29 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Braunfels

“Best pizza in New Braunfels. The supreme pizza was indeed supreme and their pepperoni pizza rolls are the best I have ever had. I called in an order and it was delivered hot and fresh within 25 minutes. Courteous staff. Will be going back for more!“

“Fantastic meat lovers pizza. 10 minutes for a huge pie. My new go to pizza place. Nice scenery.“

“Took five teenage boys to Bootleggers Pizza Parlor after a full day at Schlitterbahn. "It's actually fire.""This pizza is low-key goated.""This food is bussin'.""Massive W.""They cooked.""No cap, I'd come back." Not a crumb was left on the table. The staff was awesome, and somehow they managed to satisfy five starving teenage boys who had been at the water park all day. That's basically a miracle. I liked it, too. No cap.“

“We have eaten in the restaurant. Lastnight I ordered from Grubhub. The food was delicious. Best Minestrone I’ve ever had. ?“

“Delicious pizza and great patio!“

“I have been a happy Papa Murphys customer for over 30 years. Two pizzas ago I submitted a review that stated that the amount of toppings seemed to have decreased and that they did not spread out to the edge of the pizza. This last order however did not disappoint! Toppings were just right and spread evenly! Thank you for being my number 1 pizza choice after all these years!“

“Reserved space for granddaughter’s 15 BDay. The food is exceptional, customer service from Management to wait staff were wonderful in every way. All was sanitized. We had an amazing time! Thank you!“

“MOD Pizza is hands down one of my favorite pizza places in town! Every single time I come here, the experience is amazing—from the atmosphere and incredible customer service to how quickly and carefully everything is prepared.

A special shoutout to Chase and Sav, who always take such great care of me. They bring such an abundance of positivity and genuinely make you feel welcomed the moment you walk through the door. Their energy, friendliness, and attention to detail are a huge part of what makes coming here such a great experience.

You can genuinely see the care that goes into making every pizza. Everything is fresh, made exactly how you want it, and somehow comes out amazing every single time. I honestly can’t think of a single visit where I haven’t enjoyed my pizza.

Great food, great atmosphere, incredible efficiency, and even better people. I can confidently recommend MOD Pizza as one of the absolute best pizza places in town. Chase, Sav, and the entire team deserve recognition for the amazing experience they consistently provide. Keep up the incredible work! 🍕❤“

“safe and clean and tons of fun“

“We went today Easter Sunday, beautiful and super clean restaurant, we ordered a family package, excellent price, the flavor of the brisket was delicious, the attention of the owners was perfect, the best way to spend Ester, Thank you“

“Was so hopeful, but the pizza was disappointing. My carry out oder of "The Big One" was a disaster. I wish I could have attached a photo. The pizza did not look anything like the photo. Crust was flat and without rise. No red onions present, kalamata olives were replaced with canned black olives, and is that fresh basil on the pizza in the photo? Unfortunate and very regretable.“

“Loved the pizza! Had a crispy crust and just the right amount of toppings and cheese. Staff was super friendly and happy. Will go back!“

“Bill the manager and the staff are the sweetest. I wish I could attach a picture of my custom made Dish by Bill but unfortunately I’m not able to. But BIG THANKS TO BILL FOR WHO YOU ARE AND HOW YOU TREAT YOUR Customers . STARS ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️♥️“

“Amazing pizza, tried both the New York and Detroit style. Both styles were delicious and cooked to perfection. Also tried a order of the fresh cut fries, delicious!!
We ordered take out this time so we didn't get to enjoy the live music, definitely plan on going back when we can stay awhile.“

“We ordered a large Italian Sausage and Mushroom pizza from the Mattenga's App, which is very easy to use. The pizza was really tasty. The crust was super-flavorful, which is rarely the case with other pizza places. Also, they do not skimp on the toppings! You can tell all of the ingredients are very fresh. Everything about the experience was great, from ordering to pick-up. Looking forward to our next pizza night!“

“I really appreciated that they did not have any televisions. The pizza itself was delivered piping hot. They also offered a wide array of different pizza choices, and everything seemed impeccably clean. Overall, I honestly couldn't find any fault with the experience.“

“Opened up early for me to complete a large order. Really appreciated it!“

“Delicious food, excellent service, generous portions! Best Garlic Knots in Texas!“

“The pizza was really really good and the pizza roll was good too! Ranch tasted homemade, half the staff was nice the other half seemed mad/ disappointed they were working on 4th and you could tell lol, overall definitely would try this place again.“

“The customer service provided to us by Frank was absolutely amazing. I appreciated his kindness and smile. The food is absolutely out of this world. The best Buffalo chicken salad EVER***!!! The pizza was so tasty and the onion rings...oh my...delicious. We will be back for Monday cornhole for sure“

“Awesome place to hangout, great atmosphere, rad staff & delicious menu 🍕🤘🏼“

“Taste reminded me of a place near Chicago called wells brothers Italian pizza and they are amongst top 10 us pizza places. It taste very authentic. I will be back with friends and family.service was fast like 10 min I was already eating and the staff was very friendly. Thanks above the ground pizza ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“The pizza’s good, but more than that I LOVE the atmosphere. Very family friendly. Upbeat vibe. The employees and manager are all terrific. I’ve only had good experiences here.“

“When I called to place an order Mieka answered the phone. She was VERY kind and super helpful. She repeated all information back to me to make sure everything was correct. Mieka also delivered our pizza and was just as kind in person as she was on the phone! She definitely made our experience a great one! Oh and the pizza was delicious!“

“When I called to place an order Mieka answered the phone. She was VERY kind and super helpful. She repeated all information back to me to make sure everything was correct. Mieka also delivered our pizza and was just as kind in person as she was on the phone! She definitely made our experience a great one! Oh and the pizza was delicious!“

“Marcos Pizza on Walnut Avenue in new Braunfels Texas is one of the best places to go. Manager Kayla is amazing. She helped me feed an entire group of fundraiser volunteers🧑‍💼 . I could not have done this without her. If you’re in the new Braunfels area, please go by and give Kayla your love and business.“

“They have a central answering service for orders and I was sent to the wrong location despite me clarifying the location to pick up the pizza. Fortunately the manager understood since this was not the first time this has happened. She even gave me a discount. I felt bad having food wasted. But I am glad she was so understanding and I hope the stores General / Regional managers see this and make corrections to their ordering system.“

“Anytime I order a pizza from Domino's it is always fresh and hot with plenty of toppings. The delivery people are always fast and friendly, especially Samantha! My dogs love Samantha :-)“

“staff is very rude and dismissive lady on the phone hung up on me mid sentence as I was trying to request something. that's not the customer service I ever want to experience ever again. shame on this lady and this location“