Andy's Frozen Custard

$ • Ice Cream

Menu Order Online

About Andy's Frozen Custard

Andy's Frozen Custard offers a wide variety of flavors and toppings, from simple vanilla and chocolate to custom concretes. The quality is consistently excellent, with perfectly smooth and delicious custard. The staff is friendly and patient, providing great service. A customer's favorite is the blackberry concrete, and the KEY lime pie with roasted pecans is also delicious. The place is also kid-friendly, offering corn hole toss for everyone.

Customers describe Andy’s as serving frozen euphoria in a cup, with the custard being irresistibly smooth and creamy. The brownie bits are good and actual brownie bits, not overly chewy. Some note that concrete toppings can be skimpy and there can be inadequate blending of the concretes, with ingredients only in the top part. Plenty of workers are inside, working quickly to keep lines moving, though they may not always pay attention to the finished product. The customer service is highly praised, with the people described as fine and dedicated. Overall, visiting Andy's provides a wonderful and peaceful experience, and the custard is a treat worth returning for.