50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Selma

“I was excited to learn about this place from my son, as we've not found a truly remarkable pizza in San Antonio. We loved Ms Ellies, but since it closed, nothing else has checked all the right buttons on our pizza meter. The crust was phenomenal....thin base, bubbled up charred edges, slight crisp on the surface giving way to the perfect chew. The sauce...perfect in its simplicity...just tomatoes and not much else, if anything....perfect amount of cheese (light) so it doesn't weigh down the pie. Fresh basil. Sopressata. It's a walk-up window, and some small seating areas outside... no dine-in option at present. I can't hold that against them. It's just where they are in their Journey so far. But I do look forward to the time that they have a dine-in area and wine to enjoy with their fabulous pizza.“

“Clean. Great staff is always an asset. The characters are good bout mingling with he kids.“

“Food is absolutely amazing, 10/10.
two issues i have is one it feels icky inside, I know its cleaned but idk maybe musty? Second is having one door locked feels pretty uninviting maybe even illegal? Idk the fire codes confused me. anywho, I applaud your employees, They do an amazing job and they look like they have fun while doing it. Definitely will come back“

“Loved MAARS Pizza. if you are a pizza lover this place is recommended for you. The pizza they serve here is big and delicious. 4 stars.“

“Best pizza in New Braunfels. The supreme pizza was indeed supreme and their pepperoni pizza rolls are the best I have ever had. I called in an order and it was delivered hot and fresh within 25 minutes. Courteous staff. Will be going back for more!“

“First time visiting. Ordered to go since I was on my way to work. I got the Italian sandwhich and a house salad with jalapeno ranch dressing. The sandwhich was big!! And so flavorful. The restaurant has a cute lil area outside to side and for kids to play. Will definitely be back to try more things.“

“Pizza ingredients were fresh and very tasty. Crust was perfect.
Definitely worth the try. 😁👍

Wife had the lemon pepper hot wings. They were jumbo size and very tasty. 👍
Only negative comment, establishment had no public restrooms.“

“1st time here & it will not be our last time. This place was amazing the staff here are very friendly and welcoming. Danny took our order and would come by to check on us. the other staff did as well helpful to our needs. They have spicy peach wings totally game changer and so far the best wings I have ever had. If your in the area stop by and give them a try, you will not be disappointed.“

“We love parry’s in Cibolo ! Christian was our waiter this time around and he was absolutely fantastic. He was still new and for being a busy Friday night the service he provided was amazing. He even made it a point to ask if we preferred our child’s lemonade watered down a bit which as a parent.. having that suggested was wonderful. The bar was behind a bit but he made sure to up date us throughout our dinner without being too over bearing. Will absolutely return.“

“Y’all!! If you haven’t been to Catalano’s Pizzeria in a while, here’s your sign to go back! I had the lemon butter spaghetti (GLUTEN FREE) with clams and scallops and let me tell you what…it’s hands down the best clam spaghetti I’ve had in my life (and I’ve had a lot of clam spaghetti at all kinds of Italian restaurants). Just amazing! Hubby had fettuccini Alfredo with chicken Parmesan and that looked delicious too:) thank you for an amazing date night dinner!! Everything was so delicious!!“

“súper rico todo, un muy buen ambiente y el personal muy amable“

“The staff is always wonderful and the food is delicious! We love coming here“

“Best Italian food in San Antonio!! It’s BYOB also right now until they get their liquor license, so you can bring your favorite wine or beer to enjoy with your meal. The pizzas are huge and the pasta is delicious.“

“Not much to the place but service was good and cooked to order. Very friendly staff. Would suggest an ice machine as drinks were not very cold. Also fountain drinks would be nice. The calzone is very good as is the sauce. If you are looking for a basic place with good service and food, give this place a try. We will be back“

“Our favorite pizza place in town! My hunny and I have been there several times, pizza always top notch as well as the wings! Customer service has always been amazing, they already know our drink order! Multiple TVs to catch your favorite team. Trivia night is always a blast! We HIGHLY recommend this place if you’re in the area 😁“

“Little Caesers Pizza In San Antonio Tx.“

“We hosted a Celebration of Life at BJ's Brewhouse, Hwy 281 N. Could not have been more satisfied with the atmosphere, service, and especially the food. There were 80 of us with the Pizza and Salad Buffet. EVERYBODY there remarked how wonderful how wonderful the pizza and service were. I've heard terms like "never had pizza this good", "the service was excellent", "wonderful place." I highly recommend this particular location for events. EXCELLENT.“

“We were welcomed into the neighborhood with a coupon for a pizza. Well defenetly be going back to eat in. I highly recommend, the pizza was amazing and not just cause it was free. The service was professional and the atmosphere was extatic. So many food options and adult drink options. The decorations really drew my attention. Over all my kid wants to go back.“

“Loved the pizza! Had a crispy crust and just the right amount of toppings and cheese. Staff was super friendly and happy. Will go back!“

“we waited awhile for our food and we were the only ones there. Plus, they have no ice for their drinks?? who does that???“

“The Cuban sandwich was amazing!“

“Amazing pizza, tried both the New York and Detroit style. Both styles were delicious and cooked to perfection. Also tried a order of the fresh cut fries, delicious!!
We ordered take out this time so we didn't get to enjoy the live music, definitely plan on going back when we can stay awhile.“

“I'm on a high protein health plan with low carb. I ordered two crustless pizza bowls: 4 toppings. I got pepperoni, sausage, spinach, jalapeños. Wow! 8 servings, high protein, excellent flavor?! Janathan helped today. 100% satisfied with his customer service. Friendly, appreciative, & calm. I'll be back!“

“I didn't realize that thin pizza meant burnt, crispy crackers with tidbits of your selection of protein. The service and delivery was so fast that they didn't have time to bake the pizzas at a nominal time frame to insure a freshly baked pie of perfection. Delivery person was awesome. but, overall I was Disappointed.“

“This place has never given me no issues , the customer service is great ! The food is always done fast & delicious . I’ve been here plenty of times for pick up orders and I’ve only ever seen one person dine in . They do not do the buffet dine in at this location , but you’re able to sit and eat your own pizza at a table . This Place is always clean & the decorations give nostalgia .“

“Best Pizza and Italian restaurant in New Braunfels, with the best service ...and now it is, sadly, closing.“

“Ribeye was amazing. Ordered it medium, but not bleeding and it came out perfect. No A1 needed to disrupt from the juicy perfection. Just dinner and drinks. Jada was great, super attentive and knowledgeable on beer choices. Ordered a drink that wasnt available and the manager Jojo made it right! Top notch customer service! Will definitely be back again! Thank you BJs for having excellent management and excellent staff! - Margarita 🌼“

“Great food! I would definitely recommend this place.“

“I've been a huge fan of Peter Piper Pizza since I was a little kid. Pizzas are delicious 💯 there. I love it. I went back in October and my experience was awesome 💯.“

“the food was awesome brought back memories of me being in italy“

“Hands down my favorite pizza. Affordable, convenient, quick, plus HEB hospitality.

The chicken bacon ranch jalapeño is my absolute go to, but their specialty pizzas that change out have also been yummy. I’ll always hype them, but I can’t be too mad that others are missing out. More for me 😋“

“First time visiting... decided to grab the spaghetti dinner, a cold sub & cheesecake (to go)! Everything was DELICIOUS!!! So grateful to have spotted this GEM! Definitely returning to a new favorite spot!“

“Fish and chips were awesome.“

“I ordered pizzas for my daughter’s birthday a week ahead of time. I then changed my order multiple times between the date I placed it and actually picked it up.... Despite all of this.... my pizzas were perfect, they had them done early... and helped me to my car! I couldnt have asked for better service! They made sure to give me any coupons that were going on too! Thanks Domino’s for making my daughter’s birthday a hit! You rock!!!“

“My husband I love to go here. It’s cozy and the waitresses are always wonderful. We always get the fettuccine Alfredo. Said last night we should try something new, but the sauce is so good. It’s our ‘go to’ place.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“I’ve come to know this store as a very reliable fall back on rough days after work. Two years of ordering, and not all of them on bad days but definitely always on a bad day - And the people here are consistent each and every time, I’ve never seen them miss.

It’s a comfort, knowing no matter how wrong things can go in a day, I can at least end it safely with the effort they put into the work they do and service they provide. Yeah, maybe it’s just a pizza, but it’s a pizza I know is gonna be good, I can count on it being the one good thing to come out of a day of bad things.

What happens when after a bad day, there’s a disappointing delivery out of all the other times they’ve done great? I forgive, because I get that things get rough, and I know how it feels not to get everything right every time. It’s incredibly human, and I appreciate the staff here for showing up everyday and making this bit of peace for me, and others.“

“This establishment has the best of both worlds. You have a bar for regular customers and an ultra lounge for special events. Both accessible and beautiful with a menu that's easy or fine dining optional. Definitely a spot you want to visit for date night, bachelor parties, birthday parties, company events or private events.“

“We absolutely love the manager and deliver drivers but almost every time we order the pasta we get about 10 bites out of it. We know it's not going to be completely full but for $5.99 we should get it at least hallway full. Please please fix this problem. Thank you, Jennie“

“Such a friendly location with great staff! I ordered delivery and got my pizza but part of the order was wrong. I called an spoke with Kyle. He was apologetic and offered solutions to make it right. I am close to the store and volunteered to run up and get the right one. Kyle offered to remake the order since it might not be hot. I declined as it hadn't been long. When I came up, he had indeed made me a new hot pizza. Mistakes happen and its about how we handle them I will certainly be patronizing this location again“

“They forgot to slice one of our pizzas 🍕“

“Thank you so much for your donation of 6 pizzas to the Samuel Clemens varsity football team weekly Feed the Herd Team dinner. They enjoyed every slice!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Food was ok. It seemed super greasy compared to other locations. It was fresh and the taste was great minus the extra grease. The girl who worked there had braces and was hard to understand, when I asked her to repeat what she said, she seemed annoyed. Otherwise, it was good enough to get 4/5 stars.“

“Yall. I’ve been seeing some bad reviews; but let me share my experience.
I come to little Cesar’s pretty often. Say once a week or once every couple of weeks. I call ahead or order online, and then go get my pizza. There’s only been a handful of times it wasn’t ready.
The pizza. This store has literally the best pizza. Perfect dough, crispy, but soft. Cheese bread is always soft and warm. We come for new braunfels just to get it because it’s perfectly made everytime. Out of the 4738 times I’ve been there in the last two years, never been disappointed. Well, except once, but that was DoorDash being idiots.
All in all, it’s a great place and while I’ve never had a problem; you can’t judge a store by a few bad moments.“

“Awesome pizza, and the service was very nice. Kind of out of the way. But the pizza was worth it. Definitely give this place props, we try a lot of pizza places and this was in the top 5. I had wings and they were excellent. Thanks Marco's for the best first time experience, I will definitely be back.“

“First time to ever try it tonight and I admit, we were a little skeptical but it was very good pizza and bread sticks and the service was great! We will definitely be ordering from there again.“

“Love the sandwich I ate with the tomato basil soup on the side.“

“We had pizza, wings and pasta delivered. They were very quick and the delivery man was friendly. The pasta was very dry and hard. Not the best Pizza Hut pasta. I have tried at many locations. The pizza and wings were good. We would order again but stay away from pasta. This is disappointing because we don t always want pizza.“