50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bainbridge Island

“The pizza is great and I really like the cider they have on tap despite few draft options otherwise. We live nearby and our daughter likes the little arcade they have upstairs. Unfortunately, if you come in after 4pm without a group, it feels unwelcome to stay at the restaurant. The slices are taken off the wheel and for some weird reason there's no special combo for a slice and draft. The staff just sells whole pizzas and a lot of the floor games go unused because of the strange change of atmosphere in the evening. The staff themselves are also hit and miss. Some being friendly and others giving every nonverbal they want you to wrap up and leave.

Edit: bumping to 4. Food's great and think we got unlucky, because the owner was right about every staff member except that one guy.“

“Pizza was great! My son is gluten intolerant and the gluten free crust, (in his words) was the best he's ever had. The food was fresh and tasty, definitely going to be ordering from here again.“

“Great pizza spot with really solid flavor and quality ingredients. The crust has the perfect balance of crispy on the outside and soft inside and the sauce is rich without being overpowering. Every bite tastes fresh and well put together. This is the best pizza on Bainbridge Island.“

“We try to drop in here every time we dock in Winslow. This wood fired pizza is so wonderful with delicious toppings and excellent flavors. There were three of us in our group and we each ordered a different pizza - all delicious! We look forward to the next time!“

“The food was really good!“

“10/10 would go again! Classy venue. Excellent service and amazing food!“

“Great service. One gal running around, but she was very efficient and friendly. Spacious place. Lots of seating and patio tables, too. My sandwich was really good. Prices are slightly high but seem reasonable compared to most of the places in the area.“

“I’ve brought so many friends here and recommended it to countless people because it’s just that good—hands down the best Mediterranean restaurant in the area!

I get the beef gyro plate each time I come, and it hits every single time. Everything pairs perfectly together—it’s a flavor explosion 🤭

It’s mainly a takeout spot, but there is a small covered area where you can eat, along with a couple of benches outside. It might be a little cold right now, but it’s a decent setup once the weather warms up. I already look forward to the next time I’ll be back for it again!! 10/10 recommend!“

“We had an amazing dinner at a specialty pizza restaurant in Seattle named Sunny Hill. It’s a little hole in the wall that has the best Pizza and appetizers in Washington. If you’re ever in the area, make sure to check it out. It was so good to be with the family and finish up some details for today’s big event.“

“We are visiting for a game. Half the excitement is trying something new! What a unique and exquisite place! We will be back!“

“2 years ago due to health I became a pescatarian and look for quality vegetarian, vegan options. Of the many things I miss at the top of the list was a good pepperoni pizza. I have tried all vegetarian, vegan versions. Last night my son and daughter-in-law brought me to MOTO. I ordered the vegan pepperoni pizza. The first bite made me literally want to cry. This was the best pepperoni pizza of ANY kind I have eaten in my considerably long life! Thank you Lee, Nancy, and the entire MOTO crew! I cannot possibly provide a high enough recommendation, this is the alpha and omega of pizza!“

“I thoroughly enjoy how I can just sit down and drink a beer while waiting for the deep dish pizza that is absolutely delicious and definitely not the same like any other pizza place around Seattle. and it is now the only place where I will. an have been getting my pizza. so I definitely recommend“

“Our family Friday dinner is always Pizza. Tonight, for the first time we tried Smoking Monkey Pizza in Seattle. It's in a Magnolia neighborhood and it's definitely worth the drive from Shoreline. The Pepperoni Pizza was awesome. The crust thin and not to crisp and not too soft. The Mozzarella Cheese sticks are sensational. I was told that they are made in house. They are a rectangular shape and the only complaint is that we only ordered one order. Next time two for certain. Garlic chicken wings. Seriously. So good. Good sized and the garlic flavor is so good. Thankful that we ordered a large order! Also ordered the chicken sandwich that comes with fries. Served on a soft Hoagie roll it had great flavor. Fries were hot and crispy. House salad too and it was fresh and had great flavor. The Balsamic Dressing was really good. The service. Super friendly. The ambiance of the restaurant is really cool. If you haven't been to Smoking Monkey I highly recommend it. As do my 3 kids. 10 out of 10 Lots of variety on the menu and everything is done really well! Smoking Monkey in Seattle is now a family favorite!!! Check them out!“

“Best sausage sandwich in the world!!! And those garlic knots... YUM!“

“I went today for the first time. I tried their chicken bacon ranch sando and my friend tried their grinder sando - SO GOOD!! The atmosphere is fun and spacious, the staff was friendly & available, and the food was delicious! Will be trying this spot again!“

“Great pizza with fresh toppings! always delicious 😋“

“The manager here is completely rude to his customers and his staff. Refuses to refund or replace and item made incorrectly. Just terrible customer service. Think twice before giving your money to such a terrible person. Read many other reviews that talk about how the staff here is treated. The food is mediocre at best, but even of it was better, service matters. I'd encourage the owners to think about how they treat people and how they would like to be treated as a customer when the business was at fault. Disgusting. There were mushrooms sent to a kid with an allergy when it was clearly noted on the order to leave them off, there was a hair in the pizza. I would encourage the owner to take a class in customer service and learn to do what is right instead of being rude and snarky.“

“Hey hi ooo uh hi r go ouo I vhi hi Gus“

“Really enjoyed this pizza spot. The pizzas are customizable with great quality ingredients, and you definitely get what you pay for. My favorite was the Funghi Salsiccia with the Cascioppo's Italian sausage paired perfectly with the mushrooms, rich and flavorful without feeling too heavy. The hot honey was also surprisingly impressive, especially if you like that sweet and savory combination on pizza. Definitely a place worth coming back to for a quality pie.“

“Amazing pizza. Can’t wait to come back for more.“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“Hey hi ooo uh hi r go ouo I vhi hi Gus“

“This place is next door to us so we obviously order it pretty often. I've always gotten the pepperoni or the margarita. Today I tried something new the chicken tikka masala pizza and it was perfect. It's like eating the meal in slice.“

“This was a carry out pizza but facility was very clean and organized. Pizza was ordered online and I accidentally removed an item. I called the store and the Papa Murphy's employee was very happy to accommodate my request.
The Papa's favorite pizza didn't disappoint. Crust was crispy with the perfect amount of sauce and toppings.“

“Great place. Clean, was well staffed, courteous and quick service. Sauces were wonderful, salad crisp and chock full of veggiedswith great dressing. Meat balls and sauce, the best, Pizza looked and tasted good.definately 5 stars“

“I recommend simply to show support to my family. I'm the nephew of the owners.“

“The dessert was so yummy! 😋“

“best pizza ever! and the ranch dressing they make, heavenly!!!“

“I have mixed feelings about this place in the best way possible. I was both disappointed and pleasantly surprised.

From the outside, it looks like a beautiful restaurant with a cozy, stylish atmosphere. You walk in expecting a full dining experience, but inside it’s much more of a casual grab-and-go pizza spot. You can buy pizza by the slice, take it to go, or eat there quickly. There’s no real table service or restaurant-style experience, which was a little disappointing at first.

But here’s why I was happy too: for around $10, I got two slices of pizza, felt completely full, and the whole process was fast and easy. They simply warmed it up in the oven, and I was eating within minutes.

So if you’re looking for a luxury sit-down dinner, this is probably not the place. But if you want to stop by, grab something tasty, affordable, and satisfying, it’s honestly a great neighborhood spot.“

“Had the Best Wood fire pizza ever, who would have thought clams on dough would be so good. Recommend you give this place a try. Look forward to coming back soon. Yum!!“

“Helen and crew are the best! Always great service and the quality keeps us coming back.“

“I spent a good amount of time reading reviews and looking at photos of all the pizzerias there are here in the Silverdale/Poulsbo area and I am so delighted that I didn’t sleep on West Side Pizza!!! After speaking to gal who owns it, found out they make their own dough everyday, also make their own marinara and grate their own cheese!! This is a huge deal if you’re a foodie!! On top of that they have a super budget friendly lunch special for the days you’d like a hot slice but not a whole pie! If you haven’t already-check these guys out!! Support small, local, family owned businesses for the Win!!!!!“

“I ordered a lrg pizza from luciana a week ago it was delicious and it was fast deleivery well cooked and hot pizza delicious and yummy pizza“

“Tonight I ordered food to go. Ravoli and a salad. One order was easily enough for four people. Delicious food and delivered promptly and hot. The salad was also delicious. I love Sopranos and highly recommend their food. Just have a group to share it with - huge portions.“

“Food selection, food quality, atmosphere, staff and pricing will surely make it a Fav among locals and visitors alike... Wow Good!“

“It is by far the best pizzeria we have ever tried in Seattle. My wife is from the south of Italy (born and raised) and pizza is a big deal in our house. Strega is a top quality spot, with great food and an awesome service. We are lucky to live close by! Totally recommend. Siete bravi, ragazzi!“

“Brought my family of ten in, and every dish we ordered was excellent. Even better, though, was the timing, professionalism, and warmth of our server. Hands down one of the best dining experiences I’ve had from a service standpoint—especially impressive given the size of our group.“

“This is the real deal! I'm from New England and miss real pizza. This is just like pizza from home! It's a bit expensive but a worthwhile treat. I did see a sign while leaving yesterday that said they do slices during certain times.“

“The pizza was great and the service was friendly!“

“Easily some of the best pizza in Kitsap! Super nice owners and the customer service is always fantastic. It's dine out onky currently but hear they might be opening a spot to dine in at some point!“

“Pizzeria 22 is an affordable treat. Our group ordered bruschetta, calzones, and a pizza. Each of us commented on how delicious the food was. The server was attentive and warm. I recommend Pizzeria 22 for anyone looking for a reasonable evening out in Seattle.“

“Note to self, don't get the wings, garlic and buffalo were slimy- no breading at all, no crispy skin. Hoping the air frier can make them better. We also only got one dipping sauce. Pizza is always good! Death by pizza is my favorite! Pizza was cut terrible haha. Worked out having a youngin who would eat the tiny piece.“

“Order 3 pizzas online this am to pick up at 11:45am for my husbands last day at work. They were a hit!! Not a piece left, thanks!!“

“Hey hi ooo uh hi r go ouo I vhi hi Gus“

“Order 3 pizzas online this am to pick up at 11:45am for my husbands last day at work. They were a hit!! Not a piece left, thanks!!“

“We bought a ½ and ½ BYO pizza. Pizza sauce on one half and Alfredo on the other half. Not every place will do that, do that's awesome. give amount of toppings. chicken layered 4 slices thick on the chicken bacon Alfredo side, whole cloves of roasted garlic, covered with bacon. perfectly cooked. simply awesome! We also ordered chicken Alfredo pasta and addedI bacon. It was great also. and also had a ton of chicken in it. probably 50/50 chicken to pasta ratio. the pasta came with a piece of garlic bread that was ok and a nice fresh side salad. We will definitely go back!“

“⸻

Domino’s Pizza Box Review: WHY DID YOU DO THIS

Okay listen. It’s literally midnight, I’m surviving off cold coffee and pure crust and I NEED to talk about Domino’s. The pizza? Amazing. The cheese? A gift. The garlic twist thingys? Yes absolutely. But the BOX?? Domino’s what have you done.

Why did you change the box from that awesome red + blue combo to just… BLUE. Who decided this??? Who walked into a meeting like “Well you know what would be really cool? Let’s make the pizza box look like a boring filing cabinet!!!!” Cause I just wanna talk. Outside. In the parking lot.

The red was IMPORTANT. It made the box look FUN. Like “Yay pizza time!!!” Now it’s just blue and it looks like it’s judging me for ordering extra cheese again. It looks like it should contain printer paper. It looks like a sad cereal box who lost its identity. It looks like it’s going to start giving me a lecture about being responsible with my money.

When I walk through the door holding that new box, no one cheers. No one gets excited. They’re like “Oh you brought…a…package?” NO. I BROUGHT PIZZA. RESPECT IT.

Also Domino’s literally built their whole personality on red AND blue. Now it’s like they forgot half of who they are. Like someone deleted their other personality and left them with the boring one. Bring back the spicy side!!! Bring back the red!!!

I’m emotional about this. I have memories with those boxes. Movie nights. Sleepovers. Times when pizza was my only happiness. And they changed it. WHY??? My nostalgia is crying into the crust.

Here’s the thing: Pizza is supposed to be dramatic. It’s supposed to scream PARTY. The blue box does not scream party. It whispers “I’m tired.” Same, but still. Let the BOX be EXCITED at least.

I’m still gonna eat Domino’s because obviously. I’m literally devouring it right now. But Domino’s please hear my midnight suffering: blue only = sad. red + blue = ICONIC.

Give us back our red. I’m begging you. Me and my coffee-powered brain and my cheesy fingers are begging you.

Okay that’s it I’m going to sleep goodnight“

“Just carried out my best Pizza Hut pizza of the year. My s’mores pie thing was awesome, too. A smidge pricey even with a coupon but over all I’m pretty satisfied.“

“Bartender is so friendly and nice! She provided great recommendations to my friends and I for drinks. She was funny and sincere and totally made our night out the best we’ve had in ages! Pizza was stellar, bartender was THE BEST, and the karaoke DJ was GREAT! This is the best place in Ballard for a night out. Totally reminds me of the 90s scene I miss so much from way back. Whoever puts together the playlists for Friday and Saturday nights is definitely speaking my language. Keep it up, Veras! You’ve got the food, the booze, the music, and the vibe down.“

“Always amazing service and food. Wonderful space and visit as much as we can!“