25 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middletown

“Made a random stop on our drive from North Carolina to Ohio. The food was excellent, but we were inpressed with the customer service. Every single employee was friendly and helpful. We would have stopped to enjoy a drink, but were anxious to get back on the road. All around a positive experience!“

“I have been to Claudios often lately. The staff are so kind and on the ball. Clearly they are treated well. And it shows in their personalities. It's clean! Bathrooms clean!! Love! The food is delish! I've had the pizza, Stromboli, subs, eggplant parm. (It was little bites of heaven) I've loved it!! And they are reasonably priced!! And absolutely local favorite!!! Thank you Claudios! ?“

“Didn’t expect to find such great pizza when our truck broke down in the middle of who knows where. The kindest waitress and a fantastic pizza.“

“I was looking for a pizza place to take my daughters and niece, since we're from out of town, and I'm glad I picked Fox's today. The staff was extremely friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere was pleasant. We got a pepperoni pizza, mozarella sticks, and bacon cheese fries, and all tasted great. We will definitely return if we're ever looking for pizza in Strasburg again.

Kid-friendliness: It was very kid-friendly.

Parking: Parking was easy with plenty of spaces.“

“Here’s a review for a hip pizza joint with great food and I recently ate melting pot pizza and wow, what a gem! This place nails it with a killer combo of vibe, food, and location. Tucked into a buzzing spot downtown, it’s got that effortlessly cool, urban feel—It’s the kind of joint where you can roll up with friends or even solo and feel right at home. The pizza? Insanely good. The crust strikes that perfect balance—crisp on the outside, chewy inside—and Pair it with a craft beer from their rotating taps, and you’re set. Location-wise, it’s a total win. Smack in the heart of front royal Service was chill but on point—staff were friendly without hovering. Prices are fair for the quality, though it’s not the cheapest slice in town (worth it, though). If you’re into hip spots with legit food“

“I was looking for a place to make pumpkin shaped pizzas for my Halloween party. I’d called several places and no one was willing- then I called them, and they said they’d never done it but were willing to try! So they not only did the pumpkin shapes, but they also made little faces on the pizzas. My guests were so excited for how cute they were. The pizzas themselves were also delicious! I especially love the fig and caramelized onion pizza, very gourmet! I totally recommend this place, delicious pizzas and helpful staff!“

“After moving to the area about 4 years ago from NoVa, I have to say that not only is the food excellent and freshly made to order but Frank and the rest of the staff go above and beyond when it comes to customer service and special requests! This can also be said for most of the small businesses in town! Thanks for everything you guys do! You have a customer for life!“

“Absolutely awesome! Great food, drinks and the band we just saw, The Charlee Allman band was so incredible! I definitely recommend this place to have a great time!“

“Excellent pizza. Can’t wait to try other menu items!!“

“We had the Madeira Chicken with veggies and Caesar Salad as we eat Keto. The service was excellent and the food was divine!“

“After a long day in the road, having delivery to a local hotel is awesome. Called and spoke to Tommy to place my order. He is fantastic!! He was so funny and personable. He had such a great disposition and was an absolute joy to speak with. Give that boy a raise and keep up the good work Tommy.!!“

“Absolutely delicious and kind service!“

“The food is Always yummy!“

“Seniors of Shenandoah Valley had their monthly luncheon here. The service was excellent thanks to Natasha. So glad that they added the extra room that accommodated all 17 of us. There was plenty to be able to take home for an additional meal or two.“

“We had fun here, pizza was good and lots of games. My only complaints were they didn't check our stamps when we left and I saw lots of people leaving without having them checked. I thought the stamps were for the safety of the kids. My other complaint was that my kids wanted cotton candy for part of the prizes they got, and when we got home, we went to open cotton candy bags, and the cotton candy looked so gross. Looked like lines of brown through it and like peddles in the bottom of the bag. I threw all the cotton candy away. I didn't trust how gross it looked. We usually love Chuck E. Cheese, those things were just a little off for us. I'm sure we will give it another shot in the future, so hopefully, some of these things improve. 🤞“

“Friday I placed an order online for 2 pepperoni pizza's, I had a special request but didn't see where to enter it when I placed my order. So I called when the store opened and made my request. The pizza was for a going away lunch so I was anxious for the order to be correct and it was Better than correct. I asked for the pepperonis to be in a heart shape on the pizza's and they made the pizza's into hearts!! It was perfect! Absolutely perfect! Huge shout out to Stephen's city Papa John's!! You helped make the lunch perfect!“

“I am originally from the Bronx and this is the closest to NY pizza that I have had since I have moved here in the 80's!!!! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!!!!!!! The orange oil dripped on my paper plate when I folded my slice....SOOO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“Best pizza ever 😍 I eat here all the time because I work at the mall!“

“Good food and they were happy to make us crustless pizza bowls and bunless cheese steaks to meet our dietary requirements, both of which were delicious! This place is locally owned and you can tell they take pride in their restaurant and the food they serve. Service has been terrific every visit. We're definitely becoming regulars at this tasty establishment!

Dietary restrictions: They were happy to accommodate dietary restrictions. They went above and beyond to make low carb gluten free options for us!

Parking: Adequate parking, on street out front and there's a parking lot in the back too.“

“This Domino’s location has some good employees that make great pizza. I have been to many other locations that were not up to par. Tonight they were slammed with orders and my pizza was behind schedule so I got rewarded a free pizza through the app. It was an amazing pizza as usual and I almost feel bad that I was given a free pizza, as I hope it doesn’t reflect badly on this location. Despite being extremely busy the staff is very friendly and makes quality pizza that they care about. I hope nothing ever changes about this location.“

“I've never been to the Front Royal Location. The ice machine was down and they were a little busy, but man Josh just made my day. He was efficient, quick, and made me some pretty amazing food. Totally would go again..... great customer service and delicious food.“

“I must give credit where credit is due. I ordered a large cheese stuffed crust pizza and my husband picked it up. They were very pleasant but the best part was the pizza it was HOT, FRESH and DELICIOUS � My family was very pleased. We will definitely be ordering from there again soon. Keep up the great work. You guys ROCK.“

“I came across this place while on my lunch break from my firearm training classes nearby. I was feeling hungry but didn't wanna spend too much, so I did the two slice and drink combo with a salad.

The service was good, and the food was delicious. My only suggestion that they might want to do a unique and different under $10.00 combo for each day of the week. Doing so might attract more customers, especially if the combo for that day appeals to them.“

“Cicis pizza was awesome when it was in the Target plaza in University Town Center, Morgantown! Disappointed when they closed that location!

The only reason I’m writing this is because Google won’t stop bugging me to write about it!“

“Love the chipotle chicken pizza! The wings and cinnamon pie were great too! The staff is always friendly!“