7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Belfair

“PHENOMENAL PIZZA. My friend and I ordered a 16" with split toppings, and it tasted like a pizza dream come true. The pizza was loaded with toppings, and I could taste the quality of the ingredients in every bite, from the sauce to the sausage. I wish I lived closer because this would be one of my favorite restaurants! Next time I'm up near Belfair, this restaurant will be one of my first options!“

“I prefer the "take 'n bake" over regular pizza. We don't have any pizza delivery in our area so we have to pick it up ourselves when we go to town. It's always nicer to have hot, out of the oven pizza rather than 30 minute old pizza, no matter how well insulated a bag is.“

“It had been a long time since I had been to any West side pizza but man, what a difference it was! Very clean and almost like walking into a restaurant. Staff was very nice and flexible

Parking: The parking lot is in front of the store could be difficult during the day when the businesses around it are open because it's not a huge lot.“

“Ordered on a busy Friday night. Online ordering and phone ordering was not working so I went in person. The team was very friendly and very busy but managed to make sure we were taking care of. They even offered a customer service just your as we waited longer than expected. Top-notch crew. Top notch customer service.“

“Hubby has been wanting to try this place for months, he’s a pizza fan. We finally called in an order tonight and the woman on the phone was very friendly to take our order. Great customer service! We were impressed by the fresh ingredients, great quality of food, full of flavor, and sauces tasted like they’re made in house. Cheesy garlic bread sticks were bomb.com! So much flavor and the right amount of cheese. Huge serving of them! Marinara sauce was way better than most pizza joints. Buffalo sauce which we normally don’t like (ordered on the side for wings), was amazing and didn’t have that Tabasco vinegar spicy taste most buffalo sauces or wing sauce contains. I’m glad we got it on the side to try anyways! The cinnamon twists come in a huge order for 16in, I wasn’t expecting so much and wished we got the smaller order but they were delicious. Light and fluffy and right amount of cinnamon and sugar. My hubby is going to take their advice and try it in his coffee in the morning. And the winning dish- the Pizza! Since hubby is a pizza fan he wanted to start with a basic pepperoni with extra cheese and get a feel for it. His jaw dropped when he saw how big the slices were and instantly fell in love with this place! lol The first thing I noticed was how fresh the pizza crust looked and it’s artisan style, was even better when I tried it. The extra cheese covered over great quality pepperonis with the pizza sauce and fresh crust, it was AMAZING! He said no more Seabeck pizza after having Allyn pizza. Thank you for making your food with love and fresh ingredients, it shows in the quality and taste of the food! We will be coming back for more!“

“kept getting put on hold to place an order, tonight 11-27-2023 i was a bit irked. and 30 minutes later i was at the store to pick up my take and bake, it was not ready , however the man was all by himself moving around trying to do everything counter customers making pizzas and answering the phone and never once did he break stride and after a few minute another co worker came in and just jumped right in barley having time to put down her stuff and grab an apron, hats off to the two folks working while my inner Karen was off the hook the reality is i saw 2 folks busting there butts to produce a good dang pizza . I am impressed! thank you both!“

“I ordered a Calzone and it was amazing ! Honestly one of the best Calzones I've ever had. I think the bad reviews are most likely local crack heads who can't taste anything anways. I would highly recommend and will be returning to eat a calzone meant for two by myself again.“