Restaurants in Chincoteague

“My husband and I went to eat here for the first time for our Anniversary last night, the food and service was absolutely amazing, we will be back very very soon. Thankyou for making our 9 year wedding Anniversary a special and memorable experience. ❤”

“Great food! Great service! Awesome experience! We will be back soon!”

“5 stars and then some- the food is absolutely delicious and this is one of the few places I feel safe eating on the island. I have a severe shellfish allergy- including having issues with cross contamination. Better is able to accommodate for my allergy and is always quick to answer any questions I have about which foods are safe for me, packs my meal separately from any shellfish, etc. I highly recommend trying them- you won’t be disappointed!!!”

“A dog you can enjoy on Assateague Beach! Hot dog and sausage are both very good!”

“Great pizza. Delicious dough, crispy crust, and stretchy mozzarella all at a great price. Service was fast, and the staff behind the counter are welcoming and kind.”

“We went for NYE and it was incredible! Our new island favorite. Thank you Blackfin for the delicious meals and wonderful hospitality!”

“All of the food is great And drinks. Very nice employees🦀🦐🐟🍻”

“I love the tea from here its the best on the island!”

“I loved ALL that this place had to offer! The people, the music, the atmosphere, and the food. The cauliflower bites were the best we have ever had and the crushes are amazing!!! We just LOVE ChincoTiki!!!!”

“I love the tea from here its the best on the island!”

“Our family spent the day with our baseball team at the park and enjoyed some beverages at Keko's bar. The staff was very attentive and quick to serve us. I mistakenly left my card at the bar and Neilly over delivered by mailing my card back to me on her day off. THANK YOU SO MUCH!! I highly recommend the drinks, atmosphere, and most definitely the people/staff at Keko's and Maui Jack's.”

“We spent the weekend in Chincoteague for our 65th anniversary. On Saturday we ate lunch and dinner at Bill's. My husband had oysters for lunch and flounder for dinner and was pleased with both selections. I had shrimp for lunch and the fried seafood platter for dinner. They shrimp for both meals were very small and did not have a lot of taste. The clam chowder that was included with my dinner was delicious. The rest of the seafood was average. For sides we had the Granny Smith apple cold slaw and red mashed potatoes with cheddar and hamhocks. Both were absolutely scrumptious. Our cocktails were great, as was the service! We made reservations for dinner. The restaurant filled up quickly but there seemed to be adequate staff. All the staff we encountered were very friendly. We would go back again.”

“Hands down my favorite place for coffee and a breakfast sandwich. I recommend the sourdough bread. The staff is so kind and so pleasant to chat with.”

“This place is now a must go-to every year we come down. I’m only sad that for so many years we never tried it. It is by far our favorite and worth every dollar and ever bite!”

“A local Chincoteague favorite. Excellent specials - usually non-seafood American classics like fried chicken, prime rib, and beef dumplings at an unbeatable price and quality. Classic-style buffalo wings, daily vegetable rotation, and excellent fries. Plentiful dining hall seating, great for parties 1-14. Bar seating with full food service as well. Standard menu has plentiful seafood options. Tip: large parking lot behind the building. You can go next door to Island Creamery after your meal for fantastic ice cream.”

“We never leave our vacation without a visit (or two) here. Everything is delicious! 10/10”

“This is an absolute must stop for coffee or matcha! Was in town visiting and decided to stop by. Gained a customer every time we visit the island. Friendly staff. Clean establishment. And the best Matcha I’ve ever had in my life! Can’t wait to get another cup on the next visit!”

“Mr Whippy’s made me two 1/2 sheet cakes for my wedding . They were absolutely delicious. They were so sweet and accommodating too. Highly recommended”

“12/25/25 We were in town for vacation, and it was open on Christmas day. We got Tofu Vegetables, General Tso Tofu, and Veg Lo Mein, as well as the Sweet Potato Sushi! They seem to understand what vegan is, and everything tasted vegan. Definitely not healthy food but certainly yummy! In a town with limited options, I recommend this restaurant!”

“We had a wonderful dinner for our anniversary very good service and friendly will come again”

“The staff were really great! Unfortunately, the fried pickles didn’t agree with my stomach. However, the hamburger and fries were very tasty. I would definitely come back next time I’m in the area!”