13 Best Pizza Restaurants near The Plains

“This is such a sweet place with people who clearly love to cook and be adventurous with their menu. I had the chicken salad tacos and I loved the watermelon radishes instead of a taco shell. The flavors were outstanding and the outdoor seating was beautiful. The prices are reasonable and the options are plenty! I fed myself and my kids and got drinks plus a tip for $60. There isn't a road sign on Main Street that I saw, but the GPS gets you there easily. Definitely check it out! We'll be coming back ☺️☺️“

“Best french toast I've ever had! ?The only caveat is that I added a lot of the fruit that was a side, inside in between the layers ???? (strawberries and blueberries) great job with the nuts... also amazing steak and egg sandwich!!! The cilantro jalapeño aoli is bomb af, and you get it on a CROISSANT... Latte was smooth and barely sweet, with honey available to add at your leisure. I just wish they had more locations, more obvious signage, and more space inside. Quite the hidden jewel ?“

“Amazing, the people here are amazing and so nice here. I really recommend this place with their amazing meat pizza. Not only that they actually do their pizza fresh. Thus, I recommend this amazing pizza place for any pizza lovers here in Virginia!“

“I grew up on Spitoney’s and am pushing 48 now. It is the slice I judge all others against. Sausage mushroom and pepperoni is my go to pie. And the cheeseburger sub with grilled onions is always on point. Nothing fancy, but always great food and service and it feels like home. When did you last walk into place and find the owner working the flat top or the register? Bill and family are good people.“

“This place is a hidden gem. My husband and I originally planned to go for a late breakfast at eggexpectations when we pulled up and saw that they were no longer in business and had closed! What’s up with that? This place was always busy every time we went. So being somewhat new to the area, I did a search for restaurants near me. Brooklyn Brothers showed up right next-door and they had good reviews. So we said , why not?We went in and a pretty young lady greeted us and sat us at a booth. We were the only ones there, but it was after the lunchtime rush would’ve been. We were promptly served drinks but it took us a while to decide what we wanted to order because there were so many things on the menu that sounded really good. We ended up ordering their signature, Brooklyn Brothers pizza to share, and my husband ordered a regular salad and I ordered a modified house salad(added feta and olives, sort of like a Greek salad). The salad greens were fresh and it included roasted peppers, fresh red onions and cucumbers and cheese. It was a very nice sized helping. When the pizza came, my husband and I looked at each other - if it tasted half as good as it looked, we would be happy. Well, I have got to tell you, it is some of the best crust I have had in years, and I am Italian! Plenty of meat toppings and nice and cheesy. My husband commented that it’s one of the best pizzas he has ever had in his life and he is 66 years old… Lol We couldn’t believe we had lived in the area almost 7 years and had never come to this place. We asked how long they had been in the area, 16 years!Anyway, sorry for the long review. The food selection is numerous, the prices were fair, the atmosphere is nice and clean, and the staff was attentive . I can tell you now it will become one of our regular places to eat.“

“DELICIOUS! We've ordered twice from Valentinos for our office meetings. The doctor, myself and the other employees love this place.Must try: the garlic knots, chicken parm, tortellini.The tomato sauce used on the chicken parm and spaghetti is so good! Dr. Fredrick stated that it tasted homemade and reminds her of the food she had while visiting Italy. We will order from them again.“

“Great pizza! We picked up a great rose as well, the woman at the counter was super helpful. The pizza was done within 15 minutes and she gave us a chilled bottle. The store is laid out well, I love the simplicity of the whole process. I felt like I could pick out almost anything and it would be a hit.“

“I conveniently timed my feedstore run with lunch. The crust and the marinara are the make or break for a pizza, calzone, Stromboli. Good Fellas Warrenton’s choice of ingredients and finesse— created a perfect combination of flavor and texture. Portions are enough to share, though I was grateful I didn’t have to share my dessert! Chocolate Mousse Cake— mmm made me chew slower out of pleasure! I am not a chef or a baker so I may get terms wrong (I’m just a foodie)— it seemed to have like a thin layer of chocolate… like a ganache maybe, a dense cake that wasn’t heavy (how is that even possible?!) with a very light and fluffy chocolate mousse between the layers. OMG. I will be back. The menu is extensive— I recommend checking it out before hand. I saw several other meals and desserts I look forward to trying, next visit.“

“I've been coming to Tony's for about 25 years, starting out in Manassas and now in Haymarket. The food's fresh and Tony personally never misses an opportunity to greet his customers.I've never tried the entire menu, but I'm good with my staples of a couple of slices of pizza or caprese or the steak and cheese or chicken Caesar salad.Love the staff who make the place run, and it's the same folks year I and year out. A great family place and not a run of the mill chain restaurant.“

“This was my first time very visiting Giuseppe! Best experience I had in a restaurant. The food was amazing, the staff was super nice and they hustled to meet all our needs. I loved the live entertainment too. I will definitely return again. I'm mad at myself that it took me all these years to visit Giuseppe. I've lived in the area for 10 years.“

“Ledo's pizza is excellent. After many years of eating just pizza and their excellent fresh salads, I had their jumbo wings. They were excellent and really 'jumbo'. Some of the meatiest wings I've ever had with great taste. It may seem minor but their celery sticks were also excellent. They obviously have a great source for their vegetables.“

“On our way through the area and randomly stopped for pizza. Anthony's is in a little strip mall, and was very unassuming from the front. Local spot, nothing fancy but with a surprisingly extensive menu and good lunch specials. We ordered the cheesesteak and two slices...and maaaan they hit the spot! Both were amazing - truly. We were pleasantly surprised. If we lived nearby, we'd be regulars. Also, they carry Coke products so gold star just for that. ?Kid-friendliness: My kids would have enjoyed the pizza here - lots of options for kiddos.“

“Papa John's, the ultimate pizza experience that truly lives up to its reputation. "Better ingredients, better pizza" - that's not just a catchy slogan, it's a promise fulfilled with each and every bite. As a pizza enthusiast, I've tried various pizzerias, but Papa John's has consistently delivered an extraordinary dining experience.When it comes to flavor, Papa John's hits the bullseye every time. Their pizzas are "finger-licking good" - a mouthwatering blend of fresh ingredients, delectable cheese, and a crust that's "out of this world." From their classic pepperoni to their unique specialty pizzas, Papa John's offers a tantalizing range of flavors that will leave you craving more.But it's not just about the taste; Papa John's also nails it in terms of service and delivery. With their efficient team, they ensure that "fast delivery" is more than just an empty promise. I've always been impressed by the speed and professionalism of their delivery drivers, ensuring that my pizza arrives piping hot and ready to devour.When it comes to customization, Papa John's takes the crown. They truly understand the power of choice, allowing customers to tailor their pizza to their exact specifications. From the crust style to the vast selection of toppings, Papa John's ensures that "have it your way" is not just a phrase coined by the competition.In addition to their exceptional pizza, Papa John's also offers a variety of mouthwatering sides and desserts. Their "taste the joy" mantra extends beyond the pizza box, with delectable options like garlic knots, chicken wings, and decadent chocolate brownies. It's an all-encompassing experience that will leave you fully satisfied.While there may be other pizza places out there, Papa John's stands out from the crowd by consistently delivering on their promises. They truly epitomize what it means to be "the way pizza should be." So, if you're in the mood for a slice of heaven, look no further than Papa John's - a slice above the rest!“