14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Gainesville

“Amazing every time we go!!! Yum yum yum!“

“I was out in Gainesville for a surgery and research pizzas to bring home to Manassas and decided to try Manhattan Pizza because of all the positive reviews I'm so glad that I did. It was the best pizza that I've had in a very long time we will be traveling back that way next time we want pizza and to try their Gyros and subs. They were so friendly when I picked up my pizza it was just a very positive experience I appreciate that they take pride in their pizzas.“

“We tried this place for the first time and it quickly earned a spot on our favorites list. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel welcome. Our waitress, Farrah, was fantastic--she was warm, attentive, and had just the right mix of professionalism and friendliness that really stood out.

The food came out surprisingly fast, which was impressive given how fresh and hot everything was. We started with the cheesy bacon fries and paired them with the BBQ ranch (that's what I call it), and it was an absolute game-changer--rich, flavorful, and something we'll definitely be ordering again. Every bite tasted like it was made to order, not rushed or thrown together.

The atmosphere was just as enjoyable as the food. The restaurant had plenty of seating, so it never felt cramped, and everything was spotless and well-kept. What stood out most was the sense of community--many of the staff seemed to know the customers by name, creating a warm, welcoming vibe that made the place feel more like a neighborhood gathering spot than just another restaurant.

Between the top-notch service, delicious food, and how quickly everything was served, this place checks all the boxes. We'll absolutely be back to try more of the entrees on the menu.“

“We waited 15 years passing by this pizzeria - tried it tonight - and WOW!!!!! This pizza was phenomenal!!! Everything from the cheese, to the crust…. We will be recurring customers! Best pizza hands down!! Don’t miss out on 15 years like we did!“

“I recently had the pleasure of visiting the Pizza Boli's location in Lancaster, PA, and I must say, it exceeded all my expectations! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by their friendly staff, who went above and beyond to ensure I had a great experience. The customer service was top-notch!

The menu features an incredible variety of delicious options, and I was thrilled to see that the Gainesville location offers the same amazing menu. The quality of the food is outstanding — every bite of my pizza was bursting with flavor, and you can tell they use the freshest ingredients. Plus, they have a fantastic selection of beverages to complement your meal.

Whether you're in Lancaster or Gainesville, Pizza Boli's delivers the same incredible experience. I highly recommend both locations for anyone looking for great pizza and superb service. I can't wait to come back for more! 🍕✨“

“Hands down my favorite grocery store. I’m so glad I have one so close! I can’t imagine doing my shopping anywhere else!“

“went here on prom night with the gang. my boy austin was the best waiter i’ve had in a while! he even took some tuff flicks of us in our prom fits. he even helped wingman for a friend who eventually rizzed up 😛 W AUSTIN! oh also the food was great and the pazookie was way too much sugar for me but was still gas (even tho i don’t like chocolate)“

“Yes the service slow but its a small family restaurant so you have take that into account. Maybe they should hire more but i am not sure if they get enough traffic to afford it. The food is good though. Its worth the wait. The subs are piled with a ton of meat and the pizza was good.“

“We had a very wonderful experience at Olive Pizza & Grill . the food was delicious, customer service was top notch and the staff were really polite and kind, For Vegetarians also this is the good option,“

“Margaritas always nails it! Customer Service is always very very friendly. For take out they get you in and out quickly. And best of all my picky husband really liked their chicken cheesesteaks. As a Philly native he is very particular and Margaritas as I said nailed it! #newregulars“

“Ordered a stuff crust pizza? There was no cheese in that pizza in the crust at all. Nothing no juice in that crust what back next day, they fulfilled and remade it, no problem. Tasted excellent, and it was very delicious. Can't wait to stop by again“

“The Steak and Cheese Sub was very good and delivery was fast. I highly recommend this restaurant!“

“This place is beautiful and super clean. The people here are really friendly, which made the experience even better. We tried the Hawaiian pizza and it was absolutely delicious! The whole atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the prices are very reasonable. I'd definitely recommend this Ledo Pizza to my friends and family, and I'm already looking forward to coming back for more!“

“The pizza was not completely cooked through and the matter was brought to the staff who cooked it attention but he refused to put the pizzas back in the oven to cook a longer. The pizzas were already paid for and I was unable to eat it due to the uncooked dough and toppings.“