50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Garden Ridge

“My husband I love to go here. It’s cozy and the waitresses are always wonderful. We always get the fettuccine Alfredo. Said last night we should try something new, but the sauce is so good. It’s our ‘go to’ place.“

“Best pizza in New Braunfels. The supreme pizza was indeed supreme and their pepperoni pizza rolls are the best I have ever had. I called in an order and it was delivered hot and fresh within 25 minutes. Courteous staff. Will be going back for more!“

“In for the 2nd time. We ordered a 16’ honey bear and a garden salad. With the Mattenga’s Ranch (must try) both were yummy and flavorful. Best part of our experience was our server Seneyah!!! She was attentive and her customer service was 5⭐️! We’ll be back.“

“I was excited to learn about this place from my son, as we've not found a truly remarkable pizza in San Antonio. We loved Ms Ellies, but since it closed, nothing else has checked all the right buttons on our pizza meter. The crust was phenomenal....thin base, bubbled up charred edges, slight crisp on the surface giving way to the perfect chew. The sauce...perfect in its simplicity...just tomatoes and not much else, if anything....perfect amount of cheese (light) so it doesn't weigh down the pie. Fresh basil. Sopressata. It's a walk-up window, and some small seating areas outside... no dine-in option at present. I can't hold that against them. It's just where they are in their Journey so far. But I do look forward to the time that they have a dine-in area and wine to enjoy with their fabulous pizza.“

“3.14, and it was super busy. The employees seemed very overwhelmed with all the orders. There was a line out the door just for people waiting to pick up orders. I ordered online and came for pick up when I was notified it was ready. I still had to wait 40 minutes. I could see my order number sitting on the counter the whole time. When I was finally able to make it in to pick up my order, my small caprese wasn't there. One employee asked another employee to make it. She walked in the back and came out to look up at the menu as if she was trying to figure out how to make it. She walked around some more and never really did any work. Another employee who seemed to be cooking asked what I was waiting for, and he went in the back to make it. He was very apologetic. It seemed like no one was in charge, and they couldn't keep up. I myself work in a very busy kitchen, I do understand. A thought would be for one employee to start calling out the order numbers as they are stacking up on the counter. When someone steps up to claim said items, then verify who they are with that order. Instead, customers had to wait in long lines as their food just sat there. The guest behind me had ordered a 16" and a 10" but received 2, 10". He had waited so long he didn't want a refund he just took the 2 he was given. Great pizza but very unorganized for such a busy day. Whoever was in charge at the O'Connor location should have called Matt or Enga and let them know they were overwhelmed.“

“Loved MAARS Pizza. if you are a pizza lover this place is recommended for you. The pizza they serve here is big and delicious. 4 stars.“

“The staff is always wonderful and the food is delicious! We love coming here“

“Our favorite pizza place in town! My hunny and I have been there several times, pizza always top notch as well as the wings! Customer service has always been amazing, they already know our drink order! Multiple TVs to catch your favorite team. Trivia night is always a blast! We HIGHLY recommend this place if you’re in the area 😁“

“been coming here for YEARS and still love everything they serve“

“Sat at the bar for some drinks and Taylor took great care of me!“

“We hosted a Celebration of Life at BJ's Brewhouse, Hwy 281 N. Could not have been more satisfied with the atmosphere, service, and especially the food. There were 80 of us with the Pizza and Salad Buffet. EVERYBODY there remarked how wonderful how wonderful the pizza and service were. I've heard terms like "never had pizza this good", "the service was excellent", "wonderful place." I highly recommend this particular location for events. EXCELLENT.“

“súper rico todo, un muy buen ambiente y el personal muy amable“

“This is our go to spot now. I have tried quite a few different things from the menu and everything has been really good. My favorite is the meat calzone but Friday night we had the chicken Alfredo pizza and it’s right up there now. They remember names and faces also and that means something to me. Always friendly.“

“Best Italian food in San Antonio!! It’s BYOB also right now until they get their liquor license, so you can bring your favorite wine or beer to enjoy with your meal. The pizzas are huge and the pasta is delicious.“

“The owner and staff are very personable. The food is consistently great and they have a lot of unique and classic options to order. I love that you can get pizza by the slice during the day and it’s in a great location(you can get ice cream right next door after you eat at ice ice baby) the prices are fair and the food is delicious!“

“we waited awhile for our food and we were the only ones there. Plus, they have no ice for their drinks?? who does that???“

“Amazing pizza, tried both the New York and Detroit style. Both styles were delicious and cooked to perfection. Also tried a order of the fresh cut fries, delicious!!
We ordered take out this time so we didn't get to enjoy the live music, definitely plan on going back when we can stay awhile.“

“Excellent food! Love the plantains!“

“My delivery person was wonderful! Big smile, kindly said hello & how are you (like he really meant it) and then asked if he could hand me a package from the porch. Hallelujah for good service! It doesn’t happen too often lately and should be celebrated. .“

“grear ceasar salad, bread sticks were great, pepperoni pizza was great, cheese again great, chicken bbq was definitely the best I've ever had. thank you very much!!“

“Great pizza (can order by the pie or slice), pasta, stromboli, sandwiches, salads, soup, and other Italian dishes with good wine and beer. Our whole party enjoyed our varoious orders in a casual atmosphere. Live music, sports TV, and bar seating. Nightly specials. Excellent service given to our large party by Hayley! We'll be back.“

“I ordered pizzas for my daughter’s birthday a week ahead of time. I then changed my order multiple times between the date I placed it and actually picked it up.... Despite all of this.... my pizzas were perfect, they had them done early... and helped me to my car! I couldnt have asked for better service! They made sure to give me any coupons that were going on too! Thanks Domino’s for making my daughter’s birthday a hit! You rock!!!“

“Fish and chips were awesome.“

“We had the pleasure of dining at BJ’s on this pass week and encountered Ebony T. Ebony was our server who made sure our overall experience was good and delightful. She ensured our food was served promptly and exceeded our expectations throughout our dining experience. The next time we dine at this BJ’s we’ll be sure to ask to be in Ebony’s section. If you’re every in the Live Oak area and choose BJ’s please ask if Ebony can accommodate you in her section. The food didn’t disappoint either especially the famous pazookie.“

“This place has never given me no issues , the customer service is great ! The food is always done fast & delicious . I’ve been here plenty of times for pick up orders and I’ve only ever seen one person dine in . They do not do the buffet dine in at this location , but you’re able to sit and eat your own pizza at a table . This Place is always clean & the decorations give nostalgia .“

“We don't live in the delivery area, but decided to stop by once to give Marco's a try while out and about. We quickly decided it's worth the drive. This time it was pizzoli for everyone! 7 pizzoli for 2 adults and 3 teenage boys. We all were very satisfied with our dinner.

The ambiance isn't earth-shattering by any means, but the staff are all nice and the food is great. So what we have to drive to get it; we can pretend we're pioneers or it's 2019 again. Absolutely worth it.“

“Great food! I would definitely recommend this place.“

“Hello! I am not too sure who helped me in the front but I believe it was a manager a few minutes ago. The manager was so nice and saw I had my baby siblings in the car along with my brother and gave us some free cookies. It was a nice gesture and I appreciate it so much!“

“We had a great time! The food was good and the staff was very friendly. We will be coming back!“

“I didn't realize that thin pizza meant burnt, crispy crackers with tidbits of your selection of protein. The service and delivery was so fast that they didn't have time to bake the pizzas at a nominal time frame to insure a freshly baked pie of perfection. Delivery person was awesome. but, overall I was Disappointed.“

“Clean. Great staff is always an asset. The characters are good bout mingling with he kids.“

“First time visiting... decided to grab the spaghetti dinner, a cold sub & cheesecake (to go)! Everything was DELICIOUS!!! So grateful to have spotted this GEM! Definitely returning to a new favorite spot!“

“I’ve come to know this store as a very reliable fall back on rough days after work. Two years of ordering, and not all of them on bad days but definitely always on a bad day - And the people here are consistent each and every time, I’ve never seen them miss.

It’s a comfort, knowing no matter how wrong things can go in a day, I can at least end it safely with the effort they put into the work they do and service they provide. Yeah, maybe it’s just a pizza, but it’s a pizza I know is gonna be good, I can count on it being the one good thing to come out of a day of bad things.

What happens when after a bad day, there’s a disappointing delivery out of all the other times they’ve done great? I forgive, because I get that things get rough, and I know how it feels not to get everything right every time. It’s incredibly human, and I appreciate the staff here for showing up everyday and making this bit of peace for me, and others.“

“Delivered wrong pizza. Tried to charge for sending out correct pizza. Told it would be an hour more. Not even a sorry bout that, then hung up.“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“The best little caesars in San Antonio. The Italian cheese bread tastes spectacular, the crazy bread. They season them very well and make more parmesan cheese than at any other little caesars in San Antonio. Always fresh and if you want to advance I recommend that you place your order in the app, it is very easy and fast“

“*** this was a 3 star but they resolved the problem so quick and they were very nice about it!
We’ve never had a problem here until last night. We got someone else’s pizza and got all the way home before we noticed it so we just ate it. It was going to be too much of a hassle to drive back up there. The pizza is good, service is good, just unfortunate that we didn’t get what we ordered!“

“I went to the Bulverde HEB and I tried the pizza for the first time Tris was very inviting and welcoming. I told him this was my first time purchasing their pizza and he made me feel very confident in my decision. I got to my car and tried it and instead of leaving I had to go back in and buy another pizza because Bulverde is the only location near my area that sells tacos and pizza. I think that they should add this menu to evey location . I think it's more affordable for families, the barbecue is fine but is on the pricey side and everyone can't afford to feed their whole family on that service. This is a number 1 seller and should be available at every HEB franchise. 😊“

“We absolutely love the manager and deliver drivers but almost every time we order the pasta we get about 10 bites out of it. We know it's not going to be completely full but for $5.99 we should get it at least hallway full. Please please fix this problem. Thank you, Jennie“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Best Pizza and Italian restaurant in New Braunfels, with the best service ...and now it is, sadly, closing.“

“First time to ever try it tonight and I admit, we were a little skeptical but it was very good pizza and bread sticks and the service was great! We will definitely be ordering from there again.“

“It was a Friday night and Cody was rockin'! He was by himself and was doing it all... making the food, taking order and handling customers! He was super sweet and helpful and went out of his way to help everyone there! I highly recommend this Marco's... especially when Cody is working!“

“Just great pizza. It has an eclectic atmosphere. The Music mix is a highly underrated aspect to any restaurant, and Mod's mix was on point. The lunch special of pizza and a drink for $12 I consider to be a fair deal, as well. I'll gladly return.“

“Thank you so much for your donation of 6 pizzas to the Samuel Clemens varsity football team weekly Feed the Herd Team dinner. They enjoyed every slice!“

“So excited this location opened near us! It’s so clean and huge!! The best part though was fresh hot food and awesome customer service!! Colby & Ashley helped us today and they were awesome! Super sweet and kind. Thanks for the best lunch! We had our daughter with us and it was a rainy day but it turned out to be good thanks to y’all!“

“We had pizza, wings and pasta delivered. They were very quick and the delivery man was friendly. The pasta was very dry and hard. Not the best Pizza Hut pasta. I have tried at many locations. The pizza and wings were good. We would order again but stay away from pasta. This is disappointing because we don t always want pizza.“

“Always delicious! Hot and ready! Plenty of toppings on mine! I love this Pizza Hut!“

“Just went to grab a slice of pizza. The place seemed like a nice bar where you can get pizza. The guy working was extremely nice and went above and beyond. I got a cheese slice. Really inexpensive. I was surprised. Crust was great but I'm picky about sauce and it was okay. It was fresh and hot. I didnt feel like i wasted my money. All in all it was decent. I Will have to go back to take the whole place in. But to get a slice of pizza on the go, I'd go again.“