27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middletown

“We were spending the night in Middletown and decided to The Italian Touch. It was delicious. I can't say it was the best I've ever had, but it was close.
I had the baked ziti, which is Plenty for two people. It came with a nice side salad and knot rolls that were so so good.
My husband got the lasagna and he said it was also good.
If we are ever back this way, I'd stop in again.“

“Didn’t expect to find such great pizza when our truck broke down in the middle of who knows where. The kindest waitress and a fantastic pizza.“

“My daughter brought me a cheese steak to my home in Alexandria and I was like OMG this is awesome.....she told me it was a place in Winchester called Claudio's, well I told her that it is worth a trip for me to travel for such an awesome cheese steak and this was a 2 hr old one at that!! I made the trip this past Sunday with my grandson and stopped into Claudio's, the food, cheesesteak's awesome, onion rings were crispy and flavorful, service was kind, friendly and helpful. The manager on duty was awesome, I told him I traveled from Alexandria just to dine at the Pizzeria and he made sure that we enjoyed are visit! Thank you Claudio's and we will be sure to visit again very soon.“

“This is one of our usual stops whenever we are in town. My usual go to is the pizzaroni wedgie. This time I added lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and mayo. It was a very messy sandwich but also very delicious!

We placed our order over the phone and it was ready for pickup within 10-15 mins. Overall they are pretty consistent!“

“Quickly delivered an amazing pizza to the Marriott. Would recommend trying if you are in the area.“

“I grew up in Front Royal enjoying Melting Pot as a kid. Even though I no longer live there I enjoy their pizza any chance I get. Best pizza ever 🍕 😋❤️“

“Thanks for the pizzas. Everyone enjoyed the tasty lunch.“

“After a long day in the road, having delivery to a local hotel is awesome. Called and spoke to Tommy to place my order. He is fantastic!! He was so funny and personable. He had such a great disposition and was an absolute joy to speak with. Give that boy a raise and keep up the good work Tommy.!!“

“Most negative reviews seem to be about not the pizza here. Their pizza is NY/NJ Style excellence--thin, floppy, greasy, and delicious. That other popular, successful local place has a nicer eat-in atmosphere, but the pizza at Kings is head and shoulders better than any I've had in the state.“

“Outstanding service and food.“

“After moving to the area about 4 years ago from NoVa, I have to say that not only is the food excellent and freshly made to order but Frank and the rest of the staff go above and beyond when it comes to customer service and special requests! This can also be said for most of the small businesses in town! Thanks for everything you guys do! You have a customer for life!“

“Rica comida italiana a buen precio , porciones , grandes y un buen servicio al cliente …. Quede encantada de este lugar“

“Absolutely awesome! Great food, drinks and the band we just saw, The Charlee Allman band was so incredible! I definitely recommend this place to have a great time!“

“My kids and I go to a lot of different Chuck E Cheese locations, this location is by far my favorite just because of the customer service.
Every employee is always so nice and helpful! It is also one of the cleanest locations, especially the bathrooms.“

“It’s always so nice having a meal at Ledo’s. The staff and owner are always so nice and personable and the food is so good. Pizza, a salad and a diet Dr Pepper for me usually but I can’t wait to try the wings! I’ve heard they’re really good!!“

“We ordered pickup yesterday 9/23/25. At the time of our arrival the counter person at Point of sale was knee deep in phone calls as well as several walk-ins, including us. The gentleman was new, which we found out later, but he accidentally messed up our order. So we waited an extra 10 mins or so to get the correct pizza and onion rings. Both of which were given at no extra cost and we got three free small pizza coupons for the wait as well. We showed grace in our additional wait time and never expressed frustration, but the business still went above and beyond to ensure our happiness. Exceptional customer service and hospitality. Kudos to Fox Pizza and the Owners/ Staff. Great establishment!“

“I had the chicken orto and my son had the tortellini Alfredo—both were absolutely delicious and full of flavor. The adult portions are generous, so there was plenty to share and even some leftovers. Definitely a great spot if you’re craving hearty pasta.“

“I must give credit where credit is due. I ordered a large cheese stuffed crust pizza and my husband picked it up. They were very pleasant but the best part was the pizza it was HOT, FRESH and DELICIOUS � My family was very pleased. We will definitely be ordering from there again soon. Keep up the great work. You guys ROCK.“

“Friday I placed an order online for 2 pepperoni pizza's, I had a special request but didn't see where to enter it when I placed my order. So I called when the store opened and made my request. The pizza was for a going away lunch so I was anxious for the order to be correct and it was Better than correct. I asked for the pepperonis to be in a heart shape on the pizza's and they made the pizza's into hearts!! It was perfect! Absolutely perfect! Huge shout out to Stephen's city Papa John's!! You helped make the lunch perfect!“

“The best and yummiest cookies in town! 🍪“

“steak and cheese sub was a top 3 ever for me.“

“The food is excellent, everything on the menu is just wonderful. The music from the ceiling speakers could be turned DOWN a good bit.“

“Cicis pizza was awesome when it was in the Target plaza in University Town Center, Morgantown! Disappointed when they closed that location!

The only reason I’m writing this is because Google won’t stop bugging me to write about it!“

“I never had a bad experience with this location. Last order was through Uber Eats and the driver never picked up half my order. After a very brief call to Lincoln at the store it was rectified right away and I could not ask for a better manager to deal with the situation.“

“This Domino’s location has some good employees that make great pizza. I have been to many other locations that were not up to par. Tonight they were slammed with orders and my pizza was behind schedule so I got rewarded a free pizza through the app. It was an amazing pizza as usual and I almost feel bad that I was given a free pizza, as I hope it doesn’t reflect badly on this location. Despite being extremely busy the staff is very friendly and makes quality pizza that they care about. I hope nothing ever changes about this location.“

“If you haven’t made a visit to PizzaTwist you are missing out on delicious pizza!!! Very clean, friendly and DELICIOUS“

“We were part of a large party for dinner on a Saturday night. The table we reserved was ready when we arrived. The waitress did a great job keeping up with all the orders and keeping tracking of who was with who for the check.
Lots of food options and reseasonable prices.“