitors. The shop is kid-friendly and welcoming to families, making it a good spot for a fun outing. However, it’s worth noting that vegetarian options are limited, and some flavors may be a bit bland or could use more oatmeal flavor in the oatmeal cream pie ice cream. Overall, Old Mill Creamery offers high-quality ice cream in a friendly and accessible setting.