17 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Braunfels

Guadalupe Brewing Company & Pizza Kitchen Brewery • $$
1586 Wald Rd, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Canadian Bacon Olives Half Pepperoni Half Sausage
Detroit 1586 Pepperoni Pizza
Detroit Style Pizza
Cheeseburger
Beer Flight
Pretzel
Burger
Wings

“Fabulous place to grab some delicious beer. It has a super chill outdoor seating area that’s well-shaded and lovely! We had their Detroit style pizza and it was pretty good - great cook on the crust for sure - good topping choices. (: Overall I highly recommend spending time here. It’s quite pleasant. (:“

4.7 Superb94 Reviews
Bootleggers Pizza Parlor Pizza • $$
197 S Seguin Ave, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Buttered Crust Pizza with Pepperoni Peppers and Onions
Create Your Own Pizza
Blackberry Bees Knees
Loaded Potato Wedges
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Fried Mozzarella
Chicken Parmesan
Meat Head Pizza
Antipasto Salad

“It was my first time their and it definitely won't be my last pizza is so far the best in New Braunfels, definitely delicious and worth a try it's made just right I had a customized pizza with German potatoes and mozzarella sticks and supposed bread sticks which they left out but I understand they were busy, and as a person that works in the food industry I usually don't complain I'm sure they'll make it up to me when I stop by again.. Appreciate the hard work and definitely the food was ? stop by you would think the same.“

4.6 Superb119 Reviews
NB's Wicked Bah Pizza Pizza •
111 S Union Ave #123, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Tiramisu Cake and Italian Cream Cake
Wicked Loaded and Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni and Jalapeno Pizza
Italian Coconut Creme Cake
Wicked Cheesy Garlic Bread
Buffalo Chicken Eggroll
Cheese Garlic Bread
Spicy Honey Drizzle
Wicked Greek Salad
10 Meat Lovers

“Y'all!! OMG is all I have to say! My husband and I are such pizza snobs and could not wait to try NB's Wicked Bah Pizza!! When we looked at the menu, we were surprised to only see a 10" option size pizzas, but we were excited to see that because we thought it would be a great idea to order several different ones each time so we could try all the different combinations. Their pizza is not like the normal pizza what we are used to with so much dough and crust. The pizzas are filled to the brim with toppings and the toppings go all the way around the pizza, so it is like a crustless pizza. ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS and our new favorite pizza place in town. Not to mention, the owners are the SWEETEST!!!!!!!Another aamazing item on their menu are the egg rolls! WOWZER!!!!!! Words cannot describe how fantastic these are and melt in your mouth, you just need to try for yourself! ? ? ?“

4.5 Superb137 Reviews
Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels Pizza • $$
2180 TX-46 Ste 107, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Calzone Includes Mozz and Ricotta Cheese
Buffalo Wings Mild Medium Hot
10 Gluten Free Crust Pizza
20 Mattenga's 1 2 & 1 2
Thai Sweet Chili Wings
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pretzel Sticks
Brisket Pizza

“I travel in RV and am always searching for a good pie. My Supreme pie from Mattenga's was excellent. The first thing you'll notice is a plethora of fresh toppings. Since I got a supreme, it was loaded with fresh veggies (in addition to peppperoni and sausage). I'm talking lots of veggies and enough red sauce (slightly sweet tang) to make every bite enjoyable. Being from Upstate NY, I tend to prefer NY style thin crust but their crust, while thicker, was semi-firm but light and chewy at the same time. Thanks for a great pie!“

4.4 Superb97 Reviews
Di's Homemade Pizza Pizza • $
211 W Lincoln St, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Breadsticks with Cheese Add 1 50
One-Topping Pizza
John's Meat Loverz
Almost Gone Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage

“I own a landscape company and me and my guys fixed a fence for the restaurant owner, she got us a free pizzas for everyone, the pizzas are a out of this world, she has a wonderful soul and smile I will never forget that ,my favorite pizza place in texas ♥️“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
Noli's Vite Pizza • $
1744 E Common St, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

5 People Chicken Parmigiana
Kids Spaghetti and Meatballs
Pepperoni Mushroom Calzone
Chicken Vegetable Soup
Shrimp Noli's Special
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Florentine
Noli's Variety Mix
Garlic Knot Bread
Sausage Arrabiata

“I love New Braunfels, but very few food places give you that "wow" factor in town, and my brothers in Christ, this place had that wow factor. I went for lunch with my little brother and we shared the sampler appetizers and everything was delicious. Shrimp were large and fried to perfection, calamari were crispy, and the mozzarella cheese sticks slapped. I ordered a stromboli and buddy in the kitchen that made it, made it well. Noli's will definitely enter my rotation of "you know you're going to get good food" places.“

4.3 Superb107 Reviews
Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits Pizza • $$
1198 Gruene Rd, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Chips and Marinara Sauce
Spaghetti Meatballs Marinara
Classic Caesar Salad
Mediterranean Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Well Done
Boss Hog Pizza
Inferno Pizza
Veggie Pizza
The Big One

“Hands down best pizza I’ve ever had! We took our 3 kids and ordered a large Mediterranean and two orders of pizza chips, and a half wedge salad. O.M.G Delicious!!! My best description of the quality and flavor would be the Pappadeaux of pizza!! We will literally never order pizza or Italian from any where else local. The flavor from everything we ordered was out of this world good. Can’t wait to try the drinks for our next date night!“

4.3 Superb96 Reviews
Peter Piper Pizza Pizza • $
1286 I 35 N Frontage Rd, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Jalapeño Bacon Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
Strawberry Crunch Dessert
Cinnamon Crunch Dessert
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Garlic Cheese Bread
Chicago Pizza
Birthday Cake
Salad Bar
Bone

“Great place to take the kiddos either for parties or just a treat. The arcade games entertain the kids and the pizza is surprisingly good for the parents. I had the wings also while I was there. They were supposed to be buffalo style but there was no sauce on them. But they were surprisingly moist and tasty without the sauce. The staff was exceptional and helpful. My grandkids would probably pick this place to go again if given a choice.“

4.3 Superb85 Reviews
Cicis Pizza Pizza • $
121 I 35 N Frontage Rd Ste 300-A, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Nashville Hot N Spicy Chicken Pizza
Mac and Cheese - Specialty Pizza
An Assortment of Pizza Slices
Giant Pizza Value Meal
Spinach Alfredo Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza
Garlic Cheese Bread
Mac & Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Chicken

“Not anywhere close to a delicious NY pizza but nice selection of always hot pies. Price is great but it does bring in a rather scary looking clientele. The salad bar was surprisingly nice. Just wish they had spinach. Cinnamon buns were the highlight. Way too “

4.3 Superb72 Reviews
Above Ground Pizza Pizza • $$
311 FM306, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza and Lemonade Sangria
Sir William Creamy Garlic Mushroom Pie
Make It a Calzone with Ricotta Cheese
Lunch Special Pizza
Classic Caesar Salad
Mediterranean Pizza
7 Margherita Pizza
Buffalo Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Mushroom Dip

“It has been three months, but I still think about this pizza! Some places talk about their woodfired ovens, Above Ground actually has the taste of wood firing and that is a good thing! We found out about it from a local and it has the feel of a well kept gourmet secret. We made sure to get a big enough pizza that we could take some home with us on the long drive back to Dallas. It didn't make it for a second day before being devoured. We will be back when we can! If you're in the area, even just passing through, it's worth the stop.“

4.2 Good99 Reviews
MOD Pizza Pizza • $
272 FM306 Suite 106, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Mad Dog with Jalapenos
Create Your Own Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pesto Drizzle
No Name Cake
Caesar Salad
Meat Lovers
Mod Pizza
Sauce
BBQ

“My pizza was delicious, however my husband said the opposite of his. He says his was too salty. The tables were all dirty and sticky and there were a lot of drinks that were empty or out of order.The service was wonderful! Everyone was friendly and fast and very organized.“

4.2 Good84 Reviews
Stout's Pizza Co. Pizza • $
1850 TX-46 Suite 101, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

The Original Calzone
Chicken Bacon Ranch
The Stout Special
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Rolls
Avocado Salad
Cheesy Bread
Meat Lovers
Supreme

“Husband and I went on a Tuesday night. Staff was friendly and attentive. We shared a Ceasar salad and a large pepperoni pizza. The lettuce was nice and cold and the large pieces of Parmigiano cheese were nice. Their pizza crust was nice and soft, not hard or crusty. It has a great flavor. I love that the tomato sauce is not spicy.“

4.3 Superb50 Reviews
New York Pizza Pub Pizza • $
2345 TX-337 Loop, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Southern or Grilled Chicken Salad
Pepperoni Mushrooms and Sausage
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Butcher Shop Pizza
Whole Wheat Crust
Chicken Tenders
Buffalo Tenders
Supreme Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Cheeseburger

“New York Pizza Pub is right around the corner from our house and we frequently buy pizza from them. Their garlic knots are amazing. The pizza is usually amazing. "Usually" is the only reason I'm hesitant to give 5 stars. Most of the time the cheese, sauce, topping, bread ratio is on point, the pizza is evenly cooked and not burnt, and the service is prompt and polite. Every once in a while it seems like we hit a busy night or perhaps a new hire and one of those things slips a bit. It's never bad enough to wish we hadn't ordered, just noticeable when you get used to the typical quality. It has happened enough times to know it's also not just a one time occurrence. Otherwise we're very happy to have them so close! Keep up the good work!“

4.1 Good116 Reviews
Lucy Cooper's Ice House Bar • $$
1515 Kuehler Ave, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fried Devil Eggs
Breaded Wings and Fries
Southern Fish N Chips
Fried Green Tomatoes
Cheeseburger Eggrolls
Disco Club Sandwich
Donut Brunch Burger
Fried Deviled Eggs
Bar Soft Pretzel
Pepperoni Pizza

“First time coming in Ally was our bartender she was amazing so attentive.I got Bet Yo' Sweet A$$ Margarita it was delicious!! Shared the Tin Can Nachos they were pretty good really messy, needed more cheese throughout nachos. Over all experience it was great. We will definitely come back in.“

4.1 Good88 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
606 S Walnut Ave Suite 400, New Braunfels

“We adore Papa Murphy's... It's its own thing and we have enjoyed pizza and movie night at home for years. We have tried other pizzas, but Papa Murphy's is always fresh and they are always willing to help with our family's ever changing tastes! Barbeque Chicken, Hawaiian with extra pineapple, no sauce (it's a kid thing), you can order anything you can imagine! Love the speedy service, we call it in and pick it up on our way home!! Pizza is ready, gotta go!!! Deeeeelicious ?“

4.2 Good20 Reviews
Villanovas pizza Pizza Takeaway • $
1514 W San Antonio St, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Ranch Lovers
Large Pizza
Meatzza
Black
Wings

“Great pizza. We are from out of town but when we're back in New Braunfels we ALWAYS get pizza to go from Villanova's! Thank you for always having great tasting pizza and for being so friendly! We called and ordered when we were in San Marcos and I told Mr. Villanova that we'll be a bit late BUT we'll be there. He said ok. We loved it.“

4.1 Good30 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
316 Business, I 35 Frontage Rd, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Extra Cheese Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Lava Cake

“Starting this review with a WOW! Food was way above reproach. Fresh, hot, excellent taste! While so many restaurants just get by, this Dominoes knocked it out of the park. Order was perfect and that is rare in this day and age. Steven delivered our order and he was not only nice, he was very professional. UNEQUIVOCALLY UNEQUALED!“

4 Good47 Reviews
Loading...
map Map