26 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Braunfels

Noli's Vite Pizza • $
1744 E Common St, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Kids Spaghetti and Meatballs
Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce
5 People Chicken Parmigiana
Pepperoni Mushroom Calzone
People Spaghetti Marinara
Salad with House Dressing
Chicken Vegetable Soup
Shrimp Noli's Special
Chocolate Cheesecake
Eggplant Parmigiana

“We have eaten in the restaurant. Lastnight I ordered from Grubhub. The food was delicious. Best Minestrone I’ve ever had. ?“

4.6 Superb231 Reviews
Bootleggers Pizza Parlor Pizza • $
197 S Seguin Ave, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Buttered Crust Pizza with Pepperoni Peppers and Onions
Pot Roast and Beer Cheese
Balsamic Chicken Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza
Blackberry Bees Knees
Loaded Potato Wedges
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Chicken Bacon Ranch
15 Pepperoni Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza

“Straight up perfect! Clean, hospitable, relaxing, pizza outstanding!“

4.6 Superb203 Reviews
Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels Pizza • $
2180 TX-46 Ste 107, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Calzone Includes Mozz and Ricotta Cheese
Buffalo Wings Mild Medium Hot
10 Gluten Free Crust Pizza
20 Mattenga's Molto Meat
SM Spinach Caprese Salad
20 Mattenga's 1 2 & 1 2
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Thai Sweet Chili Wings
20 Texas Pothole Pizza
20 Honey Bexar Pizza

“Best pizza in New Braunfels. The supreme pizza was indeed supreme and their pepperoni pizza rolls are the best I have ever had. I called in an order and it was delivered hot and fresh within 25 minutes. Courteous staff. Will be going back for more!“

4.7 Superb132 Reviews
Crust Pizza Co. - New Braunfels Pizza • $
2955 Town Center Dr #400, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Kids Spaghetti w Meatball
Crusted Goat Cheese Salad
10 One Topping Special
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Barbque Chicken Pizza
10 Big Buffalo Chicken
10 Pepperoni Supreme
Garlic Cheese Bread
Kids Mac & Cheese
Pepperoni Rolls

“Crust New Braunfels has become our favorite pizza. The staff is awesome and the pizza is always great. Recommend trying the stuffed or double crust“

4.5 Superb184 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
606 S Walnut Ave Suite 400, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Dairy-Free Cheese Mini Murph Pepperoni
Pepperoni & Mozzarella Calzone
Herb Chicken Mediterranean
Dairy-Free Cheese Hawaiian
Chicken Bacon Artichoke
Cheesy Pepperoni Pizza
Papa's All Meat Pizza
Murphy's Combo Pizza
Cowboy Keto Friendly
Gourmet Vegetarian

“We ordered online, and it was very easy. The prices were great. They came with clear, easy to follow directions. Our pizzas were made quickly and accurately, and they tasted amazing! The NY pepperoni made me feel like I was back in NYC.“

4.8 Superb77 Reviews
Di's Homemade Pizza Pizza • $
211 W Lincoln St, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Breadsticks with Cheese Add 1 50
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Lily's One-Topping Pizza
Can't Wait to Eat Pizza
John's Meat Loverz
Almost Gone Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage

“Fantastic meat lovers pizza. 10 minutes for a huge pie. My new go to pizza place. Nice scenery.“

4.7 Superb92 Reviews
Peter Piper Pizza Pizza • $
1286 I 35 N Frontage Rd, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Cheese Bread Original Wings
Jalapeño Bacon Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
Strawberry Crunch Dessert
Cinnamon Crunch Dessert
Handmade Breadsticks
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Chicken Alfredo
5 Meat Supreme
Birthday Cake

“safe and clean and tons of fun“

4.4 Superb109 Reviews
Cicis Pizza Pizza • $
121 I 35 N Frontage Rd Ste 300-A, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Zesty Ham and Cheddar - Specialty Pizza
Nashville Hot N Spicy Chicken Pizza
Mac and Cheese - Specialty Pizza
An Assortment of Pizza Slices
Old Fashioned Pepperoni Pizza
Zesty Ham & Cheddar Pizza
Giant Pizza Value Meal
Bavarian Dessert Pizza
Spinach Alfredo Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza

“Had a great experience at Cicis in New Braunfels! The staff was super friendly and stayed on top of everything. Kendal especially went above and beyond—easily some of the best customer service I’ve had in a while. Thanks for making our visit so smooth!“

4.4 Superb104 Reviews
Round Table Pizza Pizza • $
675 N Business Interstate Hwy 35, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Personal Meat Lovers Pizza
Breadsticks
Salad Bar

“I’m super picky about pizza and I swear I’ve tried every place in town hoping to find a go-to for good pizza. I think this will be the place! A little pricey… but after ordering from somewhere subpar tonight, I’m happy to pay a little more for Round Table because the pizza is super good ?. I think their secret is in the sauce ?“

4.6 Superb54 Reviews
BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Pizza • $$
2951 Cold Spring Dr, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Enlightened Cherry Chipotle Glazed Salmon
Jambalaya Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes
Loaded Nachos Piranha Pale Ale Chili
Build Your Own Beer Flight
Broccoli Cheddar Soup
Chicken Pot Stickers
BJ's Original Wings
Sweet Potato Fries
Brewhouse Sampler
House Wedge Salad

“Reserved space for granddaughter’s 15 BDay. The food is exceptional, customer service from Management to wait staff were wonderful in every way. All was sanitized. We had an amazing time! Thank you!“

4.2 Good203 Reviews
Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits Pizza • $
1198 Gruene Rd, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Inferno's Scorpion Pepper Pizza
Pizza Chips and Marinara Sauce
Spaghetti Meatballs Marinara
Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza
Chorizo Stuffed Jalapenos
Cesar and Dinner Salads
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Classic Caesar Salad
Mediterranean Pizza

“Was so hopeful, but the pizza was disappointing. My carry out oder of "The Big One" was a disaster. I wish I could have attached a photo. The pizza did not look anything like the photo. Crust was flat and without rise. No red onions present, kalamata olives were replaced with canned black olives, and is that fresh basil on the pizza in the photo? Unfortunate and very regretable.“

4.2 Good198 Reviews
DoubleDave's Pizzaworks Pizza • $
2164 Gabriels Pl #105, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak Stromboli
Doubledave's Peproni Rolls
Garlic Spinach Stromboli
Cheese Breadsticks
Boneless Hot Wings
Choose Your Crust
Pepperoni Pizza
Hamburger Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Pizza Rolls

“Never been until today! Loved it. Great atmosphere, & the pizza rolls the girls recommended were SO freakin good! 👌🏼“

4.3 Superb88 Reviews
MOD Pizza Pizza • $
272 FM306 Suite 106, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Mad Dog with Jalapenos
Create Your Own Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
No Name Cake
Pesto Drizzle
Caesar Salad
Greek Salad
Pizza Salad
Meat Lovers

“I just wanted to say we had an amazing experience today. We came in and it was extremely busy. There was a customer in front of us with entitlement demands. She was being very unreasonable with her demands. I would have honestly been fired if I had to deal with the customer. Your employee Katie and her crew just smiled and did everything they could to please her. I was really impressed with the crew and how the remained cool, respectful, and didn’t let that effect the vibe. I know most the time people are real quick to let you know when something is wrong, but never take the time to say when something is right. Katie and the crew were right and spot on. You have an amazing crew. Continue doing what you all do, its noticed and have made me and my family loyal customers.“

4.2 Good79 Reviews
Guadalupe Brewing Company & Pizza Kitchen Brewery • $
1586 Wald Rd, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Canadian Bacon Olives Half Pepperoni Half Sausage
Detroit 1586 Pepperoni Pizza
Detroit Style Cheese Pizza
Beer Flight of Stouts
Turkey Club Sandwich
Detroit Style Pizza
French Toast Stout
Charcuterie Board
Fried Pickles
Cheeseburger

“Amazing pizza, tried both the New York and Detroit style. Both styles were delicious and cooked to perfection. Also tried a order of the fresh cut fries, delicious!!
We ordered take out this time so we didn't get to enjoy the live music, definitely plan on going back when we can stay awhile.“

4.7 Superb166 Reviews
Stout's Pizza Co. Pizza • $
1850 TX-46 Suite 101, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Texas Pepperoni Pizza
The Original Calzone
Chicken Bacon Ranch
The Stout Special
Gluten Free Crust
Pepperoni Rolls
Pineapple Pizza
Avocado Salad
Ceasar Salad
Cheesy Bread

“grear ceasar salad, bread sticks were great, pepperoni pizza was great, cheese again great, chicken bbq was definitely the best I've ever had. thank you very much!!“

4.2 Good74 Reviews
Calahan's Pub and Pizza Pizza • $
194 W San Antonio St, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Discounted with Every Pizza Purchase
French Dip Sandwich
Large Beef Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Wings
Butcher Block
Cheese Sticks
The Guadalupe
Kitchen Sink
Greek Salad

“My Fiance and I have been coming here a couple times a week for the past few weeks. The food is spectacular and the service is great. We had a food quality issue last night, which was quickly resolved by Elissa. She is very attentive and we appreciated her help! Definitely coming back for more meat rolls!“

4.1 Good111 Reviews
Bella Sera New Braunfels Pizza • $
259 TX-337 Loop, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs with Meat Sauce
House Salad with Caesar Dressing
Dinner Rolls Included for All
Strawberry Cheesecake
Homemade Garlic Rolls
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Calabrense
Meat Lovers Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Marsala

“Kid-friendliness: We ate here with our one year old daughter and they had a GREAT selection of food on the kids menu for a good price. Overall we it was a perfect way to end the day with an amazing small dinner with family and friends after her big birthday party.“

3.9 Good176 Reviews
Bosses Pizza, Wings & Burgers New Braunfels Pizza • $
263 TX-337 Loop, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Wings Bone in or Out & Drink
Pizza 4 Toppings & Drink
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Philly Cheese Steak
Bacon Cheeseburger
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Wings
Cheese Bread
Bosses Fries
Patato Wedges

“The customer service provided to us by Frank was absolutely amazing. I appreciated his kindness and smile. The food is absolutely out of this world. The best Buffalo chicken salad EVER***!!! The pizza was so tasty and the onion rings...oh my...delicious. We will be back for Monday cornhole for sure“

3.9 Good148 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
2204 TX-46, New Braunfels

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Lucy Cooper's Ice House Bar • $
1515 Kuehler Ave, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Boodreaux's Clotheline Bacon & Chicken Fried Deviled Eggs
New Orleans BBQ Shrimp & Low Country Shrimp Boil
Nashville South Chicken Sammich
Maskville South Chicken Sammich
Boodreanx's Clothesline Bacon
Chicken Fried Devil Eggs
Trash Can Nachos Supreme
Breaded Wings and Fries
Southern Fish N Chips
Cheeseburger Eggrolls

“Today I celebrated an early birthday get together with 12 of my friends and it was amazing! Great food and service!!“

4.4 Superb224 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
2084 Central Plaza Suite 101, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Family Italian Chef Salad with Ranch Dressing
Fiery Pepperoni Pizza
Large All Meat Pizza
Pepperoni Magnifico
All Meat Calzone
Chicken Wings
6in Ham Sub
Lasagne

“The pizza’s good, but more than that I LOVE the atmosphere. Very family friendly. Upbeat vibe. The employees and manager are all terrific. I’ve only had good experiences here.“

3.9 Good68 Reviews
Hangar 54 Pizza Pizza • $$
35830 FM3159, New Braunfels

“this review is for the new Rexburg location in Mother hibbards have stopped in there four times within the last week to try the food and they never have anything in the warmer. no pizzas nothing. I went in there tonight. no food in the warmer. the kids that work there are sitting on the floor up against the wall doing absolutely nothing. Do they only serve Pizza at lunch and zero food for dinner? there's nothing anywhere that says what times they have food what time? they don't have food so tonight I went from hangar 54 right over to Valley wide and got me a personal pizza and now I'm headed to work.“

4.7 Superb3 Reviews
Above Ground Pizza Pizza • $
311 FM306, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Sir William Creamy Garlic Mushrooms Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza and Lemonade Sangria
Sir William Creamy Garlic Mushroom Pie
Make It a Calzone with Ricotta Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Garlic Mushroom Pizza
Codie's Primal Pizza
Classic Caesar Salad
Garlic Mushroom Dip
Lunch Special Pizza

“I just heard Jimmy sold his place to the people next door and dang, you can tell. the pizza was served raw and the salad was slimy. nothing was edible and they refused to refund us seeing we didn't eat anything. $45 for a 7in and 2 half salads is ridiculous. Jimmy should take his face off the sign now and be fully unattached.“

3.8 Good113 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
316 N Business Interstate Hwy 35, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Extra Cheese Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“Anytime I order a pizza from Domino's it is always fresh and hot with plenty of toppings. The delivery people are always fast and friendly, especially Samantha! My dogs love Samantha :-)“

3.8 Good60 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
312 FM306 Ste 114, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Medium Hand-Tossed Pizza with Pepperoni and Beef with Extra Sauce and Extra Cheese
Pepperoni Pan Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Lava Cake

“When I called to place an order Mieka answered the phone. She was VERY kind and super helpful. She repeated all information back to me to make sure everything was correct. Mieka also delivered our pizza and was just as kind in person as she was on the phone! She definitely made our experience a great one! Oh and the pizza was delicious!“

3.7 Good27 Reviews
New York Pizza Pub Pizza • $
2345 TX-337 Loop, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Mushroom Sausage Slice
Southern or Grilled Chicken Salad
Pepperoni Mushrooms and Sausage
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Butcher Shop Pizza
Whole Wheat Crust
Margarita Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Buffalo Tenders
Supreme Pizza

“I would recommend it because the pizza is always really good. But my goodness, the service. It’s not just those actually serving, it’s also those who order things for the restaurant. At least 50% of the time, they don’t have the gluten-free crust that they advertise. They won’t tell you that when you call an order. And when you go in and sit down and order, they don’t tell you until they have already brought out the drinks and placed the order for the entire table. If we need gluten-free crust, it’s not like we can just say oh well will do without. We can’t let one of our parties sit there and not eat anything. Best part of all? They get very irritated when you won’t pay for the drinks that you did not even drink, which they brought while telling us they don’t have gluten-free crust. Today, I called and placed the order and then ran upstairs to take a shower as we were in a time crunch, which was the reason for ordering takeout to begin with. My son went to pick up the pizza. As I was getting out of the shower, he called And said he had just gotten to the store and they did not have the gluten-free crust. Since I was in a rush, I said to just go ahead and pick up the large pizza that we ordered and our gluten-free family member would get something else from somewhere else. Turns out they hadn’t even started the order. So none of us were able to get anything because by that time we couldn’t wait for them to make a pizza. Apparently, they had called to tell me they were out of gluten-free crust while I was in the shower. Why they couldn’t have said it when I was placing the order, we’ll never know. Anytime I go eat anywhere else, if they are out of something, the waiters always know and apologize that it is not available. Not here. No one ever knows until they go back to the kitchen and specifically ask. Bottom line? Great pizza, terrible, terrible management and service.“

3.7 Good206 Reviews

You May Also Like