38 Best Pizza Restaurants in Amarillo

“Great staff, always fantastic food. Do yourself a favor go try it out, but also make sure you go to one of their tastings!“

“Update - The owner, Cody, called back and we had a great discussion about what happened. I appreciate Cody taking ownership of the problem and offering a solution. I've updated my overall review to 5 stars. The food is always great and ownership takes pride in his restaurant. With most businesses anymore, the problem will always be low level customer service or lack of communication.“

“I love Papa Murphy’s pizza because the toppings are plentiful and it’s easy to cook at home. All of the ingredients are really really fresh and the pizza is giant sized. It is much better than the other vendors I go to sometimes. But if Papa Murphy’s is in town, that’s where I’m going to get my pizza.“

“nice people good pizza will be back again“

“Hands Down The Fudging BEST They Be Looking Out For Folks Like I Got Home And I Realize I Forgot To Order Ranch For My Wings As Well As Ketchup For My Fries. It Was A Complete Vibe Kill Until I Open Up My Fry Box And Bam 2 Ketchup Packets And A Ranch Cup.🥹🙏🏾🤗 And Everything I Ordered Was Cooked To Perfection
#NOONEOUTPIZZASTHEHUT“

“Best pizza ever! Always eat here when we are passing through!!!“

“The food was delicious and the service was great!“

“Best pizza ever! Always eat here when we are passing through!!!“

“I have lived in Amarillo my whole and just tried their pizza for the 1st time. How have I missed this place for so long? I have definitely been missing out. This will be my go to for pissa from bow on.“

“Will be dining/taking out once a week now. We support you #LGB“

“Best pizza in Amarillo and the best staff! Thank you for the great service and delivering to our neighborhood! We love La Bella’s!“

“Just had my second pizza and it reminded me of East Coast Style. Then I heard the owner say they were East Coast Style. Delicious Pizza! Go now!“

“Place was very clean, they are a bit short staffed but the server was as attentive as possible even with many separate customers. The food was absolutely delicious and I had no complaints about the flavor and chicken wings. We don't have a sit in place where I'm from, and I'm glad we stopped by. No one beats the Hut.“

“fresh food all the time. it's the best tasting pizza I have ever had in Texas. so I recommend you come down 6th and try it. trust me you won't be disappointed.“

“This place was great. Great service and food. Fun place!“

“I love eating here. Been eating at the other locations for years. They have an awesome menu with a great variety of meals to choose from. Definitely a place to keep going and enjoying meals.“

“Valore is hands down one of our favorite places to eat! If you love Italian food, this spot is an absolute gem. The dishes are always flavorful, fresh, and beautifully presented—it’s clear the chefs take real pride in what they do. What really sets Valore apart, though, is the staff. Every time we visit, we're greeted with warm smiles and friendly, attentive service that makes us feel genuinely welcome. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy amazing food, and leave already looking forward to your next visit. Highly recommend to anyone looking for top-quality Italian cuisine in a cozy, inviting atmosphere!“

“It was my first time at Cicis Pizza, and I really enjoyed it! The pizza was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. I loved the variety — so many kinds to try! The staff was friendly, and the place was clean and comfortable. I’ll definitely come back again!“

“m mx,,x,exmmzmz,xm,mxmx mdm,m“

“Good spot for takeout or delivery, giving 90s vibes with classic topping-heavy pizza. I occasionally pop in for pizzas whenever I have an evening work meeting and need a lot of food for a lot of people. Can usually feed 10 to 15 with four pizzas and a couple salads. All of the pizzas and the chef salad are beyond generous with toppings and made fresh. My favorite pizzas to get here are the jalapeno popper and the chicken bacon ranch. The chef salad can field pricey at nine bucks for a large, but there's a lot stuffed into the box and, again, everything is always super fresh. They offer delivery but I usually go for pickup and service is great at the counter.“

“Our go-to pizza place for delivery, however this time I felt like the ham & pineapple pizza I ordered was so overloaded with pineapple (I love pineapple, but even I have my limits) that it completely overwhelmed the pizza. It was as if they tipped the container over and said "oops." I'll still eat it (even though I don't enjoy it this time) and I'll still order from them, but I hope this won't happen again.“

“This restaurant is fantastic. Their service is excellent, the food is delicious, and everyone who works there is friendly. The owner goes above and beyond to see that customers are treated correctly. I will make it a point to continue to eat here every time I am in Amarillo.“

“It's my favorite pizza place in town with a great bar. The staff is always extremely friendly, as well.“

“😍I love love their salads and when they messed up an order the manager on bell was so accommodating and replaced my order and redelivered.“

“Staff was nice and helpful from the first reservation questions to the end of the baby shower. We had a whole family event with about 20. Loved how we were able to decorate the room and everything went perfectly. Our guests had a good time choosing food on the buffet. Enjoyed everything from salad, pizza sticks, pizza and ice cream. Best party place around! Thank you!“

“Pizza was good. Pizza guy had no cheeses or peppers. How you deliver pizza with no cheese and peppers????“

“I got a takeout order online from this location and I had William as my delivery driver. I never leave reviews but his service made me want to go out of my way to say thank you! He was extremely kind and had fast service! My food arrived warm and delicious. Again I want to point out his amazing service, he is a great guy!“

“The Best Pizza Hut in Town! Thank You For The Best Service. Awesome ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“A group of girlfriends and I were in town to for the weekend and decided to end our trip with some brunch here before heading back home. Everything was exceptionally delicious and the decore was so cute! I love that the staff isn't limited to a strict dress code and we were able to see different personalities in how they presented themselves. 10/10 would recommend and would definitely eat here again.“

“Godfather's Pizza brings back a taste from earlier times it is an incredible pizza, it really tastes wonderful I would put it up against anyone's pizza. If you haven't ever tried Godfather's you really need to you won't be disappointed. Try it once you'll never want anybody else's Pizza.“

“excellent delivery and service“

“Great staff! Delicious fast quality food!!“

“Thanks for my order you guys everything arrived really fresh and extravagantly delicious.....might I add the delivery driver arrived 15 to 20 minutes early....keep up the good work in the kitchen. Keep up the amazing service ....as well as to you to the delivery drivers out there who chooses customers satisfaction....will definelty recommend and will absolutely order again 😁🤓🙀...nicely done!“

“Wonderful staff. Very attentive. Thanks! Dakota was great. Cait is so great to visit with.“

“The customer service here is amazing. Last week I ordered 2 pizzas, one of which didn’t have the pineapples I ordered on it. Not a big deal, once I noticed I just called to get a refund for the up charge. The man that answered the phone, I’m assuming the manager (unfortunately I didn’t get his name) immediately said he would remake both pizzas for free, either then or at a later time. I chose later & thanked him. Called back today, he said he remembered me & to give him 15 minutes to have the pizzas ready. He even brought them out to me when he noticed I was sitting in my car. Thank you so much once again!“

“So your pizza is still good, but I am so sad that you changed your sauces! Please got back to the pesto. It's what made you stand out. Thank you! 😊“

“I have lived all across the United States from San Diego to Philadelphia. This ifir sure one of the best Pizza establishments in Amarillo. I'm Bombcity native born in a hospital right on Route 66 and have been in the food service industry since j was 15. The pies and other dishes in this establishment are made with love and it shows in every bite. I would give the staff more stars if I could. I have nothing but great things to say about this particular joint. It by far one of my favorite spots to hit up when I'm in Bombcity.“

“Love this location so much, my favorite! Everything from the quick preparation, my orders, the food itself and the kind employees and delivery drivers I've had (Cody/Joe) are all nothing but exceptional every single time! Very much appreciated! ❤“