15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Gainesville

“We are ordering from our office since more 2 years, from manhattan pizza in gainesville were are located 6,miles from them we never try different location because we trust big time this place running under a great person and great manager ,he did not learn the business from here,he was born were the food has been created greece italie and mediterenian midle east ,they never late
or braught us wrong or missing items
One word only,
Thank you.Manhattan pizza Gainesville for braught us the happiness and the satisfaction when we eat each bite,
Fernando aquino 3,14 ,2025“

“Their app sucks! Constantly reloads while you’re trying to complete your order. The food is top notch but the app is awful!“

“We love Mama Mias!! The delivery is fast, and we always have a great experience dining in or delivery. The pizza is great and so is the lasagna dinner, the staff has always been pleasant, friendly! Just placed our order for delivery and as always super friendly!!“

“I love Brookly Brothers. They have the best pizza around. Whether you are eating in taking out or getting it delivered. Every time I have gone in they have always been friendly and polite. Great staff and the food come out fast and perfect every time. I have loved everything I have eaten from there. Definitely recommend going.“

“Wegman’s is one of those grocery stores that raises the standards on luxury super markets. If you think Whole Foods Markets are the best you’ve probably never been to a Wegman’s. Their selection is even better and more exotic with offerings such as giant oversized soft pretzels stuffed with real crab meat and lobster meat sans the shells. Whole Foods Markets only wishes they had the freedom to offer such items. Aside from those special custom made foods they also offer all of the best organic produce and various other nationwide organic items plus they’re not too elite to offer things like Campbell’s soups and whatnot unlike WFM. You really get the best of both worlds from the luxury grocery stores world plus they’re plebeian regular grocery store shopping all available in one store.“

“Yes the service slow but its a small family restaurant so you have take that into account. Maybe they should hire more but i am not sure if they get enough traffic to afford it. The food is good though. Its worth the wait. The subs are piled with a ton of meat and the pizza was good.“

“Bro. They are the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Cheese is good. Meatsters is also really good (keep in mind that not everything on meatsters is halal but you can tell them to make everything halal) and also fajita. Customer service is amazing, but someone else is gonna talk about that in detail.

Vegetarian options: There is options with no meat

Dietary restrictions: It’s halal (except for some things)

Kid-friendliness: I mean their cheese pizza was really good“

“Our waiter, Christopher, was awesome! We were seated in a section without any wait staff and after about 15 minutes or so, I asked for someone and he very kindly chose to be our waiter. It did a fabulous job and went above and beyond with their service!“

“We had a very wonderful experience at Olive Pizza & Grill . the food was delicious, customer service was top notch and the staff were really polite and kind, For Vegetarians also this is the good option,“

“Margaritas always nails it! Customer Service is always very very friendly. For take out they get you in and out quickly. And best of all my picky husband really liked their chicken cheesesteaks. As a Philly native he is very particular and Margaritas as I said nailed it! #newregulars“

“Ordered a stuff crust pizza? There was no cheese in that pizza in the crust at all. Nothing no juice in that crust what back next day, they fulfilled and remade it, no problem. Tasted excellent, and it was very delicious. Can't wait to stop by again“

“The Steak and Cheese Sub was very good and delivery was fast. I highly recommend this restaurant!“

“Cheesy and saucy pizza and friendly staff. EVERYTIME i go here the pizza is always a hit. They are usually busy inside especially on Fridays. which can be understood for having to wait longer as some reviews mentioned. Talked to staff and owner a couple times and he seems to be heavily involved in the business and management. A knowledgeable man who can talk about the craft of how the pizza is made/ ingredients. Definitely a place to stop by if you’re in the area. The desserts are always a plus ?“

“I had an amazing experience at Papa John's, all thanks to Conner! He's one of the friendliest and most efficient team members I've come across. His attention to detail and dedication to making sure my order was perfect really stood out. You can tell he genuinely cares about the customers and the quality of his work. Thank you, Conner, for making my experience so enjoyable. I'll definitely be coming back!

Vegetarian options: cheese pizza and deserts.

Parking: lots“

“The pizza was not completely cooked through and the matter was brought to the staff who cooked it attention but he refused to put the pizzas back in the oven to cook a longer. The pizzas were already paid for and I was unable to eat it due to the uncooked dough and toppings.“